142

Descended From the Sun: Episode 15

There’s no such thing as a normal life when you’re in love with a soldier, and knowing that he could be called away at any moment doesn’t mitigate the pain every time it actually happens. It takes a certain kind of strength to watch the one you love walk away, knowing you may never see them again. But imagining the worst can’t even come close to the reality if it were to ever truly happen.

EPISODE 15 RECAP

Shi-jin waits for Mo-yeon to finish his discharge paperwork, posing prettily for her enjoyment. As she wheels him out to the car, he lets her listen to his headphones — which turns out to be a bootlegged recording of her cliff confession, HAHA.

Mo-yeon is so flustered that she lets go of his wheelchair and sends him careening down a hill, and he goes tumbling head over heels. Horrified, Mo-yeon goes running to see if there’s any damage… to the wheelchair. ~pfft~ Shi-jin notes that she’s still death to anything with wheels, and quips that she should avoid public transportation, for the safety of the citizens.

Dae-young takes Myung-joo out to eat, though he’s stonefaced and just sits staring as she eats voraciously. She finally tells him to say whatever it is he brought her here to say, but he says there’s nothing — he just thought she looked too thin (and in banmal, for the first time ever).

Confused, Myung-joo asks for clarification — did they break up, or just have an argument? Are they in the process of breaking up now? Straightforward as always, Dae-young says, “I’m in the process of going to Yoon Myung-joo.”

She asks if he really intends to just live his life as a simple worker, and Dae-young justifies that it means they’ll be together. Myung-joo doesn’t think he looks very happy about it, and she offers to break ties with her father so that they can be together and Dae-young can stay in the military.

Dae-young doesn’t like this idea, and he can see why her father would oppose him as a son-in-law. Myung-joo has the potential to become even a starred Colonel, and any father would want a man for her who also meets that potential. Myung-joo understands, but says that it makes her hate him.

Having fed her, Dae-young takes his leave. Unimpressed, Myung-joo tells him that next time, she expects an actual answer from him regarding whether or not they’re going to break up.

Meanwhile her father still has Dae-young’s military discharge request on his desk, and he glares at it unhappily.

Shi-jin texts Mo-yeon that night, and video calls her when she says she’s washing up for bed, hoping to get a peek, hee. She calls him a pervert and hangs up on him, only to have him ring her doorbell two seconds later, beer in hand and disappointed that she’s still dressed, heh.

Mo-yeon goes to shower and comes back to a room filled with candles, Shi-jin having remembered that she prefers to be lit by candlelight. Something jogs Mo-yeon’s memory and she asks Shi-jin how he rescued her from Argus that night in an Arab helicopter, but Shi-jin goes all twitchy and starts trying to distract her, whining about his sore arm (and getting the wrong arm, hee).

He fails, as usual, and Mo-yeon promises not to be angry if he tells the truth — so long as the truth isn’t that he used her business card for the favor. His guilty expression answers that, though he argues that he used it to save her life. Ha, did she really think she was going to get an oil field out of it instead??

Private Ki-bum is also back in Korea, and he runs into Team Alpha, who’ve come to cheer him on as he takes his high school equivalent test. Awwww. They even brought him taffy and magic PPL almonds, and Dae-young tells him that when in doubt, pick the third answer. HA. They send him off with a pat on the booty and lots of encouragement.

Suddenly all of their phones ring simultaneously… oh no. They head back to the base to prepare for a new mission, and Shi-jin notices that Dae-young is unusually subdued. Ki-bum comes to fetch him to Lieutenant General Yoon’s office, where he’s told that this will be a three-month-long mission, so he needs to decide now whether he’s going, or wants to be discharged effective immediately.

Dae-young doesn’t hesitate — he wants to go with his team, and Yoon seems relieved at his answer. After he’s home, he’ll process his discharge request. Dae-young knows that this means Yoon is accepting him as a son-in-law, and he promises to return safely. After he leaves the room, Lieutenant Genera Yoon rips up the discharge request — he has no intention of processing it.

Dae-young leaves his dog tags on Myung-joo’s doorknob, his way of letting her know that he’s leaving on a dangerous mission.

Chi-hoon finally figures out that the word his little friend had been saying when he said goodbye, wasn’t his name — he was asking for a goat. The doctors are more amused that Chi-hoon still doesn’t know the kid’s name, heh.

Shi-jin calls Mo-yeon outside to tell her that he’s being sent away on a long mission, looking all sheepish and adorably sorry. She tries not to cry but fails miserably, and Shi-jin gives her a big hug. She tells him not to get hurt and he promises not to die, and to come home to her. That worries me, since he’s never promised not to die before…

He starts to leave but Mo-yeon stops him for another hug, and they say that they’ll miss each other. As he drives away, something makes Mo-yeon recall Argus’s words: “Big Boss… he’s smart, funny, and mysterious, but he has a lot of secrets. He’ll disappear from time to time, be hard to contact. And then one day, he will never come back.”

Mo-yeon is tense and distracted until she hears from Shi-jin that he’s arrived safely. She texts him often after that, telling him about her days and how much she misses him. He can’t respond, but she keeps up a steady stream of communication.

When Shi-jin’s mission is over, there’s not enough room on the helicopter for everyone, so he sends his team back, he and Dae-young planning to catch the next ride. But as they wait, out of nowhere a bullet rips through Shi-jin’s chest and he goes down, and Dae-young struggles to pull him to safety and stop the bleeding.

Oh god, Shi-jin looks like he can’t breathe. His eyes start to go glassy, and he sees his old captain, the one who was taken down by a sniper shot right in Shi-jin’s arms. To his smiling friend, he says, “I will go.” No, don’t go!

Dae-young begs Shi-jin to stay awake, but it’s a losing battle. Dae-young is also shot, and Shi-jin slumps, his eyes closing. From the air Team Alpha scream in horror as they watch the area where Dae-young and Shi-jin took cover disintegrate in a fiery explosion.

Mo-yeon is growing frustrated by Shi-jin’s silence, and she meets with Myung-joo to drink herself silly. Myung-joo thinks she’s being unreasonable — if Shi-jin could contact her, he would. She’s just jealous because she’s spent more time broken up with Dae-young than actually dating him.

She tells Mo-yeon that this most recent fight isn’t just a fight, it’s a war, and one she intends to win. She’s feeling optimistic, since he left her his dog tags, which tells her that she’s got the upper hand. When he gets back, she plans to kidnap him for a vacation and work everything out.

Team Alpha salute Lieutenant General Yoon upon their arrival home, Shi-jin and Dae-young conspicuously missing. Snoopy reports that their mission was a success, though his voice falters as he says that they’ve not found the bodies of their missing comrades. It’s raining, but I have a feeling that everyone on that tarmac is crying.

Shi-jin’s father is summoned to Yoon’s office, where the set of dog tags on Yoon’s desk tell him all he needs to know. He loses the struggle to hold in his grief at the loss of his son, and Yoon salutes him respectfully.

Myung-joo is researching vacation spots when he spy comes to speak with her, and at first she gets excited, thinking that Dae-young is home. But he says in a quavering voice that he has a report, and Myung-joo’s face falls.

Snoopy goes to see Mo-yeon at the hospital, but the poor man can’t even look her in the eye. The scene flips back and forth between Myung-joo and Mo-yeon as they process the news that Shi-jin and Dae-young are dead, Myung-joo demanding he repeat himself, and Mo-yeon just descending into tearful confusion.

Mo-yeon is handed a letter, written by Shi-jin, in which he explains that they always write a will before they go on a dangerous mission. He apologizes for not keeping his promise to come back, to not hurt her, to not die while he’s gone. But he says that he was thankful to have met her, and that he loved her.

Myung-joo staggers to her father’s office, eyes red from unshed tears, and begs him to say it’s not true. He can’t, and he gives her Dae-young’s final letter, which she refuses to accept. If she reads it, then it means he’s really gone.

She turns her grief on her father, blaming him for Dae-young’s death, and for stealing the time they could have had together. Yoon, looking devastated himself, just tells her that these are the final words of a good soldier, and should be treasured. Again Myung-joo rejects them, and rips them angrily out of his hands.

Mo-yeon goes rushing to the military headquarters, but she’s stopped by the sound of Myung-joo’s sobbing. She gets angry at Myung-joo — if she loses her composure, what’s Mo-yeon to do? She demands that Myung-joo tell her this is a mistake, but when she sees a letter identical to the one from Shi-jin in Myung-joo’s hand, the truth finally sinks in. They’re really gone.

She asks Myung-joo if this means that she’s truly never going to see Shi-jin again, and Myung-joo can only nod. Mo-yeon’s legs go out from under her, and she finally cries, both women giving in to their sorrow together.

Lieutenant Park visits Mo-yeon to tell her that there will be an announcement of Shi-jin’s and Dae-young’s deaths. The official story will be that they died in a car accident during training, and he has her sign a confidentiality oath for her protection.

Calm, with only a tear betraying her emotions, Mo-yeon asks if Shi-jin’s death saved a life. Lieutenant says proudly that it did, and that he protected peace and died for his country. Mo-yeon can’t understand, then, why his death has to be kept a secret, and she asks Park why they choose this kind of life.

Life goes on, and Mo-yeon throws herself into her work. It pays off and she’s promoted, which sparks a fit of jealousy from snooty Dr. Kim. She approaches Mo-yeon to convince her to change a patient’s medication to a more expensive one, spitting at her to go volunteer again if she’s not willing to play nice with other doctors. This time Mo-yeon just neatly puts her in her place without losing her own temper.

Ji-soo is worried that Mo-yeon will work herself into the ground, urging her to go home and rest occasionally. But even this little break lets Mo-yeon remember Shi-jin, and she tears up even as she laughs that she’s going crazy.

Myung-joo is preparing to go back to Uruk, which we learn was a request that her father granted. Lieutenant General Yoon admits that he still feels badly about letting Dae-young go on that final mission, and that he worries about her.

Myung-joo meets with Mo-yeon to say goodbye (and aww, they have Dae-young’s and Shi-jin’s stuffed animal friends with them), and Mo-yeon expresses envy that she’s going back. Myung-joo has three days, so she suggests they do Dae-young and Shi-jin’s “three days no nights” drinking binge before she goes.

Mo-yeon agrees, and she asks Myung-joo how Shi-jin and Dae-young became as close as they were. Myung-joo says that they met over a woman, and we see in flashback that Shi-jin had jumped under Dae-young’s umbrella on a rainy day.

Knowing that Shi-jin was here because Myung-joo’s father hoped they would marry, Dae-young had awkwardly blurted out that he and Myung-joo were dating. Shi-jin had interrogated him about their relationship, and Dae-young had been so nervous he’d gotten his made-up facts all mixed-up (such as saying they’d been dating for a year, but only met a month ago, hee). Shi-jin had assured him that they wouldn’t be fighting over Myung-joo, suggesting that instead, they only fight on the same side.

Mo-yeon wanders past the coffee shop where she and Shi-jin once had a conversation about saying “I love you.” He’d noted that they never said it, but she countered that they said it with actions, not words. Shi-jin had told her to say it first since her name comes first alphabetically, but she’d just said that the person who wants to hear it more should go first.

Shi-jin tried “ladies first” on her, then age rank (she’s older), and when Mo-yeon got all riled up, he’d blurted out, “I love you!” Mollified, Mo-yeon had responded that she loved him too. They’re too cute for words.

Mo-yeon takes Shi-jin’s stuffed comrade to her place and lights a candle, and hears Shi-jin’s voice telling her that she’s beautiful. She sees him sitting on her couch and says she missed him, and asks why he didn’t come back. “Because I was working for peace.”

She asks if his promises to her meant nothing, and he says softly that he intended with all his heart to come back to her. Mo-yeon dissolves into tears as she says, “But you didn’t come back. You didn’t come,” and she’s only talking to the stuffed animal.

Myung-joo arrives in Uruk, carrying the letter from Dae-young which she still hasn’t read. She vows never to read it, and tells Dae-young’s spirit to be annoyed about it.

Mo-yeon is at the airport when she gets a call from Daniel, who is literally camping in a hallway because he’s forbidden to enter the country. Heh. She tells him that she’s going to volunteer for the Albanian refugee camp, though she has an ulterior motive. Tomorrow is the anniversary of Shi-jin’s death, and she wants to visit the place where he died.

Mo-yeon is still texting about her daily life to Shi-jin, and she tells him about meeting Daniel at the airport. She’s heard that there’s a desert where she is, and wonders if there’s an oasis. She says that she’s become the kind of doctor who believes that life is more important than profit, and asks if Shi-jin is proud of her.

Ki-bum is also in Uruk again, though he’s no longer a private — now he’s a Sergeant, and the commanding officer. I’m so proud! He makes Myung-joo some ramyun and admits that he did this with Dae-young often, then notices that it’s snowing outside, a rare event in Uruk.

Mo-yeon finds the desert and goes out with flowers, tying back her hair and remembering a time when Shi-jin did it for her. She finds a place that seems filled with memorials, stones piled up in small towers, and places her flowers for Shi-jin on top of one. She recalls Shi-jin’s promises not to get killed and tears up, calling him a liar.

Her walkie-talkie crackles to life with a request to bring back some medicine, and Mo-yeon pulls herself together enough to answer. She tries to put her white stone from the beach in Uruk on the stone tower, but it keeps getting blown off by the wind. Her walkie-talkie fires up again, and she hears the voice of a ghost: “Big Boss transmitting.”

She drops it in shock, wondering if she’s really hearing things now. She checks her phone and sees her text messages suddenly registering as “read” one by one, and again she hears “Big Boss transmitting” from her walkie-talkie. But this time the voice continues, “Beauty. Turn around.”

She does, and for a long moment she sees nothing but sand. And then, over the crest of a dune, comes Shi-jin. Holy crap, he’s alive.

Repeating over and over, “It can’t be. It can’t be,” Mo-yeon tries to run to him. But her knees give way, and she collapses to the sand. Shi-jin runs the rest of the way to help her stand — he’s filthy and scarred, but he’s alive.

Mo-yeon asks in a disbelieving voice if he’s been alive this whole time, and Shi-jin just says that he somehow keeps overcoming these difficulties. He pulls her into a hug, as she repeats, as if to convince herself, “You were alive. You were alive.”

With tears streaming down his face, Shi-jin can only say he’s sorry, over and over.

COMMENTS

A year — a whole year! Where the hell has Shi-jin been?? Why hasn’t he contacted anyone? I’m dying to hear what happened to him, how he survived that gunshot and explosion, and what he’s been doing for an entire year while everyone thought he was dead. I could rant about it, but I’ll wait to hear what he has to say for himself before I blast him. And all I can say is, Dae-young had better also be alive ~shakes fist at Show~

Unfortunately, because the show has a habit of putting our leads in life-threatening situations from which they literally bounce right back up over and over, once again it undermined its own emotional moment when we were supposed to think that Shi-jin (and probably-but-better-not-be Dae-young) died in that explosion. Which is a terrible shame, because imagine the emotional impact that scene could have delivered if we’d been built up for fourteen episodes that Shi-jin could die at any moment, yet he hadn’t ever actually looked death in the face and skipped away easily, much less multiple times. With that tension building throughout the course of the show, that scene could have been a huge emotionally climactic moment for the viewers — but because I’ve seen Shi-jin nearly die and cheat death so many times already, when he went unconscious and the area went up in flames, all I thought was that well, he’ll show up again like he always does. It’s a damn shame, because I did truly want to fear for his life at some point, the show was telling us to fear for his life, but the execution just made his death-defying tricks much too common for me to actually believe he was dead.

That said, it’s a credit to the show that I still felt the pain and loss of those who loved them keenly. Shi-jin’s father didn’t say a single word when he learned that his son died, but he had me sobbing. Myung-joo’s and Mo-yeon’s reactions were gut-wrenching and so true to character, with Myung-joo defaulting to anger while Mo-yeon struggles to deny the truth as long as she could. And I loved that we got to see the grief of Team Alpha as they were burdened with telling Myung-joo and Mo-yeon, because it’s clear that they loved their leaders every bit as much as the women did.

And that’s really what saves the show, I think, from itself — though it’s flawed in a lot of ways, and outright unbelievable in others, when it comes down to it the characters and their emotioanl journey are why we’ve all stuck with it through to the end. If the characters weren’t so well-written and perfectly cast, I don’t think Descended would be nearly as successful as it’s been. Jin Gu and Kim Ji-won have long been actors that I’ve liked, but never particularly taken notice of, but this drama has catapulted both of them to a level well above anything I’ve seen them reach before. Song Hye-gyo has given us a character that’s spunky and flawed in all the best ways, making us want to see her grow and change, yet stay true to herself. And let’s not forget the incredible magnetic powerhouse of Song Joong-ki — the man has proven that he’s not lost one bit of talent while doing his military stint, and in fact seems to have gained a gravitas that grounds his boyish good looks and gives his (always great) acting a maturity it didn’t have before. I’ve been a fan of his for years, but he’s truly proving that he’s a force to be reckoned with when it comes to creating unique, charismatic characters. I can’t wait to see what he does next.

RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , , , ,

142

Required fields are marked *

SHK owned everyone in this episode. If homegirl doesn't get any awards for this show I'm gonna stir up a storm.

0
28
reply

Required fields are marked *

+100
She really was amazing in this episode.

0
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

+1million

SHK is fabulous. And every bit as good as SJK , if not better

0
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

@ Piggy, I totally agree with your comment. In some of the scenes, I have actually found SHK's performance to be better as well.

@ LollyPip, I always appreciate reading your thoughts on dramas, and I particularly liked how you expressed the emotional impact some of us could have felt after hearing that YSJ had disappeared. I related to what you wrote about that, as I didn't feel anything when I found out the first time that YSJ and SDY were missing (or dead). The 2nd time around, with the subs, I was really moved by everyone's acting and reactions. Lt Park closed his eyes, and the man on the right of Daddy Yoon had a hard time swallowing. I also felt that the rain added some dramatic effect. I wonder if it was really raining that day.

I also agree with you that the characters, and how they are portrayed by the different actors are what has made me feel attached to this show. I was so happy for instance to see KKB back on my screen, surrounded by the Alpha Team that I squealed. Like you, I was really touched to see how the military men (all of them) care about each other. And yes, JG and KJW have been doing extremely well in this drama, and their chemistry is excellent and very strong.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

She's much better than him, at least in this role.

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

"... in this role", how are they both even comparable?

0

What I mean is that they are incomparable.

0

I think he's done better work, but SJ is not a deep character. He's charming, but there's really not a lot for SJK to work with. So far, SHK has been given all the heavy lifting and character development in the drama.

I can compare them because they are both leads of DoTS?

0

Lol no... One is playing the role of a soldier, while the other is playing the role of a doctor. You can't say in this role because they are playing two different roles.

0

Yep. I think she's owning the whole show really, but this episode especially.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree, she hit every note in an excellent manner in this ep. Her acting was flawless in everything. I loved how subtle she was at times, like for example, the way she looked at SJ when he was complaining about his arm hurting him, and she told him that he was complaining about the wrong arm. I loved what she did with her face at that moment. She can be quite subtle at times.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I feel so drained. Ugly cries for 20min non stop,

Subconsciously i know he's still alive but what if im wrong?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Song Hye-kyo is Queen.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh she will surely get an award, SJK too. Because there is no way that KBS won't appreciate them for giving the station best rating in years.

Not saying that they don't act well though, because they definitely do. Which is why we're sticking to this show despite all the flaws.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

About this, "Not saying that they don’t act well though, because they definitely do. Which is why we’re sticking to this show despite all the flaws."
I totally agree! I have stuck to this show in great part because of the great acting, in spite of its flaws.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Can we dare hope for double daesangs, 1 each? Hehe! They both deserve it, for making DotS the drama that it is now :)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Her emotional crying scenes were sooo good. And not only that, like Ivoire mentioned, I'm a fan of her often subtle portrayal. It feels real and mature.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

@ Kit,

YES!!!!!! Her emotional crying scenes were simply excellent! You know, I have learned that watching actors/actresses when the camera is not directly on them, tells you a lot about their acting, and about how seriously they take it. So I have been paying attention to that. I think it also helps how they are directed.

I also find that subtlety is not easy to do when acting, because you don't want to over do it, and you don't want to be so subtle that the audience or viewers do not notice what you did. So I always admire those who do it well, and she has.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes! I agree. I, too, have the habit of looking at the actors' expressions when they're out of the camera's focus just to see how their faces hold up. I am curious though as to what some actors are like in real life because I want to know if the expressions and nuances they show on camera are part of their acting or just how they really are like in real life. Can you think of an actress/actor off the top of your head who always shows completely different mannerisms and nuances in different roles? I haven't paid that much attention to tell.

Lately SHK always has that subtle aura in her roles so maybe that's just how she's like in person. Maybe we're just giving her too much credit for her subtle portrayal when in reality she hasn't given it much thought and is just doing what comes natural to her? And someone like Hwang Jung Eum is always overly animated in her roles because the actress herself is like that in real life? Haha. I'm just rambling on here. Probably because I haven't had much sleep, lol. But not saying anything negative against SHK here. I actually like her subtlety, which I find she always gets criticized for as it makes her seem more cold and distant. I don't have any issues with it because I have friends who are the same way and are really nice and warm people despite the resting bitch face and aversion to touchy feely gestures. Haha!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

+10000000
I knew Si Jin can't be dead, yet I was crying my eyes out throughout this episode and that is only thanks to SHK's stellar acting. And how the heck can someone look so ethereal beautiful while crying, life's not fair. lol

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Agreeeee!!! Goddess, beauty and acting.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This. Totally KNEW he couldn't be dead, totally sobbed through it all the same. And then I was haunted by the thought...what if the show went there? What if they really went there? Agonising.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Tbh, I was worried the last episode would just be SJ flashbacks and maybe showing what happened to him when he died. So, yeah I knew he wouldn't die for real, but there was always some doubt. And seriously SHK sold it so well.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

i feel like she's the prettiest when crying actually- the way tears pool in her eyes is just so mesmerizing

while mine just look swollen and red and watery- where is the justice in this world, i ask you /sigh

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I share the same sentiments. I thought that they couldn't really kill off the lead guys but man was I just bawling my eyes out every single time she teared up. Even her hinting at things like "wine, water.." etc, it made me sob! lol!

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Me too, really love the crying scene. And also the music background really fit and capture the moment

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I actually added Ellie Goulding's How Long Will I Love You to my DotS playlist haha! That song really fit the scene where she was was at home imagining SJ holding the doll. Broke my heart and the song's lyrics fit her perfectly.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

That was my favorite/saddest scene to me. Her feelings for him took over so much of her life, and she can't even think of a hair tie without remembering him. It was just so sad. And so real, because I've lost people in the past and the strangest things will make me remember them and cry.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Same!! Sometimes I'm driving and I remember the most random thing about a loved one who's passed away and the tears just start streaming down my face. It was wonderful how she portrayed the sense of grief and loss.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I really loved that scene in her house - I thought it was going to be something silly with the stuffed animal but was really touched. Honestly the plot is a bit ridiculous at this point and the realism is just non-existent but somehow it's just still hitting all the right buttons for me. Half of my brain is pointing out all the stupid things that don't make sense while the other half is sobbing away...this drama is making me feel a bit crazy.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree with you. The plot IS ridiculous at times, and the realism is non existent. I do feel the very good acting by all really does carry this drama. It is what has made me care about the characters all along. The earnestness (if I can use that as a word) is felt, and I love how in character the actors and actresses stay, even when the camera is not on them specifically.

I too loved that scene at her house. It was as if she knew what YSJ would have told her, because she knew his heart. I loved the "simplicity" of the scene as well.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I loved that scene as well. Cried through it. Until we got to the end of the scene when we see that she'd imagined Shi Jin and I noticed that the stuffed bear had miraculously moved from the place it was on the floor all the way to the couch where imaginary Shi Jin has placed it during the conversation.
Seeing that made me hope that that was what happened in the mission. That the bear had miraculously appeared at the scene to move Shi Jin and Dae Young before the explosion.
Of course that would mean it's a whole different drama altogether but nothing says that the land they were on was not sacred ground and they hadn't been saved by the spirit of Brother Bear. A girl can hope after all.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

WOW!!!!! I love your imagination:-) And yes, a girl can dream :-)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you for the recap! I watched this ep. 3 times, the 1st time watching it raw. When SJ and DY disappeared, and seemed to not be coming back, I didn’t feel connected and engaged with the characters emotions, though I thought that the acting was very good. So when it looked like SJ and DY were not coming back, I felt OK with that outcome, though I found it hard to believe that (at least) SJ would be taken out of the show in the 15 ep., not being there till the end. One of the writers, KES, has never killed her male lead, or taken him out of the drama. I didn’t really see why it would be different here. So when SJ finally showed up, I was not very surprised, and I was not very moved, though again I thought the acting was quite good by both actors. I felt that having somewhat experienced SJ’s “death” in ep.14 had somewhat numbed me being surprised about SJ being able to be alive, and being able to return.

Watching the ep. with subs helped me feel more engaged, though I would say that both times, I felt that the audience’s emotions had been manipulated. I look forward to ep. 16 to find out what had happened to SJ and DY. So this ep. also felt like a filler ep. for me, things that needed to happen until we would get to the last ep. Some things felt repetitive, like the song and dance DY and MJ have been doing. I did appreciate the fact that this episode was basically about MY and MJ, and I was impressed by how well SHK and KJW portrayed them. The emotions felt raw, I just wished that I didn’t feel that I had been manipulated to (want to) feel a certain way about the characters. On a shallow note, SJK looked very good when he appeared: buffed, tanned (or was that dirt?) and smexy, with his clothes matching.

There are other details I appreciated, such as how loved and appreciated SJ and DY were by their fellow soldiers and superiors. I loved seeing how Lt Park (or is he a Col?), Daddy Yoon and the other superior who was standing with them in the rain were struck with sadness and pain. Each portrayed that emotion differently, yet really well. I was a little surprised about Lt. Park, as he had come across as someone who mostly barked orders, and was mostly interested in advancing professionally. It was nice to see that deep down, he actually cared about his men. I guess that must be how most military men are.

I was also very happy to see KKB back, I had missed seeing puppy. I really loved that the Alpha Team went to show him support and encourage him, on his exam day, like other family members did for other people. And yes, that was another opportunity (among many in this ep.) to show some PPL, I know. I also loved the scene with LCH, and Blekie. It reminded me of the time when LCH forgot his couple ring in his gown, he was still someone who figured out things after they had happened. I also did enjoy the scenes between MY and SJ, and how she tried to keep him informed of the mundane things in her life.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeah, taking out SJ an episode before the finale really wouldn't make sense. I never felt he was really dead either; despite the fact that all the actors and -tresses acted out the grief really well, I just never connected with it, because I never believed he actually died. Of course, she could just be hallucinating, considering all the many unbelievable things about that reunion scene, but that doesn't seem to be the case.

"On a shallow note, SJK looked very good when he appeared: buffed, tanned (or was that dirt?) and smexy, with his clothes matching."
HAHAHAHA! Love this comment! Am I the only one who wondered at why he was all dirty and had either very red scars or some bloody scrapes, when it's been a year? I mean, did he just spend the year on Urk fighting and didn't have time to wash before seeing his girlfriend again after so long? And HOW did he find her there, in the middle of nowhere? Like, that *exact* spot? Did he track her phone? That scene was just all kinds of ridiculous and cheesy, it literally made me laugh. Which is of course always nice, but I'll take a wild guess and say that's probably not the emotion they aimed for ;)

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh wait. MY wasn't in Urk.. So, Albania, then. Doesn't change the fact that I just don't get why he'd be alive, report he's alive and then take a plane to where she is, without washing up first ha! Guess a little dirt makes the moment more dramatic?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I cried a lot because of this episode but i trust the writers that its gonna be a happy ending ...
Im not really a fan of song hye kyo before but now i am definitely one :)
And for song joong ki, im already a fan before but now i love him even more <3
Thanks for the recap! #DOTSfinale

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This was the most disjointed and bizarre episode ! Did the producers switch the sequence to counter all the spoilers released ?

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

No? This drama was done ages ago and there are no valid spoilers out there for anything.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeah, i felt like the earlier episodes were better in terms of plot. They seemed to have put more effort in the episodes until 12, then from 13 onwards, the loopholes became glaringly evident. 12 would have been a nice ending. Still a fan, though.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I feel like they were on a time crunch even though it's pre produced. Keep in mind China needs a month or more to approve the drama. Also this project was overtime and budget. They didn't know if it was going to be a hit so KBS probably was hurrying them up. the premiere date was already changed a few times so if they didn't air now, they might have needed to wait for another drama to air, making their investment a very risky one.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

SHK seriously killed it this episode. Nobody does crying scenes better and more beautifully than her. MY in general continues to be the best part of the drama, but this episode really took it to another level.

They didn't find any bodies, so I knew they weren't dead...but even so you can just feel just seriously FEEL the pain of losing SJ. I felt especially bad for her because she's really come so far in accepting being a solider's girlfriend and supports him 100%. It's such a hard life for her to love him, but she does it just the same and is proud to do so.

I really loved how Myung-joo and Mo-yeon leaned on each other and become such good friends. I really love the idea of their bond together, and how they'll probably be each other's support system through the years dealing with these two. I loved how the two women tried to move on in their own ways, and how they were there for each other. Really wonderful to see.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

yesss... agree with you Lemondoodle..
SHK really killed this episoed..
i found myself crying with YMJ & KMY... i can feel how they feel..
because the body not found, we can assume that they are not dead..
but honestly, in a dangerous mission, even if the body not found, the military will assume that soldiers is die.

so of course it will be hard for these women to accept the reality that the man they loved are dead.. since there is no body to be grief.. no body to be buried..

that's why it even make it harder to move on..

but i also love how KMY & YMJ give each other shoulder to cry on.. being each other comfort.. soo touching..

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

YooShiJin, maybe, is the real Kal-El brother...

Now, the finale is already on air. And i feel to accept the penultimate (episode 15) and the finale (16) just like that for the sake of this show victory! Yeeeaaaayyyy....

When i saw this episode yesterday, i was like 'Please dont bring him back alive!' for the sake of human being *LoL* and then here comes last 2 minutes "Big Boss transmitting..." and my jaw dropped. I was like, are you kidding me????
And ffter those last 2 minutes with no preview for episode 16, i was calming myself with that fact that.. maybe.. just maybe.. YooShiJin, maybe, is the real Kal-El brother...

*saranghae Song-Song couple*

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hi, what is a "Ka-El brother?"

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think kdoramafan means brother of Superman, whose name in Krypton was Kal-el.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ka el is superman's birth name

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh I see, thank you guys!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The fuck! I cried buckets for an hour, grieving with Mo-yeon and Myung-joo! But okay, I am just relieved that Shi-jin is so alive while I was about to resent this drama. The writer sure knows how to torment an audience, good grief!

Thanks for the recap!!!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

SORTA KINDA SPOILERS FOR 15/16 HERE. YOU'VE BEEN WARNED.

This show went off the rails hard in this episode. The characters have fallen into serious ruts of repetitive bickering (SDY/YMJ) and joking (YSJ/KMY) on a personal level. Nothing in this or the other Seoul episodes progresses characters in any way.

Then, wham, we have bad editing so you can't tell what's flashback, what's hallucination, and what's the real storyline without squinting at your screen hard. No idea why the director couldn't fix that with pre-production process.

Finally, after throwing a kitchen sink plot at us (literally, we've now checked every crisis box you can think of for warzone/doctors without borders), the writer and director decide it's time to unorganically emotionally manipulate the viewers by contorting the plot to "kill" main characters. It's just sloppy, lazy writing (which, spoilers for 16, the final scene acknowledges in tongue in cheek fashion). The last two episodes make this whole thing feel like amateur hour.

The actors and the cinematography are the only things making this show enjoyable. That's a credit to SJK/SHK/JG/KYJ. They're all performed exceedingly well and deserve kudos for that, but they can't rescue the horrendously structured script.

0
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

I had so many feelings about this episode, and your post is basically all of them.

Even though I knew they wouldn't let Yoo Si Jin die in the second-to-last episode, I was really hoping they would. I loved Song Hye Gyo's acting post-fake death. Plus, I thought it'd be really challenging to air an entire episode without "new" Yoo Si Jin scenes, so I wanted the producers and writers to have risen to the challenge. They did not. They did the easy thing. They just brought a dude we knew they couldn't kill [in episode 15!] back to life.

And I don't wanna get into ep. 16 that much, but they don't even do anything with him. The rest of this show is nothing happening, and that final scene actually made me angry. There were no more emotional stakes for us in this going in.

I kept thinking that maybe if they hadn't (1) knocked Yoo Si Jin out in the earthquake, (2) shot him in the parking garage, and (3) stopped his heart at the hospital, I might have cared when they shot him again then blew him up. Instead I rolled my eyes, because this drama taught me that none of the dangerous work they do has any lasting consequences, either physically or mentally.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I spent the entire time watching 15/16 just pissed off at the blatant yank on our emotions. The writing and the structure of the story was just so bad. There could have been good work to explore there if they had dropped half the nonsensical crud and taken the time to tease out the ideas and actually make an arc to this story. But it was just a check the box of plot points without any of the connective tissue and consideration of the consequences, as you say, to really hold them together into a meaningful arc.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Assuming they had to rush things in order to submit it to Chinese authorities, why couldn't they fix the korean version later. Did no one on the production team see that the plot just dropped off a cliff after their return from urk? While I'm thankful there were no forced separations for the main couple ( all through out this drama, the makjang stuff was left for the second couple), the rinse and repeat of shi jin dying and bouncing back effortlessly dulled the emotional impact of the last 4 episodes. I wish he had some weakness, any weakness.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

THIS. I agree with everything you said. I honestly could not get into this episode, because I already knew that SJ would no doubt be alive. The whole episode felt contrived and forced, and I felt like as a viewer I was being manipulated(horribly) into feeling sad for the fake death. It is truly a testament to the chemistry between the leads that I'm still watching. I don't even think it's the characters that keep me watching, because I don't feel like the show has really shown any significant growth for any of them. It's literally SJK and SHG that keep me coming back.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

final episode was full of plot holes and lazy writing. My love for this drama ended when they were back in Seoul. There were so much more they could have developed on how and why YSJ was alive. Good thing that the actors carried the show

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I feel you!

But I actually like the final episode. It has flaws but it is still sweet like candy.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

i'm literally crying watching this episode.. i watched it more than 5 times..Sooooo saaaddd...
just put away the silly thing in this drama and enjoy the drama..
this drama deserves an award! ahahhaha...

i love KMY & YSJ..they are so cute together.. Joong Ki, hyekyo. jiwon, jingoo, they have a very good chemistry..
all the characters are bring out alright! it's exactly the same feeling when i watch master's sun, with So Ji Sub and Gong Hyo Jin,.. good chemistry.. hahahahaha..

SDY & YMJ, hopefully you are also have a happy ending..hahahahhaa...

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Plot-wise...I feel the writer could do much better than fake-death trope. Death at the second-last episode? No one will buy that. The only good thing is this episode show how much KMY and YMJ dealt with their grief. I cried buckets for them.
My deepest sympathy for those who have lost family member in their duties.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The stupid previews after ep14 had some scenes that weren't in ep 15... So I was like... Shi-jin has to come back alive so they can go camping!! Lol

On a funny note, I was asking a friend of mine if she was caught up on DoTS and had seen ep 15 yet? She goes "wait it didn't end after ep 12?"
She genuinely thought the show ended at ep 12!

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

ahhahahahahaa...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well, they did throw in scenes where MY imagined SJ or remembered the past...so I guess she could be in deeep denial next week too.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

LMAO! I didn't notice that part in the preview. Nice catch.

I wish I could think the show ended at ep.12 too lol.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I've come to the following conclusions on watching this show:

1. You have to turn your brain off, trying to make sense of logical and continuity holes in the plot hurts too much.

2. Shi-jin is actually a vampire, that's how he survived capture after getting shot and being blown up? He's already shown once he doesn't need surgery after getting shot.

No don't question me about how the "sun" thing works if he's a vampire, I already turned my brain off.

3. OHH NO WAIT SO THAT'S WHAT HIS CALL SIGN MEANS - he's the big boss at the end of every game level - hard to kill! Geez I didn't realise he was a geek on top of everything

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh man the inner geek in me loved your last comment about the Boss monster at the end of each level.

I wonder how the writers came up with the code names? Big Boss/Wolf/Piccolo/Harry Potter/Snoopy...

I must say the Snoopy one made me laugh a little because he always looks so stoic and unmoving... unlike Snoopy the dog...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

+1000000
i love your comment.. LOL

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

SHK really shone in this episode. She's just such a great actress. Not over the top even in her crying. I thought KJW also performed well, especially when she confronted her dad. Just right before she snatched the paper from him, she gave this cry that was too real you could just feel the sadness in her.

The plot isn't well developed from ep 12 onwards, i think. After the Urk scenes, things just got a little messy in the writing department. I still love the show, but I agree with you, I wished the writers thought of better plots when they were back in Korea. The cliffhanger and the fear of YSJ dying, well, it came a little too soon with this episode. I would have wanted him to show up on the last episode so we do feel the absence. I mean, it's a year, yes, but it all happened in this episode. Anyway, that's just me.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Loved this episode, cried buckets. I'm not worried about the inconsistencies, illogic, or impossible things that happened. It's the best thing I've watched in a long, long time, so I'm going to enjoy it as much as I can.

I enjoyed the couple moments - especially when YSJ, man of no fear and no pain, pretends to be afraid and be hurting. Hah. Their flirting was so cute (although I think something was lost in translation - may need to wait for Dramafever's KBS official subs rather than Viki's volunteer subs).

After the boys were killed, it was amazing to watch the girlfriends get on with their lives. They were busy, but so alone emotionally. They still missed the boys amazingly, but they did their job, worked hard, and became the persons they wanted to be. I was impressed that KMY returned to living in the OR, climbing back up to her position, yet being so self-confident in herself that she didn't let others' antagonism get to her. She has an inner zen now, from experiencing Urk and YSJ's death, she knows what's important. It would have been nice if she had met YSJ's dad.

The part with Private Kim writing his exam (and not having family attend, sniff), the stuffed animals, the girlfriends drinking 3 nights and 3 days together, Daniel showing up again, KMY going to volunteer again, Private Kim being in command and making ramen, were great. I liked the brief glimpse of Onew's wife pushing the gurney on the hospital roof, showing that she was back in action.

I was confused, though. MYJ went to Albany because it was a good place to volunteer, or because it was where he died? Different subtitles/review say differently.

It was so apt that she ran and tripped and ran and fell while he gracefully ran to her. She's very clumsy and geeky, and he's very athletic.

I was surprised that they never showed KMY with her mom again, surely she'd be a source of comfort?

Anyway, I loved this episode, as I've loved each one. I'll have to binge watch the entire series once it's on drama fever with the better subtitles.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Agreed with all your favorite scenes! ?
And most importantly about how the ladies continued on with their lives and were competent doctors eventhough they are grieving. Compared to heirs and secret garden, female characters in this drama are strong, competent women and I like that.

Even minor characters like the head nurse and yehwa (Even Josip) are not just wallflowers, they are also good in what they do and are not damsels in distress

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

i always love a strong woman character.
ahhahaa.. like in SFD.. hahahah

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I watch these episode in 2 o'clock in the morning. haven't sleep at all and bawling my eyes out. first I said to myself they wont make me cry but it start with SJ's dad silent cry and MY and MJ oh my god. SHK really nailed it this time again. when lots of people doubt her for this role opposite SJK I always siding her, rotting her and here she proved it that she just not all beauty.
I long get rid my brain watching this drama due to that silly medic plot, war plot, nearly death and Resurrection on our captain so I just enjoy the romance and comedy and boy that is the gem of this show.

waiting for final recap..

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The scene of Shi jins dad really got me tears nothing but ugly tears for me ?????

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My favorite moment of all was that hug at the hospital. The way Mo yeon tried not to cry, and then when YSJ was about to leave, the way she said, 'hold on / wait' and went in for another hug --it's all too adorable. That feeling that you won't see your boyfriend in a long time, she perfectly encapsulates it in this scene. Even the way YSJ looked at her when he said he was going to be gone for three months, he expected her to be upset, and right he was. He goes in to hug/comfort her, and that's it right there --their relationship where they choose to understand how the other is feeling. It's all too adorable :)

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

So well said...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

- Oh man, oh man... the acting in this show...
- Them feels when the guys all turned up to wish Ki-bum good luck. BROS FOR LYFE.
- I liked how MY signed that non-disclosure agreement calmly, even though tears were rolling down her cheeks; it was a type of maturity that I feel she developed throughout the show
- I tried my hardest not to bawl because I had a face mask on... bad idea to do that while watching DotS, really
- The precious few minutes of happy, cutesy scenes at the start were just adorable, really.
- "We've been dating for a year. I met her a month ago"; Daeyoung, you precious precious thing LOL.

- By the way, I have this question but are those almonds a sponsor or something? I keep seeing them popping up in shows that I watch... and the placement of those almonds are pretty obvious too

I just can't wait to finish Episode 16, but I have mixed feelings because after that, no more DotS. How will I live?

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I didn't know who Mo Yeon wanted to be at the beginning of this show but I sure know who she is now. Hats off to SHK.

I also really love when this show slips in something serious and meaningful like Daniel's fight against drugmakers' profiteering on inoculations and medicines.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

this drama is so amazing, i can't move on to another drama because i keep watching this one again and again, SHK is great actress as well as SJK,
the most touching part is where dr kang imagining yoo's presence in her house, and the chat they had.awesome

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This show must have really made me check logic out the door because even when I know it doesn't make sense anymore, i still care for the characters especially shi Jin! While I still need an explanation how he is still alive, I'm just so relieved tha he is (and hopefully dae young too)

Major props to the actors playing ysj's dad, MJ And MY, I felt their pain and they sold me those sorrowful scenes even when at the back of my head I know there is no way they'll kill SJ.

I'm going to miss this (flawed but nevertheless addicting) show

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I just cried and cried on the latter part of the episode. The plot seems a bit unrealistic but the feelings, oh my gosh, the emotions is just so raw.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Honestly, I laughed so hard when Shi jin walked in the desert. I was not crying at all. I am so done with all the Shi jin immortality. The logic is: no body = not die.

How come Shi jin handphone survived from the war?

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

the same way MY's phone survived a dunk in the ocean apparently.

Magic ;)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well, I was kinda emotionally drained at the end of this episode. All I could think when I saw him cresting and coming down the hill was " RICKY, YOU GOT SOME 'SPLAINING TO DO!"

Why oh why, when they were saying Goodbye, in front of the Hospital, for three months DID THEY NOT KISS???? Normal people would have KISSED, SCREW RULES AGAINST PDA. Geeez...there were too many "inappropriate" chaste moments.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

omg I was upset that they didn't kiss too!!! I'm like cmon man, you guys hang out at her apartment alone at night and you won't even make out before saying goodbye?!?! inappropriate chaste moments indeed.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Nevermind the plot holes. Song Joong Ki is sure hot when he appears in the desert. Just 1 more ep left.

0
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

Lol!!!!! But I thought the same thing, when I saw him coming down towards KMY. His skin was tanned, he looked buffed, his clothes were coordinated, and he probably smelled good? :-) He did look hot!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ommo...you can smell him too? Why can't I....? ??

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes! Haha!! Even in seemingly "tattered" clothes and dirt and grime, he looked really hot!!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

he totally rocked the shabby chic concept lol
the man looks good in anything (or nothing at all!) srsly

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Don't forget the matching scraf. Ulalalaa he styled himself really well after got shot.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeah that scarf got my attention, LOL! I kept wondering where he got that... Did you guys noticed that his shirt had holes? But yeah, he was rocking that outfit.

Feels weird to me now, seeing him in interviews, less bulky/built, and with his skin not being tanned any more. He also looks thinner now, than in that last scene. And he looks much younger now than in that scene. I feel like, "was SJK ever YSJ at some point?" I know he was, but still...

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

In my view, Song Jongki in real life always has the pretty boy aura. But then in the screen he transforms into a manly man. I dont know how that works.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Plot-wise this is just getting more and more ridiculous as the show goes on. I wish they had come up with better ideas after episode 12. Oh man, just imagining what could have been...

Anyway, despite not believing that any of the two guys could be dead, I still ended up crying this episode because of how good SHK and KJW were in expressing their characters' grief. SHK especially killed in this episode! She does ugly crying so beautifully. I loved that scene between MY and her doctor friend, Jisoo. Something about the way SHK's face went from being ok to not ok just got to me. She better get some recognition for this role!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree. While Shi Jin's life has been in danger obviously more than once, this time when he almost faced death, the way he was gasping for air and trying to survive really hit hard for me. And this time he was gone for a whole year, he didn't just up and recuperate. And also I love the reaction of the girlfriends as they cope the death of their loved ones.

I am bawling throughout this entire episode, great job writers. And j cannot wait for the last episode. It'll be so bittersweet. How I can live with Captain Big Boss, Yoo Shi Jin?

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I've been waiting for your recap LollyPip and I couldn't agree more with your comment. What the hell did Yoo Si Jin did to survive that gunshot and explosion is the exact question I've been asking myself since I finished watching this episode. It's totally bizarre and out of logic. I know that if I want some logic, I better watch a documentary drama instead of a fictional one, but still, what happened to Yoo Si Jin is way beyond the DOTS world and I find it hard to accept. I hope show will fix it and bury my disappointment with the finale episode. Jaebal!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Heh. Missing for one whole year, presumed dead, in... some mysterious location, and then poof! He's in albany? And he can find Mo Yeon in the middle of nowhere.
The writers have written a very large check that we better be able to cash in the next episode. Like a KMY-detector. Superhuman eyes. Teleportation. Help me out here.

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Two things that made me go What?????? this episode:

1. He gets shot point-blank and then gets blown up in an explosion, and one year later, HE'S ALIVE. That is mind-boggling.

2. He knows where to find his girl, right down to the exact time and precise location.

Oh, well. I'll just tell myself he's got alien DNA. That's why he's so hot, see. He comes from the sun.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

My thought exactly. I was amaze how he could locate his girl. His alien DNA works so well. Jjang!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The last 2 minutes were enough proof for me that Si Jin is also from Do Min Joon's planet or at least neighboring planet. lmao

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Albania, not Albany, I think.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

SKY owned this episode but I have to agree that Joong Ki is a league of his own. This guy can't do no wrong. He kills every character his in whether it be Nice Guy, Werewolf Boy and others. I just watched Werewolf Boy yesterday and he was adorable! I hope he stays for a while. I will follow every drama he's in. Promise!
BTW, is it just me or are Piccolo and Harry Potter, twins? They really look alike. :)

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I still feel like this show should've ended at episode 12 where there was a perfect balance of fun, risk, heartache, commitment and closure. Because after that everything else seemed peripheral and as such I started disconnecting emotionally to the drama though I continued to love the characters. Somehow I knew the writer was going to use the male leads' vulnerable lives as her last weapon post episode 12 but it sadly failed to truly make an impact as I've also expected. Overall, Show, you were great and pretty and everything I thought I wanted. But just like any lofty dream, sometimes reality kicks you in the butt for a nasty wake-up call and you're left wondering if you had been better dreaming of what could've been than witnessing a flawed reality and grieving for what it is not.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think it's pretty funny that Korean drama watchers would complain about plot holes. It's even more funny when I see us complaining about cliched plot devices like flashbacks, and "separation" periods. Korean dramas are full of these things. Watch some of the funny youtube videos people do making fun of these things. Like I've said before if you're looking for realism watch HBO.

That being said I'm assuming since they "never found the bodies" that our hero was captured. That's the only way to explain that he still looks so terrible a year later.

0
15
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ahhh. This comment.

"Like I’ve said before if you’re looking for realism watch HBO."

No.

(my defence of kdramas, now)

I've heard this argument more than I care to, and I think it just ignores the qualitative difference between the media. If kdrama were HBO-style, that subtle thing that makes kdramas what they are would be erased.

Every time I've tried to watch an HBO show, after pushing myself through it, I realised I just had to stop, because it was making me die inside. Five seconds don't go by without foul language, innuendo, crass sexual references, violence, gore. The realism I want is not the HBO kind.

To me, kdramas have always offered emotional realism, and I find that the more compelling storytelling. So I watch kdrama, for consistently giving it to me, no matter its reliance on certain tropes. For making me, in 16 or 20 episodes, become so aligned to the characters. All without needing to go the extremes that HBO shows do.

I would also argue that what HBO depicts is only a slice of the realism spectrum. Nothing in my world, that I've ever seen or experienced, has ever resembled anything in one of its shows. Sure, I'll agree it's grittier and maybe edgier, but that doesn't really make it better or more realistic. When it comes down to it, all of this is essentially unreal. But I can't abide the slur on kdrama, and by extension, the people who enjoy it, tropes and all.

0
14
reply

Required fields are marked *

“Like I’ve said before if you’re looking for realism watch HBO"

I doubt that...

I prefer to watch National Geographic channel for realism ?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Very well said, thank you! I wouldn't get through an HBO episode either, and I don't relate to them, nor enjoy them. I think it is okay to analyze kdramas, and still enjoy them. I personally do. And I love the subtlety kdramas offer often, such as having hay on KMY's and YSJ's backs to let the audience know that more kissing had happened in the back of the truck. HBO would not do that, or know how to do that. I could go on and on, but I will stop here.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think its unfair to generalize all Korean dramas as unrealistic. It's a broad genre and very heterogeneous, Misaeng and the Reply series are examples of kdramas that are very realistic.

The problem with this drama is that it took itself seriously with its premise. A warzone is not some convenient place to provide angst for the main couple, its a warzone. It's execution of the serious plotlines were amateur at best, the earthquake arc was the best this show had to offer with respect to the theme. Otherwise, lazy world building, confusing plotlines, and a lack of understanding of this field took away any depth they were trying to make. We get morsels of it here and there, the critiques of the commodification of medicine and its role within global capitalism could have been such a great point to work on but other than a quote here and a scene there we don't get much.

I'm not expecting realism from Rom-coms, I agree there is often an emotional realism that is present but the show dealt with humanitarianism and war. Those are topics that should not be dealt with as an afterthought, Chi-hoon's scene with the young boy, giving him expensive sneakers, is a great example of how ignorant many humanitarians and volunteers are of the local population they aim to seek. This was an excellent opportunity to make a meaningful message but instead its treated like a joke.

These inconsistencies just make it less emotionally compelling, especially since the drama did so well with its characters. It undermines how the depth of the relationships and characterizations and it sucks because they could have done it.

0
11
reply

Required fields are marked *

Really love your perspective, thank you!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think its inaccurate to look at kdrama as a genre, because it's not, except in a VERY broad way (i.e. 'dramas in Korean' being their only common point). Genres exist within kdrama, but it isn't itself a genre, if that makes sense.

I think it's worth measuring this drama in the context of its writer and therefore genre. This was always centrally a romance drama, not a war drama. The warzone stuff is all a soundstage of sorts, a backdrop to the real business of conducting human relationships in difficult circumstances. To make it anything more than that is only setting yourself up for disappointment. I don't think you could enjoy - or even tolerate - this show if you want a show that depicts the complexities of war, peace and international politics. This just isn't and was never going to be that show.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree, that was bad vocab on my part(hungover still I guess)

If it was solely a Kim Eun-sook drama, then yes I would have absolutely not taken it seriously. But it wasn't, Kim Won-suk also co wrote it, and I think was the original writer. What was the worst part was there were small moments that hinted at more, Ye-hwa's comments on the medical industrial complex were great. Daniel protesting patenting vaccines and Fatima's storyline could have been developed into something more. That's what disappointed me the most, if it was just completely unimaginative tropey cliches then I wouldn't be disappointed. But it wasn't, the drama felt to me a completely different and radical version of Kim Won-suk's original vision. That is why we see those hints of depth within the storyline but for profit and advancing Korean soft power, the show became what it was.

I expected more because I know a lot about the field so my point of view is different. People in the medical field who watched the show were also irritated by some of the plot too.

0

@Gil, I actually agree with a lot of your sentiments, but I made a choice to enjoy what was good about the drama (I just like to enjoy things!). I'm also keenly aware of the issues surrounding profiteering and pharmaceuticals, especially in developing countries, and I wasn't sure if that scene with Daniel was taking a serious dig at the industry (because it was so short), but I was really glad it was in there. You are right that it showed flashes of better things, but never really developed them.

I think between the two writers, Kim Eun-sook was always going to have the upper hand simply because of her selling power. I thought it was an achievement in itself that DOTS took itself a little further than a pure-KES effort would have done.

Thanks for sharing interesting thoughts!

0

@snailshells

Thanks! I enjoyed reading your thoughts too. I enjoyed the romantic aspects of the drama, they did well in that part. I wish I could just ignore it and watch it, but based on my own personal experiences as well as my politics and education makes it hard for me to enjoy shows like DoTS or King2hearts based on entertainment alone. Especially thinking about how crazy popular this one got too.

0

also, I think DOTS only took itself *so* seriously, but it always knew it was a romance. Maybe the big production values and the massive hype made it seem to take on more seriousness, but I never watched it that way, and I really think most of us who enjoyed it didn't either.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree with most of your points.

A friend of mine doesn't want to watch DotS because the warzone issue which DotS attempted to touch but not really 'touching' it. the show was too focusing on the romance, while the people outside of the characters' camp were probably suffering from the war they'd been dealing with.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

lol, reading the above comments made mine looks so lost in the thread. lol.

I think it's clear that DotS is a drama mostly about love (yeah and other stuffs). But some people expected different things from DotS, because they probably have seen shows which balanced out the romance and serious issues well.

It's a matter of preference, though.

0

Spot on. I lost any sense of respect or will to take the show more seriously around episode 6. The performances are pretty good, but the whole world and set up is manipulative.

When it's candy, it's just candy, but one can only have so much of it.

On a side note - I travelled through Saigon's airport today and guess what a shop was playing as its soundtrack - that upbeat DOTS song!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

my defense of both HBO and Kdramas.
I completely agree with @snailshell's comments about the emotional realism Kdrama's give us. It is more direct and thus, more immediate. HBO caters to a mostly male American audience, who is so far removed from their emotional core, that shock and awe is the only thing that gets them.
Where HBO shines is the plotline. The stories might have characters who cuss at blink of an eye, but if they are killed, they stay dead. Kdramas sometimes sacrifice plotline to pack the emotional punch.

As for all the commentators lamenting the lack of a plot, I don't think their criticism is unfounded. Is it really too much to expect the emotional punch with a decent story to go along with it?

To me, this drama had distinct KWS and KES moments. The earthquake was the emotional core of the series. It affected everyone, changed everyone. I think that was all KWS. The cute romance was all KES. It made us giddy and had us grinning like fools. But the transitions between these two were jarring, mostly in the final 4 episodes. If you build up a story line highlighting how soldiers always live at the edge of life and death, then you need to show it. If Shi Jin turned up alive after a year, he should like a PoW and not a GQ model. I had a problem with the beginning of episode 14, and yes I have a problem with the beginning of episode 16 as well. I won't spoil it here though.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

If Shi Jin turned up alive after a year, he should *look* like a PoW and not a GQ model

typo

0

Things you'd like to do for Shi jin after that last scene in Ep 15:

Whip out your handy tube of aloe vera instant heal salve and lave it lovingly all over his poor scarred hand and his poor face, and his chest and his abs (not sure whether he has scars there, but WHO CARES??)

Fill a basin full of cold water and push him coyly into it...oh, and drop in some ice cubes (for his sunburn)

Burn all those clothes he was wearing

EXCEPT the scarf. Tie it around your head to add a Woman of Mystery vibe to yourself as you sidle around the tub mysteriously as he soaks in the tub

Pat him down gently with a soft fluffy towel. Tell him you have burnt all his clothes when he asks for them.

Whip out that tube of aloe vera cream and apply liberally all over his body. Again.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

my love for this comment is 15+alpha

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hmm.. I kinda felt this "long separation/death of a lead" coming. Seeing as it is a romance story about a soldier and a doctor and how they fall for each other, tackle their issues and attempt to reach a compromise on things, I guess this would be the logical progression to their story ..first you had them arguing about the conflict in their ideals, then you see them slowly understanding and accepting the situation, then MY gets to experience seeing SJ hurt badly.. now the probability of SJ disappearing for good. I guess if they find a way to get through this, there just might really be a good chance for them to last ..still, I cried my heart out in this episode! Excite to chat with all of you about the finale.

Also!! Lol I honestly thought the transmitter suddenly coming to life was Kim Eun Sook's wink at her writer friend who created Signal!! Hahaha!! Detective Lee Jae Han, help them! XD

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

lol you'r comment make my day

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm to scared to watch 15 &16 or read recaps. Aigoooo!

0
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

You will be okay, watch them :-) You will survive them, promise.

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks! (I even started deep cleaning the kitchen to avoid watching.)

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hey, deep cleaning the kitchen is always good. I have done that a lot. Take your time, and when you're ready, watch episodes 15 and 16 :-) Make sure you have tissues for at least episode 15 :-)

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks Ivoire! It's been a long time since I was so apprehensive about an ending. (I was traumatized by Iris.) My daughter refused to read the recaps to tell me it was ok so I really appreciate it.

Just finished watching both and you were right. I wonder why I cried more when Private Ki Bum and Dae Young reunite? Well now that my eyes have been rinsed really well I guess I'll finish the kitchen.

0

@ PlumWine,

You are very welcome! You had not finished deep cleaning the kitchen?! :-)

I just started episode 16, and honestly was more moved by what you mentioned as well than anything else. I will talk about it more in episode 16 recap. So your daughter watched the drama as well, with you? Neat :-) I'm going to go finish watching the episode. Hopefully I'll see in episode 16 recap.

0

i'm so amused by how everyone on Team Alpha thinks that blending in 'civilians' means popping their collars xD

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I imagine that it must be very hard to create a tightly cohesive story with the kind of grandness and scope that this show has tried to do in only 16 episodes. Therefore, I forgive all its flaws, especially because I'm drawn to the love story and characters anyways, not necessarily all the plot devices employed to advance said love story. And there are so many love stories in this show: love between a man and a woman, love amongst friends and co-workers, love for your country, love between parents and children, and love for living life to the fullest. This is one rare drama that I would actually watch with my children because it teaches so many wonderful life lessons. In the romance department, this is the most realistic drama I have seen in terms of how the main leads interact with each other - first there is attraction, but in the end we see deep love and that love is built on mature, honest communication and mutual respect...over time. In many Kdramas, the leading man is always someone who doesn't have many friends, who is kind of chauvinistic, and cold and distant - which is in real life the worst kind of partner a girl could wish for. But the men in this drama are emotionally-mature and have deep friendships and kind. The women are capable and smart. Thank you, writers, for such a wonderful show!

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

you've written an A+ description of the show for DotS lovers, thank you! These are the reasons why I would recommend it to everyone.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

So true. The alpha male is usually rich/talented, but emotionally disabled by his cruel and lonely upbringing. The plain heroine is usually poor/clumsy, but her large supportive network enables her to be loving and kind. Think Pride and Prejudice, Secret Garden, etc.

The best analysis I've read about these storylines is at: http://www.ilona-andrews.com/brief-analysis-of-alphahole-trope-in-romantic-fiction/

I love that the YSJ is emotionally mature (he never tries to fight his attraction to her, he goes for what he wants, he is never selfish or cruel to her) and has a large support network. He's a lot more grounded than she is and he persuades/waits for her to be brave enough to meet him halfway.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This episode had me crying from minutes 20 till the end *sobs*
I loved how everyone delivered a very good acting that made us feel their pain and even sobbing as hard as KMY and YMJ did T.T . And, was it just me who got goosebumps all over my body at a scene when KMY's humming the National Anthem of South Korea (?) as YSJ being shot?? Whoaa that feels, tho. Even when I replay it I still got goosebumps.

I knew it that YSJ didn't die ((since I always believe that dramaland won't let their hero
die before the end of the episodes. So I believe if YSJ did really have to die, he'd die in episode 16. HA))
So sad that we'll have to say goodbye to our BigBoss, a man who only exist in dramaland No one will ever replace him in our heart ❤

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My inner monologue during most of the episode:

Department store? Three months? If you don't come back, I will kill you. You hear me boys!

WHY ARE YOU LOOKING AWAY AND SMILING WHEN THERE IS FIRE ALL AROUND YOU CAPTAIN? NO. WHY DID YOU GET SHOT? WHY ARE YOU HAVING FLASHBACKS? NO. YOU CANNOT LEAVE ME. AND DAE YOUNG. NO. NOT YOU TOO. NO. THEY HAVE TO MAKE IT. OH MY GOD. THEY DIED? WHY? WHY? I AM THOSE MEN IN THE HELICOPTER.

*cries for a very long time watching the episode and feeling anger and disbelief*

Okay. It's been a year? So this is like when I Hear Your Voice did that crazy time jump and when Soo Ha forgot his memories, right? Oh no. That was a horrible time. But I'm happy my girls are still following their hearts and being amazing as always. It's snowing in Urk? This has to be some sign. And my lovely doctor is out in the sand and that stupid rock keeps falling over and OH MY GOD. OH MY GOD. I'M NOT BREATHING. BIG BOSS? HE'S, HE'S ALIVE. WHAT? WHAT????? THIS HAS TO BE A HALLUCINATION RIGHT? BUT HE'S TOUCHING HER AND IF HE'S A HALLUCINATION SHE WOULD FALL. THAT'S IT? THE EPISODE IS OVER?

I WENT THROUGH THE STAGES OF GRIEF FOR YOU!

*closes laptop and puts head on top of it*

I'm not gonna make tomorrow.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I read the introduction on top and knew YSJ won't die, so I was not so emotionally invested in this episode.

The grief from the characters was well acted by all of them.

I thought she did not know where he died? How did she go to Albania? Was it a random spot she decided to pay respect to him?

Wouldn't gun shot injuries be very difficult to recover from? I would think he would need physical therapy before returning to active service since he needs to be in tip top condition.

I agree with some of the opinions that the show in terms of plot could have ended at ep 12.

The show is still nice overall, but just disappointed that it could have been even better. There's not even fan service!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I read it as she went to Albania because there was a need for volunteer doctors there, and picked a nice spot to commemorate his 1 year death anniversary. Coz if DY could travel to Uruk to find MJ, then SJ probably also travelled from wherever they were from to find MY in Albania. Though the questions remain how he knew she was there and where exactly in the country she was, or how he managed to heal so well from that bullet that pierced him in slow-mo!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

oi. just, oi.

i wonder if the writer has any plans of branching out into films. i feel like she'd do really well with one... and i might enjoy an hourlongish film much better than an actual full length drama series written by her.

that said, i was so impressed by song hye-kyo's emotional scenes. she's one of the best criers among actresses i've ever seen. there's this quality to her; her tearful acting has always been something to watch. i remember even way back when she was in soongpoong clinic (one of the BEST sitcoms ever) whenever she had emotional scenes, she pulled them off just as well as she did here. and of course, autumn fairytale just broke my heart in high school—left me literally aching for days.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I read somewhere that there's usually a long separation at then end of k-dramas, like in Boys Over Flowers, Coffee Prince, DotS, etc. I don't know what that is, but read something about the Korean concept of "Han"? Can anyone explain this?

As to YSJ having the same cellphone, either he left it behind at the barracks when he went to the "battlefield", or he got a new cellphone and reactivated his number and got all his texts downloaded and read?

Of course YSJ can find her in the middle of the Albanian desert. He roams the world for his work and goes off the map all the time. Yeah, he looks dark and rough and tired, but he came to find her.

For me, I don't expect any realism in a k drama, just fun fantasy. (I mean, I just finished watching Signal and Healer - and do real life couples really just hold hands and kiss for years on end even when they are almost 30?). This is a romance set amongst dramatic elements of warfare, humanitarian crises and hospital drama. I actually like the loud music, because I don't understand korean so the music adds to the silent subtitles.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

havent seen the 15th episode. i think i might try to read this reviews and get to watch it tomorrow.

please kindly visit my blog too josephinethea.blogspot.co.id and it's all about korean too. i'm still newbie and have a lot to learn.

thankyou <3

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I definitely agree about the lack of buildup/impact in the drama. I really enjoyed the drama, but one thing it was missing was depth. Despite this, I think that what made the drama so successful was definitely how well written and likable the characters were and I'm definitely grateful for that.

I LOVED the bromance between Shi Jin and Dae Young, as well as the mystery behind the relationship between Dae Young and Myung Joo. I almost want to say I liked the romance between the second leads better than the first leads. Shi Jin and Mo Yeon's love didn't seem "deep" enough to me, if that makes sense. Either way, I quite enjoyed this drama despite the lack of buildup in the plot, and I'm happy that didn't disappoint me in the end (*cough* Cheese in the Trap...still kind of bitter).

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Am I the only one disappointed with this drama? I mean, the good point is that there are not the usual cliches that we always see in k-drama, but I didn't find it so exiciting and great as it is seen.
Don't know, to me it was just a 6 out of 10 k-drama, nothing special

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks Lollypip, I enjoyed the drama including the cheesiness of it all. I cried from watching the Eng subbed final episodes (great that I was too busy to watch it raw!) I thought I was over the sadness from watching the final episodes but reading the your recap and everyone's comments made me cry all over again. Thanks so much for recapping an unforgettable drama with the realistic portrayals of the actors--whose futures will be highly rewarded with more roles & cfs.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

SHK really deserves a Daesang award for her performance here. Hat off.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

this episode give me all the feels.. all through the episode i cry, laugh, cry again, then laugh. i keep crying during the sad scenes eventhough i knew it will be a happy ending..

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *