485

W–Two Worlds: Episode 16 (Final)

We’re out of time and out of cliffhanger exits, and the final chapter of our story is hurtling towards that final frame. Will our hero find a way to escape life as a manhwa hero, or die trying to change his fate? Will two worlds implode, or will our brains implode first? And what really defines a happy ending? The answer may surprise you…

 

 
FINAL EPISODE RECAP

It’s the final episode of the webtoon, and Kang Chul, Yeon-joo, and Dad are stuck inside the manhwa world until the ending, happy or sad. With the police closing in on them, Kang Chul makes the decision to erase Yeon-joo from his family registry and pulls off their wedding rings. Out in the real world, Crazy Dog reaches this part in the episode and his jaw drops.

Chul asks Yeon-joo to decide what kind of ending they get, promising to follow her lead. So she puts her wedding ring back on and calls his plan nonsense. Yessss, this is why we love you! She reaches for his hand, which is still flickering in and out and threatening to disappear, and slides his ring back on too. She says there won’t be any ending where anyone disappears, and all of them will get out of here together.

He points out that she can’t live in here for the rest of her life, but she says that the three of them can live together, and argues that visiting him in jail for the rest of their lives is better than never seeing him again. Wait, is this really your plan? Chul doesn’t think such an uneventful ending is possible, but Yeon-joo stubbornly refuses to imagine any sort of ending where Dad and Kang Chul aren’t both by her side.

Yeon-joo says that the only options for leaving her are for him to get sick or die of old age, and declares that her decision is made: They will live out the rest of their lives in here and die. The end.

It doesn’t seem like Chul thinks this is possible (and frankly neither do I), but he can’t argue and asks her to draw them an exit and a car for now, so that they can escape.

On the drive, Chul says, “You said once that your husband never told you that he loved you… I love you.” Agh, why does that make me more scared than happy? It brings Yeon-joo to tears, and she cries silently in the backseat.

Chul drops her off with Dad in a motel before going back to rescue Do-yoon. He tells Assemblyman Han’s henchmen that he wants to see Do-yoon alive before handing anything over, and they turn Do-yoon over to him without a fuss. He’s bloodied and barely conscious, and Chul makes sure that his bodyguards take Do-yoon to the hospital. He remains behind, knowing that this is the deal.

Assemblyman Han is waiting for the tablet, but Chul says he doesn’t have it, and offers up a copy of the CCTV footage of him being tortured in here a year ago. Chul warns him that he has multiple copies, and threatens to turn it over to the police if Assemblyman Han ever attacks one of his people again.

Chul adds that he should stop looking for the tablet if he doesn’t want a syringe in his neck, and turns to go. Assemblyman Han stops him with a question: “What if this ends only when you die?” Before Chul can even react, Assemblyman Han pulls out a gun and shoots him in the chest. Gack.

It sends Chul tumbling backwards, and he lands on the floor with a thud. Back in the motel room, Yeon-joo notices Dad’s hands suddenly solidifying, and she starts to panic, knowing that this means Chul is in danger.

Assemblyman Han says he heard something strange, about two worlds, and how Kang Chul is the hero of a manhwa and he’s the villain. Dude, take a number. Assemblyman Han says he thought it was crazy at first, but it explains so much of what he couldn’t understand before.

He racked his brains trying to figure out why Chul suddenly couldn’t vanish while he was being tortured, or disappear from prison, and then he pumped Do-yoon full of enough drugs that he finally heard the truth: that this is the final episode, and one of them has to die for it to end.

Assemblyman Han is convinced that if Chul dies, he’ll be able to enter that other world. Chul has stopped listening, and focuses all of his efforts on sliding a chair closer with his foot. Assemblyman Han starts poking Chul in the face with his gun, and decides that he can go find out the truth for himself in that other world. He whirls around, ready to pull the trigger…

But Chul is faster, and he kicks the chair so that it slams into Assemblyman Han’s side. Chul rushes him and they wrestle for the gun, choking each other violently. Assemblyman Han screams, “Die!” as they fall to the floor.

By the time the henchmen break their way inside, Chul has the gun in hand and shoots them down. He staggers out leaving a trail of blood, and uses up the rest of his bullets on the remaining henchmen, finally resorting to hand-to-hand combat when he’s out of ammunition.

Do-yoon is awake now and yells at his subordinates for just leaving Kang Chul there by himself. They turn back on Do-yoon’s orders, and arrive outside the hideout just in time to see Chul staggering to his car. They focus on stopping the henchmen so that Chul can escape, and though he manages to drive away, he’s in bad shape.

Do-yoon calls Yeon-joo to update her, and she’s relieved to know that he’s alive. But then they both ask each other where Kang Chul is, and she starts to panic. Do-yoon says they’re on the lookout, and asks where she is so that he can send guards to watch over her.

It’s not until hours later that Chul finally calls her, voice trembling and weak. He asks her to pick him up, because of all the things, he ran out of gas. She asks why he didn’t call until now, and he says he fell asleep.

He admits that he’s “a little hurt” and can’t manage to see where he is, so he hangs up to go find out. Ack, don’t hang up!

Yeon-joo goes to the tablet and starts drawing herself a car, and asks Do-yoon to look after Dad while she goes searching for Chul.

Chul peels himself out of the car and starts stumbling towards the bus stop, looking like he can barely stand. He finally calls Yeon-joo back and ekes out the name of the city and bus stop, and almost immediately after hanging up, he coughs up a nasty stream of blood. Aauuuuugh. Hurry!

Yeon-joo asks Do-yoon to call a doctor because they can’t go to the emergency room, and Chul calls her back to ask why she isn’t here. She stifles back tears and says she’s on her way but it’s farther than she thought, and he says softly, “I’m waiting.”

Chul says that the final episode doesn’t seem like it’ll go on for fifty years, and he starts to cry as he realizes now that the ending they’d hoped for is impossible. “Who’d read an ending that boring?” he asks.

He tries to hold on and says, “Come quickly. I miss you.” She pleads with him to hang on just a little longer because she’s on her way, but the phone falls out of his hand, and his body slumps down. Noooooooooooo.

Yeon-joo finally reaches the bus stop and sees him from across the street, and when she calls out to him, he lifts his head. Oh phew. His mouth quirks up in a little smile when he sees her.

But then, as if that’s the last thing he was hanging on to do, his eyes close and his body falls limp, and the final chyron starts to render in the corner: “The End.” Ohmygod, this can’t be the end?!

Time slows as Yeon-joo sees it happening and she starts to run across the street in tears. She’s almost there, but a truck zooms by, cutting off her path to Kang Chul. And then… night turns to day, the truck becomes a bus, and once it passes, she’s back in the real world and Kang Chul is gone.

This isn’t happening. Tell me this isn’t happening?

Su-bong grouses that no one is answering his calls, and he returns to the empty workshop. He checks Dad’s office, and does a double-take when Dad’s tablet turns into a manhwa drawing and then disappears right in front of his eyes.

Su-bong rushes to the computer to check the last episode of the webtoon, and then rushes to the bus stop to find Yeon-joo. When he gets there, she’s sitting were Kang Chul was, crying inconsolably. Su-bong just sits next to her quietly, letting her cry.

Crazy Dog reaches the end of the webtoon and has just about the same reaction that I did, like he might throw something at his computer. He’s so upset that he marches out to go pick a bone with Yeon-joo, but Seok-bum says she’s in the emergency room, and clarifies that she’s not working in it—she just got admitted as a patient.

Crazy Dog is stunned to find Yeon-joo wailing so sorrowfully in the emergency room, and he’s suddenly sweet and caring as he asks what happened. She just cries and cries, so he tucks his handkerchief into her hand before he goes. Aw.

Su-bong wipes at his tears as he drives to the motel where Dad was last seen inside the manhwa. The clerk has never seen Dad, but Su-bong pleads to be allowed to check again, because Dad must be wandering around and out of his mind.

The final straw for Yeon-joo is when her wedding ring disappears right off of her finger, like the tablet and anything else that came from the manhwa world.

When Crazy Dog spots Su-bong in the hospital, he stops to ask if this is really the end of W, and how it could end like that with the hero dying instead of the villain. That’s the final straw for Su-bong, and he snaps, “Please, STOOOOOOOOP! Shut that mouth!” Su-bong looks like he might tear Crazy Dog a new one, but then he just goes on his way, leaving Crazy Dog to wonder why Su-bong always attacks him like a crazy dog, heh.

When Yeon-joo hears that Dad wasn’t in the motel, she yanks out her IV and stumbles out of the hospital. She goes straight to Dad’s workshop to look for the tablet, but Su-bong tells her it’s gone—it was a copy after all, and it came from the manhwa world. He tells her it’s really over now, and she crumples to the floor in another wave of tears.

Yeon-joo spends the ensuing days in a haze of denial and depression, waking up to her collage of Kang Chul drawings and a fresh batch of tears each morning. She goes to the bus stop day after day and waits there to no avail, and she sketches Dad’s face on a new tablet, but it’s only ever Su-bong who walks through the front door.

They finally circulate flyers looking for Dad, and as Yeon-joo sits at the bus stop again, Su-bong narrates, “Yeon-joo noona was the only one who couldn’t accept reality. But the webtoon W completed its seven-year run and ended in September, 2016.” He says that the manhwa’s hero rejected his destiny and dreamt of a happy ending as a real person, but in the end he fell at the hands of the villain and died in front of the woman he loved.

Su-bong says that reporters came to Dad’s workshop in search of answers regarding the ending, but Dad never returned. As people buy the final volume of W in bookstores, Su-bong narrates that most people didn’t think the ending was so strange. Did those people know how to read?

“But…” Su-bong continues, “Nobody knew that the ending wasn’t a sad one.” Wait, what?

In flashback we return to the bus stop as Kang Chul dies, and this time, Yeon-joo vanishes and we stay in the manhwa world, which doesn’t freeze or stop at all—it just keeps going.

We go back a few hours to find that Assemblyman Han isn’t dead either, and his henchmen find him stewing angrily in the corner of his warehouse, right where Kang Chul left him.

Dad is still tied up in the motel room, and when he hears his bodyguard talking to Do-yoon on the phone, he asks Do-yoon to untie him because it’s faster to help Kang Chul with the tablet than to drive around looking for him. It’s true… but that’s also what the killer would say to be freed?

Do-yoon relents and warns the bodyguard to keep an eye on Dad in case he goes crazy, and Dad begins to draw on the tablet. But ack, the first thing he draws is a syringe in his guard’s neck! Dad waits until the bodyguard passes out and then takes his phone to make a call.

Assemblyman Han pitches a fit at his own assistant, screaming that nothing matters now because he could die at any moment. He’s hysterical, until Dad calls him directly and confirms, “I’m the one who made you.”

Dad asks how Assemblyman Han ended up this way, getting blood on his hands and shooting guns when he’s supposed to be president. Assemblyman Han just wants to know how Dad is here in this world, but Dad asks knowingly, “Did you shoot Kang Chul to find me?”

Dad seems amused and says he’s been here for a year, and then the door to Assemblyman Han’s office suddenly locks, and a gun appears in his hand. Ohhhh. Dad asks if he’s looking for the reason he exists, and sighs that there’s no way to stop that hunger to know, and it’ll end with some sort of explosion… just like the others before him. “That’s how I ended up this way,” he says.

Dad says that can’t happen though—if a bad guy like him knew all the secrets, what would happen to his world? Dad decides, “That’s too dangerous. You should come with me. I failed at everything else, but I need to take care of you before I go.”

Assemblyman Han’s hand starts to flicker and pull the gun up to his own temple, against his will. When he starts to shout, Dad draws a piece of duct tape over his mouth. Time is running out on Dad’s own hand, which is fading quickly, and he draws furiously until he hears the sound of the gunshot.

By the time Assemblyman Han’s assistants bust down the door, he’s shot dead, and the duct tape has been erased. On the desk, Dad has drawn a suicide note along with a USB drive, which must contain all the footage of Kang Chul being tortured.

Dad also sends the cops evidence on Ajusshi’s shooting to prove Kang Chul’s innocence, and then he leaves his own picture and a letter in the bodyguard’s hand before calling Do-yoon. Dad asks where Yeon-joo is, in the hopes of seeing her one last time.

Kang Chul sits at the bus stop coughing up blood, and as Dad drives there, he begins to fade almost entirely. His words to Kang Chul are repeated in voiceover—that they couldn’t be together in the end, and that if it were to be a happy ending for one of them, it’d be a sad ending for the other.

Dad stops in the middle of the road, arriving just as Yeon-joo gets out of her car across the street from the bus stop. He sees her crying and calling out to Kang Chul, and Dad just smiles at her, at once happy, regretful, and loving.

He reaches out a hand, but she’s too far away, and he just says quietly, “I love you, my daughter. Goodbye.” He shuts his eyes and accepts his fate, and then he fades away.

Su-bong narrates that it wasn’t Kang Chul’s death that ended the manhwa, but the villains’ deaths. He explains that their final moments never made it onto the manhwa page because the villain of the story went against his very reason for existing in order to ensure the hero’s happy ending, and he vanished because of it, taking that final story arc with him. What? Why would their deaths get edited out from the manhwa? That makes no sense.

Do-yoon discovers Kang Chul passed out at the bus stop, and Su-bong narrates that nobody knew that Kang Chul was still alive, because the manhwa had simply ended. Chul gets hauled away in an ambulance, with Do-yoon clutching his bloody hand. He’s unresponsive at first, but then… he opens his eyes. Don’t ever scare me like that again!

Do-yoon yells at him: “I thought you were dead!” And all Chul says in response is, “Oh Yeon-joo…” Do-yoon says that she wasn’t there, and Chul smiles in relief. Su-bong narrates that he knew it then, that his role as the hero of the manhwa was over at last.

Sometime later, So-hee returns to Korea after her business trip and is shocked to hear the news report that Assemblyman Han committed suicide. She visits Kang Chul in prison, and he says that as soon as he healed from the gunshot wound, they stuck him back in here. She assures him that since the murder charges have been dropped, he shouldn’t be in there for too much longer.

So-hee apologizes for suspecting him and cutting off contact, but Chul says he was happy when she did, because she proved that she could live a different life.

In his cell, Chul takes out the letter and photo that Dad left behind for him. Do-yoon told him that Dad disappeared without a trace, and passed on the letter. Dad writes that he’d hoped Chul would send him off, but he’s going on his own. Dad says that he’s already dead, and his soul is terminal because he doesn’t know when he’ll go crazy again.

Dad: “You will go out to the real world, and I will end my life here. You will become human, and I will remain a manhwa character. You will break free from the predetermined settings I created, and I will die trapped in the setting I created… Isn’t life funny? Be happy. Make Yeon-joo happy. And if you meet Yeon-joo, tell her that I’m alive, so that she isn’t sad. Tell her that I’m living a better life, inside the manhwa that I drew.”

Tears roll down Kang Chul’s cheeks as he reads Dad’s final words, and in flashback we see Dad smiling wistfully as he wrote the letter and drew a photograph of himself to leave behind.

Su-bong narrates that Kang Chul spent two more years in prison in order to wrap up the manhwa world logically, and that time passed slowly for him.

Thankfully, only a week has passed in Yeon-joo’s world. Mom asks her where dad is, and Yeon-joo says without much conviction that he’ll probably show up if they wait a few more days.

She goes to Dad’s workshop and lingers in his empty office, and then she returns to the bus stop again. She walks through the pouring rain and sits there, looking utterly broken and lost.

At home, Mom answers Yeon-joo’s phone and says she left it behind, and Mom asks who’s calling. Could it be…?

Yeon-joo sits on the curb in the spot where Kang Chul died, getting completely soaked and on the verge of passing out. A car pulls up and stops just a few feet away, and when she opens her eyes, all she sees is a pair of feet walking towards her in slow motion… She begins to fall, and loses consciousness.

When Yeon-joo wakes up, she’s in a bright hospital room, and omo—she’s sleeping on someone else’s arm. She focuses her eyes and sees a man’s hand holding hers, wearing a familiar ring.

She turns around to face him, and there’s Kang Chul, spooning her in the morning as if nothing has happened. He opens his eyes and smiles at her, and Yeon-joo still looks like she doesn’t believe it.

He asks how she is, and says that he told Mom to go home and get some rest. He thought Mom would ask more questions, and says he couldn’t very well tell her that he was Yeon-joo’s husband, so he said he was her boyfriend.

Mom had asked if maybe they’d broken up at a bus stop, and guesses that this was what Yeon-joo was so broken-hearted about. She asked what Chul did for a living, and he handed her his business card from the manhwa world. You can’t keep doing that!

He tells Yeon-joo that he spent two years in prison, but it’s only been a week here. “I was worried that time would flow the same, and that you’d die from being sad alone. What a relief,” he says with a smile.

She finally reaches out a hand to touch his face, and lets herself believe that he’s really here. A tear escapes, and she lets out a trembling sigh of relief. (She’s wearing her ring again—did he bring her a new one?)

She asks after Dad, and Chul gets up to get Dad’s picture out of his coat pocket. He doesn’t say anything as he hands it to her, but it seems that Yeon-joo knows what must’ve happened, and she sobs as Chul holds her in his arms.

Sometime later, they sit overlooking the river and Chul points out that he’s now three years older than her. “So you really have to call me oppa now,” he says happily. Yeon-joo asks if it’s really really over, and he assures her that it is.

They snuggle and kiss, and Yeon-joo narrates, “Kang Chul’s story in the manhwa was a happy ending, but the real-life Kang Chul and Oh Yeon-joo’s ending is still unknown. But…”

Kang Chul finishes, “The two of them no longer stand at the crossroads of life and death like a manhwa, and although boring and ordinary, we hope that they will get an ending that lasts fifty years. Like other ordinary couples.”

As the sun sets, the final chyron appears in the corner: “The End.”

 
COMMENTS

Was that Yeon-joo’s manhwa ending or the drama ending? Not that it really matters, since both are her story. Okay, so I’m happy for the characters and relieved that Kang Chul is alive, and I think Dad’s sacrifice makes sense in the context of the story without reaching for a deus ex machina solution in the final hour. So I’m okay with the resolution on that front, because I was worried that the magical tablet would fix everything with a wave and not make a lick of sense. But URGH, I have SO MANY QUESTIONS, and the finale didn’t even begin to address all the things I wanted it to. I feel like I set out on this journey on pins and needles waiting for the explanation of all the rules that govern this world and the final clever twist—the why of it all—but in the end, I was left wondering if the writer didn’t know either.

Does the manhwa world just keep going infinitely, with no ties to the outside world? What made it possible for the manhwa to be the bridge between the two universes in the first place, if Dad really didn’t create that world himself? What gave Dad’s tablet magical portal abilities? Why didn’t we ever really explore the fact that Yeon-joo created Kang Chul first? I wanted to believe that there was something different about Chul and his capacity to become self-aware because of her, but we never found out what made him different from all the other manhwa characters, and why he became self-aware in the first place. I just feel like all of the fundamental questions that were raised were never answered, and that means I’m ultimately dissatisfied, because I wanted closure, not just on the characters’ lives, but on this construct as a whole—two worlds bridged by a manhwa that somehow operates autonomously, according to rules that change at will.

Here’s what I don’t understand: Why on earth would W the manhwa end on a false version of the story, letting readers believe that Kang Chul is dead, when it’s really the villains who died? If a happy ending falls in the forest and no one’s around to see it, IS IT HAPPY? Dad rendering the villain useless and disappearing as a consequence makes sense—after all, he’s the one who created the one-dimensional villain whose sole purpose for existing was to kill Chul and his family, and his fate became inversely tied to Kang Chul’s the second he was sucked into the final episode. But there’s no logical reason why the manhwa would misrepresent events to the readers, and suddenly end the second the villains are rendered moot.

If Kang Chul were the hero of the story from beginning to end, it should’ve included his happy ending even after the villains died. It doesn’t sit right with me that the manhwa just stopped when the villains stopped breathing, because that’s not how endings go! If Kang Chul thinking that he wanted to stop being the hero of this manhwa was what launched them into the final episode in the first place, then it should’ve ended in the ambulance when he realized he was finally done. Or after prison, if it was suddenly so important for his character’s logic to serve his full two-year sentence (But really, why should that matter if he’s no longer the hero?). I just feel terrible for Crazy Dog and all the fans of the webtoon, who basically got cheated out of their satisfactory resolution.

It seemed like a trick for the sake of a twist to have Kang Chul die in the manhwa but not really die, and I would’ve been much happier if Yeon-joo had come up with a plan to get them out, even if it had failed in the end, requiring Dad’s sacrifice anyway. Living in the manhwa world forever didn’t seem like a solution at all, and Chul going in by himself to save Do-yoon was pretty much the stupidest thing he’s done all series long. I was disappointed that they didn’t outsmart the villians or the manhwa itself, because what I wanted for Kang Chul was to step outside of the construct entirely and manipulate his world. His self-awareness ended up being pretty limited, and I thought the finale felt tame because our hero and heroine were just reacting to events happening to them, instead of taking control of their own fate like I ultimately wanted.

That doesn’t mean I’m dissatisfied with the series as a whole, because I still got my happy ending and Kang Chul gets to live in Yeon-joo’s world without having to be a hero anymore, and he didn’t die, and she didn’t have to meet a doppelganger Kang Chul 3.0 (this was my biggest fear, because I was scared he’d be based on a real person). For me the happy ending is that Kang Chul becomes fully human with complete free will, and the fact that he becomes a real boy is enough to make me not hate the ending. I just wish we had gone beyond Chul and Yeon-joo’s happy ending, because I think there’s an entirely separate happy ending for the audience, the one where we get all our burning questions about the mythology answered, and not get left entirely by the wayside.

It’s too bad that the show used up all of the truly amazing mind-blowing twists so early on in the series, because it made the second half feel rather slow and predictable in comparison, only because it started out with such a bang. I was still very much engaged in the characters’ journey through the end, but there was a definitely slowdown in pace and loosening of tension that happened when they reset Kang Chul’s world and wiped his memory. I liked Kang Chul 2.0 and enjoyed the twist on the amnesia trope and the more grounded relationship that came out of it. But there was inarguably a zippy, raw energy to the first timeline that couldn’t be replicated, and I think that was a flaw in how the story was told in the second half. And if there were one magic wand to wave at the end, I would’ve liked for him to remember both timelines in the final moments, even if that goes against the whole not-amnesia twist.

But I’m still walking away from this drama impressed with writer Song Jae-jung’s ability to create such a pulse-pounding, intricate supernatural story, even though if you look at her past works—Nine and Queen Inhyun’s Man in particular—it’s not much of a surprise. She bends time, space, reality, and our hearts on a regular basis, and though I have plenty of gripes about her raising all of these questions and leaving them unanswered, I’m still unabashedly a fan. I was actually more surprised by PD Jung Dae-yoon, who had done light rom-com She Was Pretty before this; but he turned out a visually expressive take on two worlds, and melded together the beautiful two-dimensional art with live-action in a really stylish way, which was crucial to making this crazy premise believable, and the transition between the worlds seamless. Everything from the music to the CG effects was in service of telling the story first and foremost, and the director impressed me with his flair for suspense.

As for the cast, in many ways it was the Lee Jong-seok show—and for good reason, because he was really so good, better than he’s ever been before—but I think Dad kind of stole his thunder in the final stretch, with his crazy killer mind-meld multiple personality thing. I do think that the horror-suspense really hinged on Kim Eui-sung’s acting, and he was so good that it gave me nightmares and made me question his sanity, and then the next day he’d make me sympathetic to Dad’s plight all over again. And I’d only started to like Han Hyo-joo with her more recent films, but I loved her as Yeon-joo. She was a little screwball, but that just made me laugh more, and I found her warm and relatable, which is pretty crucial in a story where the hero and Dad are intentionally very un-relatable. I felt her angst whenever she was separated from Kang Chul, and in the final episode I really believed she might die of heartsickness if Chul hadn’t shown up in time. Her noona-dongseng relationship with scene-stealer Lee Shi-un was especially endearing, probably in large part because Su-bong was the funniest supporting character I’ve come across in a long time. I will wait patiently for his spinoff until the end of days.

What drew me to W was the freshness of its sci-fi, manhwa, meta-dramaland premise. I loved that we couldn’t anticipate where the story would go, and that it would cleverly turn a standard narrative trope on its head, making the usual drama trademark move a handy tool for the heroine to use in the manhwa world. Kisses as weapons, and cliffhangers as escape routes; I never grew tired of the ways narrative tropes could be used to rewrite the story from within. As a drama fan, it was the ultimate validation—this is the language we speak, and the heroine was one of us, perceiving the world of the manhwa the way we perceive dramas.

At its strongest, W was dizzyingly fast-paced and addictive, and it made me sincerely ponder existential questions about free will and predetermination, and the role that fiction plays in our lives. It was thoughtful and engaging on so many meta levels, especially when the drama served as a cautionary tale about a careless writer who essentially created a monstrous villain out of weak characterization in service of plot. Dad was an avatar for all of the terrible writers out there who reach for the lazy tropes in the bag of tricks, from the truck of doom to the faceless villain with poor character motivation, to the female character who only serves to pine after the hero without an identity of her own (I liked the point that was being made about poorly written female characters with So-hee’s arc). And the moment you don’t treat a fictional character like a real person with dreams and hopes, a name, or a face… well, we’ve seen what happens then.

And I’m glad that Dad’s role as the creator of this manhwa was touched upon again at the end, because the framework of Dad’s story is the thing I found most chilling about this drama. I always felt that the underlying genre of this story was horror, not because it was scary at times, but because of the themes—W was like Dr. Frankenstein’s monster, and Dad’s story was classic horror tragedy in almost every regard, and I loved that aspect of the story. There’s something truly horrific about your mistakes coming to life, and your fiction trapping you in the rules you created. I don’t know think that the writer did a satisfactory job of explaining Dad’s supernatural controlled-via-tablet, sharing-a-brain relationship with No-Face, but I do find his end poetic and tragically karmic. It fits his genre, and his tragic character’s self-fulfilling prophecy. Ironic, in a story all about characters breaking free of their predetermined paths.

The thing I loved most about Kang Chul’s journey to free will is the idea of self-awareness breaking you out of a world. On a literal sci-fi level it’s the Matrix, or the manhwa world, but it can also be any construct that defines a person. The fact that Kang Chul’s greatest weapon is choice—choosing to step outside of his predetermined destiny, rewriting his own story with the power of that choice—it’s an ideal and a philosophy that moves me, because I believe that life is a series of choices and we define our own fate by the choices we make. A hero’s journey to gain the fundamental right to determine the course of his own life, live or die, is a story worth telling. Do I think this epilogue needed an epilogue? Yes, maybe two—one for all the ‘xplaining the writer’s got left to do, and one for all the cuddles I was cheated out of. I guess I’ll just have to imagine how the rest of the story goes, since apparently fiction has a mind of its own and decides it’s the end whenever it damn well pleases.

 
RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , , , ,

485

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recap GF.

I really felt like Crazy Dog was personifying what I felt about the end of W2W! I was left wondering- “Is this it? That’s it? What happened to a show that started with a bang- it just ended with a whimper!” I loved the show like crazy in the beginning but it just fizzled out in the end! Lee Jong Suk was brilliant but he felt like a caricature of Kang Chul in the ending. And I did not buy the romance at all.. It really looked like 2 actors were speaking their lines instead of 2 human beings in love.

Ah! I will just keep happy memories of a half brilliant show and a sexy winking Jong Suk. And Su Bong and Crazy Dog are love. No offence to people who loved it. I am just a little disappointed, that’s all. Looking forward to next week with Seo In Guk goodness.

1
36
reply

Required fields are marked *

That "I love you" was flat. That scene could have had an impact if it were when he was waiting for her at the bus stop or when they finally met in the real world. But no! The writer chose to have that in a car where KC's driving and YJ's in the backseat with Dad. Really??

And did KC really has to say "You told me before that your husband never said 'I love you'..." Ughhh The way the scene played out was insincere and awkward like they're merely following the script. I got nothing. No emotional punch at all.

Until the very end, the romance remains to be bland. The romance really felt rush.

0
15
reply

Required fields are marked *

Really? Interesting because I actually liked that scene.

To me it was a soft declaration of love in a moment where they didn't have time for grand gestures but he still wanted her to know what she meant to him. He seized the moment because he didn't know if he would have another chance and he didn't want to have her miss out on it a second time. Because it's not often in life you get a second chance to tell someone that you love them.

And I thought it meant even more to YJ because he bothered to remember that he hadn't said it the first time, so he made it a point to do it this time, even if dad was there and they were fleeing for their lives. You don't have to wait for the perfect moment, you can make every moment into a perfect one.

0
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree with you. That confession is meant to be a bittersweet one. They both knew very well that they probably not able to see each other ever again. The way Yeonjoo's eyes turned red after hearing the "I love you" really broke my heart.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was not hoping for grand gestures either. I'm all for sincerity be it grand or not. I was not feeling it here. The timing felt off for me as well. As for that line he said, we have different interpretations. As much as I want to see it your way, I can't. And believe me I want so bad to feel the emotion of KC and YJ, but I feel so disconnected with their romance. It bugs me as well because more than anything, I love a good romance/love story.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I thought the confession scene was low key but given the dire situation, it was appropriate. My guess is that KC was waiting for a happier setting but since things turned out this way, he finally uttered the words at that moment.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Same here,...I like that scene....I saw the Final BTS and I'm glad that LJS and HHJ are very close to each other,...looking forward to hear any love declaration some time soon, maybe? LOL. Kinda upset we didn't get no #4. Because if we get number 4, LJS may end up marrying HHJ, hahaha....They kissed 7 times with maybe so many NG and the duration took longer than the tv version, right? No wonder they were handholding all the time even when the camera was off. If we got number 4 on the menu, I'm sure there will be a young genius, cute, doctor to be KC and YJ....Ahhh

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

i knowww...even i felt so...it was so poignant!!!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The ilu scene was perfect. I agree with, michykdrama that he said that phrase before hand to show that he had empathy for her. KC knew that had hurt her. And since they were running out of time to figure out a solution or even losing the possibility of making out alive. (But not her? did that taking her off the family registry stand). He didn't want her alone without an ilu.

It reminds me of the dad in Doctors who hadn't said ilu to his bride yet. And when he finally did, totes tears. Life is too short to wait for a romantic moment, especially while on the run and your best friend is dying.

@Sun Yeon Joo tearing up got to me. My breathing became staggered and I was like "please no, I can't cry. The episode isn't half over."

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Booo. The bolding was supposed to stand?

Mianhaeyo, mary!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I am NOT impressed with the end (apart from the part that they ended up together). They had sooo much plot to work with but they twisted the story so much that they eventually got confused.

W would have gone places if they had worked very well with their plot (again I problem of live production).

No mind blowing reveals.
Even the way the villian dead was *%#*#.
That almighty tablet would have been used to do soooo much GREAT THINGS, especially in this end!!

Please share your thoughts on the end. Gomawo고마워

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

They're making us feel exactly like Professor Crazy Dog reading his final chapter of W with that ending. Grrr. I honestly don't know how the webtoon fans didn't find it strange. Their protagonist died and zero explanation of what happened to the bad guys?!

SO MANY QUESTIONS is about where I'm at as well. I couldn't believe the finale ended where it did. Was that really an hour? This show still stresses me out even after it ends!! How did Chul cross over to the real world after he got out of prison? I guess it's permanent? What happened to Do-yoon now that he knows about the other world too?

Can that "the end" magically erase itself and keep the drama going for us too? Waaa. I'm counting on you, special episode...

2
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I guess at least we know Su-bong will get his loan money back from Kang Chul now? :D

0

I hated the "I love you" scene!! That confession sucked soooooo much! I mean, he didn't even looked her in the eyes, he was freaking driving for god's sake!

Everything in the scene was was so UNromantic, not worth of such strong words. WTF! Seriously, it felt like Chul only said the 3 words because, as he himself said, "your husband never told you he loved you"... and then Chul says he loves her... but it did not felt like a true heartfelt confession, it felt like he said it just to fulfill the lack of a previous confession. Aiiish!!!

Sniff!

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

why must he look her in the eyes??

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hmm...considering Kang Chul has a difficult time just complimenting her, I think the "I love you" scene was quite touching. Yes, he failed to properly put together a "romantic" confession, but he at least spoke honest words to her about his feelings which is quite an acheivement in itself. Remember that time when, instead of admitting his sadness and gratefulness, he yelled at her saying that he was not thankful for her bringing him back to life and then kissed her like 2 minutes later? Kang Chul is a complicated character because of his "setting" or the predispositions that he has as a result of being a manhwa character, and being able to express his feelings properly is a weakness that he developed as a result of having to repress his sadness and harden his character after the death of his family. We know that he has trouble being vulnerable so that "I love you" scene, in my opinion, no matter how random it might have seemed, is actually quite powerful in it's randomness. In a way, it's fitting that it is not a romantic confession, but a confession driven out of him as a result of desperation and that he clumsily expresses it.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Why do you say that? It might not have been romantic or grand but it felt very much honest to me. Like an ordinary husband and wife who haven't gotten to know each other well in all their time of marriage, and in a moment when they don't know what the future holds, all he could do for her was let her know what she's been wanting to hear the most from him: that he truly loved her. Sure it's not "romantic" but it's sincere and it's moments like this we should appreciate and treasure in our own lives and not grand romantic gestures which we may never get. Also, if there's anything this drama has taught us, it's that fiction cannot always be grand in an unrealistic way if we expect to relate on a personal level, and most importantly: everything is not what it seems.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I believe the first Kang Chul love Oh Yeon Joo, don't believe the second one.

Also agree on the fizzling out. Its just in Queen In Hyun's Man there is an explanation on his "travel" so I waiting for the how and whys and never got the answer.

0
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

I feel you. I think Kang Chul 1.0 loved her for real than 2.0 ver. (I dunno if its in the writing or LeeJongSuk's take on the amnesia) but hey, who said this is an ultimate romantic story eh? Lols. Praise for the superb writing and directorial skills still! Kudos to W staff! :)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Agree with u. The only thing I felt went very wrong with this show is when they started going with Kang Chul 2.0. It wouldn't have been a problem if he regained Kang Chul 1.0 memory or they in someway merged together to form the ultimate one and only Kang Chul anyhow.. maybe it would be okay if this is a 50ep makjang drama coz within just few episodes, Kang Chul 2.0's love feels too rushed it almost feels faked.

0
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

+1

I don't know whether I'm having some attachment issues, but I'm still heartbroken over the fact that Kang Chul 1.0 decided that the only way was to subject himself to a prison of a life, just to protect the people he cared about.

I mean, he's like preserved in my head falling down the side of a building - can I have some resolution for that please? ?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

With Kang Cheol 1.0 the chemistry died too. Something was missing from 2.0 and Yeon Joo's romance.
I was rooting for 2.0 but he didn't have 1.0 cheekiness and boyish charm. It is awesome tho, that LJS was able to play these 2 characters so well.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I actually found Kang Chul 2.0 pretty endearing in how he tried to learn everything about Yeon-joo and her world so that he could catch up with the relationship. I loved the part when he examined her room and noticed her mess. And the part where he got to hear Crazy Dog go off on Yeon-joo. Kang Chul 2.0 is the one who got to see Yeon-joo in her real and imperfect life. Kang Chul 1.0 was mostly in his fancy penthouse, where Yeon-joo was an interesting character who came and went outside of his control.

I wish there were more of those scenes for Kang Chul 2.0. That's a love line I'd root for.

0

I don't agree with the commonly held understanding round these parts that he was two different characters/people. I just feel like he's the same guy who woke up missing a chunk of his memories. In real life people black out certain things or have partial amnesia and we don't don't take it as the person died or ceased to exist and consider them a new individual or "2.0." Anyone else? Thoughts?

0

pickledplumtree: It's the same Kang Chul, yes, but they went through such different events and ordeal that has made the post-reset Kang Chul seem a lot more calm and collected than the first one. Hence the 2.0 upgrade. The "I'm a manhwa character" reveal for example, Kang Chul 1.0 responded with rage and depression, while the 2.0 responded rationally and systematically with his hypotheses. In fact, 2.0 continually referred to 1.0 as that guy from the manhwa, and didn't agree with choices that 1.0 made. 1.0 chose to erase that part of his life, after all.

0

You took the words right out of my fingertips. Unfortunately, I kind of saw it coming. I knew W wouldn't be able to keep the amazing storyline for long because there were just too many plotholes. The beginning was mindblowing but at the end of it all I kind of felt empty.
And eeep! Seo In Guk next week! Can't wait for him to be all sweet and cute and fluffy! Loved him Police Unit 38 being all badass, but I love cute Seo In Guk too! See, I'm so excited I can't stop using exclamation marks!

0
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hehehe I get your excitement! Probably because I feel the same :P
I for one didn't foresee so many plot-holes and unexplained things because the writer seemed to know what she was doing! Maybe 16 episodes were not enough to turn her thoughts into a fully coherent show. 20 episodes might have been ideal.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I feel the same, should've been 20 episodes, especially when Song Jae-jung even admitted that she underestimated the miniseries length. You could tell she completed half of the drama before shooting, then realized in the second half that shoot, she's running out of time and had to cramp everything in.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I actually began noticing more and more plotholes along the way, but decided to just go with it because I wanted (WANTEDDD) this drama to awesome, awesomer, awesomest! ?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was what just happened? Is that it?
W ending was, what is the word for it "crap" although I am happy they ended up together.

Is it me or it seemed like the writers, directors and even the actors got tired of the show and just wanted it to end. The female and male lead had this "tired look in their eyes"

If am into the movie business I would have bought this story take it to Hollywood and you'all wouldn't believe what they will do with it.

Awesome plot and they killed it in the end

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

@Arashi_lover this is a little bit on a tangent but - ME TOO! Arashiiiii!!! ??

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

THEY COULD ACTUALLY EXTEND THIS AND JUST CHANGE "THE END" TO "TO BE CONTINUED" AND THEN EXPLAIN TO US ALL THESE PLOT TWISTS

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Wait isn't there a special episode airing for W?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Fingers crossed!!!!!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

i'm in the same boat! it began with a great premise and it was a great start but by the middle, or maybe before the middle, I had resorted to only reading the recaps (as opposed to watching and reading the recaps) and finally I stopped all together...until this final recap. I even forgot that it was still airing.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

first, I would like to give a compliment for this drama. Yes, I little bit feel like "crazy dog" because this drama. But when I see it special episode which title the unfinished story, indeed I assumed maybe this drama not finish yet. There will be a sequele? we don't know yet. For me personally I love this drama too much. the idea a person came into manga or came out was really interesting. But the complicated and very twisted story in the middle it's episodes and also the idea 'it's a dream' to save or to erase bad kang Chul who has been shot oh Yoon Joo father really weird. Actually not weird for me, I knew it will be set like that because I can feel how hard for the writter to choose for the right solution.
I really love Han Hyo Joo and Jong Suk character, hyo joo in this drama play as a bright, clumsy and thinking less woman. Even if some viewer thought her act bad, it wasn't for me. Because the last drama Han Hyo joo I watch is briliant legacy which was she also has a bright character in that drama. So for me I didn't stick with her another character at all. In resume, I just know her very bright person. I didn't know Lee Jong suk much, but for me I like his character when his lost his memory. He calm and manly in that episode, especially when he speak at loud to oh Yoon Joo because she just kept starring and didn't give any help for patient. And the best was Kim Eui Sung character.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was literally just thinking about how the chemistry between Lee Jong Suk and Han Hyo Joo wasn't very believable. You're right, they looked like two actors speaking their lines. Of course, both of them are great actors on their own, it was the supposedly emotional romantic scenes that weren't as heart-wrenching as they were meant to be.

Fans are still waiting for the two to announce that they're dating, LOL. Don't think so, guys. They really couldn't even act like they were in love, so I doubt they are in real life. Oh, well. Let's just ship Lee Sung Kyung and Nam Joo Hyuk instead.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

So that's it…all that drama for a contrived, inexplicable happy ending with plot holes big enough to swallow both worlds. *Sigh*

Well, at least the acting was good and Dad got a poignant goodbye thanks to Kim Eui Sung.

0
77
reply

Required fields are marked *

For example, what polt holes are you referring to? Especially for the ending?

0
27
reply

Required fields are marked *

For me:

1) How did the tablet become a portal to both worlds? Are there others?

2) Since W was supposedly a real world like ours, are there others? Could other webtoon makers access their worlds magically too?

3) Basically what magic allowed the worlds to merge?

4) And this is just me, but the ring and the dead man. Seemed so significant then but nothing now. Red herring I guess but I hoped there was a twist there at some point since they made such a big deal about it.

1
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes all those plot holes.
WHAAAAAT AND WHYYY. I THINK "W" STANDS FOR EITHER.
WHY DID THE TWO WORLDS EVEN COEXIST?
Why was Oh Yeon Joo pulled into that world, really?
What with all those variables or those rules, where it came from?
How did Kang Chul got back in the real world?
I mean, really? I.CANT.EVEN!!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

+100!

I was honestly waiting for bated breath for the ring and the dead man resolution. I was expecting some pretty mind-bendy writing for that - in good faith that the author wouldn't disappoint.

Of course, I don't hate the fact that she didn't address it (W is still a powerhouse drama in its own right), but it would've made everything that much tighter and sent W on its way to the Drama Hall of Fameeeeee!!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Leaving things unexplained isn't a plot hole.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Some of the plot holes:

1. With the manwha over, how did Chul cross over to the real world? Wouldn't the link between the worlds be broken?

2. What rule even allows Chul to be a real human now? How does he establish an identity (docs etc.) in the real world?

3. Is the 'magic' still sitting around in manwha world? How did it come to be in the first place?

4. How are they going to explain Dad's absence from the real world? Chul's absence from the manwha world?

On and on...

1
11
reply

Required fields are marked *

*'magic' tablet

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well. These are not exactly plot holes perse. They are just things for us to figure out according to each of our own understanding. Though I get what you mean.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think they rise to the level of plot holes since they are essential to the themes that drive the whole story: What is real and what isn't? What does it mean to be human? Questions the writer led us to ask, then ultimately ignored.

Also, Dad was essential, the beginning and end of this drama yet he was allowed to disappear from his real life in the real world (the one that matters) without a satisfactory explanation in that world. That's not an open ending, that's a flaw in the writing.

0

How Kang Chul got out of the manwha IS a plot hole. It goes against the logic that was previously already established. It's not just something for us to figure out. It is a inconsistency that was never explained.

Also the manwha ending but the world still carrying on is an inconsistency as well which is a plothole. Even though the reason was given this time, it goes completely against the previous logic that the story had established with the world freezing when Kang Chul chose to end things with his death. The manwha should have still continued with Kang Chuls ending since we still know he was the hero and in control, since it was his choice for the last episode anyway.

0

For the first question, I got reminded the one of the comments below. In episode 13, YJ narrated that after the webtoon ends, KC still can travel back and forth.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

But isn't that narration was YJ's imagination? That she hopes/thinks that the traveling-between-worlds would still work, and KC and her can be happily every after.

But I need a speak-out-loud confirmation that yeah really that way still works, with just one question from YJ about how he came to the real world, and just one sentence from KC that he came here the way he did.

But show fails to gimme that ?

0

I agree!!

Don't get me wrong, it's because I love "W" so much that I disappointed but with such a great writer, how can you leave so many plot holes?

Kang Chul spent 16 episodes showing us that a character's will was as strong as a writer's, that you couldn't just toss a set-up so I don't accept the magical "he came back just because"!

Song Jae-Jung, you're a great writer but please, please stop with the deus ex machinas (it isn't the first time), they seem really lazy!

I love "W" but this ending...more holes than a Gruyere cheese!

1
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

one in, one out. dad remained in, KC came out. enthropy was saved. or if not, then the difference is what caused the creation of an independent univers where W manhwa is reality and we're illusion.

KC could have come out before the drawn tablet disappeared. it's just time flows differently - it happened before, in the previous episode, with the blink-and-you'll-miss-a-year.

the manhwa ended because dad disappeared - end of story, literally. the characters in the story didn't freeze or anything because they were already independent. DAD was the liant - he created the characters and imagined the world, he was the one who set KC's unbreakable will, he is the FIRST to pass in the manhwa and the one who deletes the link when going away. (again, all the missing time and the rest of the lapses are parts of the deleting link, imho.)

for me, it made sense. yes, the KC 2.0 and YJ love story is less fiery - though they're still romantic, but hey, most normal people aren't in a manhwa romance story. a quiet love for quieter people is more normal.

also, they were kind of busy trying to stay alive, lol.

0

err, entropy, universe, etc... lack of attention and second-language problems, sorry.

0

Yeah I wanted to know how KC got back into the real world. Why did he have to stay for 2 more yrs in the manhwa?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I guess we need a Season Two.

"WE NEED A SEASON TWOOOOO"

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

For me it wasn't necessary plot holes, but somewhere in the last 2 weeks, I lost interest in the show. It just seemed to be repeating itself and pulling out cliff hangers and twists just for the sake of shock factor and not organic to the story.

Dad and Lee Jung Suk were stellar. Han Hyo Joo was inconsistent, good with the comedy and not so good with the emotional scenes, she seemed to have regressed even from her Dong Yi days.

All in all, W was good, but could have been better and will be remembered more for being different from the usual, more than for being the masterpiece that the early episodes projected that it would be.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Agree with your comment on Han Hyo Joo, but I think the problem was with the character more than the acting. She had only 2 modes: cry or blank stare.

1
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Right?! I like her character so much more when she had things to accomplish and dialog to deliver. My favorite act from her was the angry tears ramen eating scene at So-hee's apartment. I felt her every pain and injustice.

Since her "death," she more or less got put on autopilot mode, except for maybe the court scene (where stare mode worked). I was so happy when she put the rings back and declared a happy ending possible. But then her very purpose to create that happy ending got taken away from her for the rest of the finale, and she became this lifeless helpless thing. Sigh. Didn't they learn a thing or two about writing characters badly?!?!

0

Like how did he live in this world with no identification, no job, nothing. How would he survive? He couldn't be her home nugget forever. Heck, they can't even legally marry in this world.

0
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hmmm. I don't think the drama will ever be able to answer this. It's up to your own imagination to believe that True Love Can Conquer All and they can Live Happily Ever After.

After all he is a manhwa character she drew that came to life. It's not supposed to be a story that's exactly true to life. Which is part of the magic yeah? Impossible can be possible.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Naturally, someone could turn a blind eye to that. There are rules of reality that were bent, but there were still others that remained, and I think it still makes sense why people would be unhappy with a "True Love Can Conquer All" ending, because it's very shallow way to wrap things up.

Considering the way that W started, it appealed to a lot of people as a well-written and intelligent drama, but it's rather unfortunate that its writing more or less came apart and it became a "just sit back and go with the ride" one instead.

0

@andy pandy
Oh I didn't mean that they wrapped it up with a Happily Ever After for the whole story, because to me it was a bittersweet ending, and they still have many obstacles to overcome. But they have the potential to have a happy ending with each other.
And I totally get why some people are upset about Not Enough Answers.

I just meant it in that we can't question everything that happens because the entire premise it based on something impossible. And to me the story felt consistent throughout in that it didn't break any of its own rules. It didn't explain everything for sure but it didn't contradict itself either. (At least to my simplistic brain it didn't. I may be wrong)

0

He does have an IQ of like 200. I'm sure he could figure out a way to make money/ forge documents. He has a degree in computer engineering so it wouldn't be far fetched to believe that he could probably hack into some government facility and forge his own identity.

Not really a plot hole as others have suggested.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeah, him having no identity in the real world was the least of my concerns about the ending.

0

since it is implied that he could still travel back and forth the 2 worlds, that means he still has access to his wealth and resources in W world.. with his smarts it's not out of the question that he can rebuild his career/ID in this world

what i'd like to know is if people would forever tag him as The Kang Chul cosplayer lol.. he couldn't even change his name now that Mom knows it

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

its basically the same with QIHM..the male lead learn to make false ID in order to live in real world...essentially thats what will KC do...
how he's going to survive that????
dont ask...
a lot of criminals do that in real lives and survive...and so can he if he behave properly...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Agree!
Actually... acting wasn't all that great. Only person I think was doing well was the dad.

1
17
reply

Required fields are marked *

Even by just reading the recaps and watching snippets of the show I can tell just great the actor playing Dad is. He's certainly the biggest surprise, I mean the most pleasant surprise coming out of this show.

I started out really impressed with HHJ but she just fizzled out. LJS on the other hand is as charming as he always is.

I don't know if it's because we had really high expectations from the writer that the finale ended up being a disappointment. Perhaps this show could've been developed into a few seasons. Then that would give her time to really think of the story and the rules.

Having said that, I do wonder how writers pitch out their dramas to broadcasting stations since they would usually end up writing a story as the show is aired. Do they only sell their ideas and the first few scripts to begin with or what?

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

"Do they only sell their ideas and the first few scripts to begin with or what?"

Yes I think that's how it usually works (at least that's what I learned from King of Dramas, lol).

1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Dad looked miserable and scared in 1st few episodes and then growled in front of Kang Chul and then played the role of villain.

When he became the villain His whole acting level changed. I told my brother look at this dangerous guy. How can he be the father of Heroine?

Then he became father but my mind kept on reminding me he is Villain. Then Short shifts from good to bad to good.

Dad did best in Acting.

Hyun Joo did ok. I don't why people are more harsh on her.

Jong Seok was awesome in 1st half of the show.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love all the actors in W.
Dad was a very good actor. So hands down his character was awesome - totally unpredictable, scary and tortured.

And I thought HHJ delivered her part well. Whether perplexed or pining away, she was believable. I feel she did much better in W than her previous works which involved playing mostly sensible and serious character. In W, I think her persona was different from her dongyi/inheritance/iljimae roles. So I find OYJ as HHJ's most endearing k-drama character.

As for LJS I like him a lot here though I have not seen him in Dr Stranger. I do find him less relatable than OYJ or maybe he was just projecting a Manhwa vibe.

I believe the problem lies in a live shooting thst doesn't do justice to a complex script and universe. But I enjoyed the ride and it's been a wonderful and worthwhile W experience for me. Long live W!!!

0

@stuffed Agreed about the acting! Dad was totally surprising. And honestly, LJS seemed to shine more playing Kang Chul 1.0 compared to later on - not sure whether this was an issue of writing, directing, or acting, but his charms really stood out for me at the beginning.

I totally bought every moment with Chul's 1.0 character and was even in love with his flat, semi-emotionless delivery - it seemed idiosyncratic and rather charismatic to me. Then towards the end, I started wondering why his little smirks (and the confession!) just didn't seem to do it for me anymore. ?

I wonder if our expectations were just too high..

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

In my opinion the cast as a whole did good in the acting.

I think this is so not LJS's best work. HHJ is okay BUT do not let her have way too many crying scenes. She makes crying sounds that are awkward without tears. Her emoting is unstable. Sometimes she's doing it right. Other times, completely wrong and awkward. KES is the best. Hats off to Dad!

0
8
reply

Required fields are marked *

'I think this is so not LJS’s best work.'

Is that a typo? You mean so far right?

I could be wrong though, though I personally think LJS leveled up from his last drama.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

IA. if anyone is ever in doubt of LJS' acting prowess i would like to point the way to that 30 minutes monologue/confrontation at the end of ep 5

he's definitely improved

0

LJS's best moments were in the first half of W for me especially his scene confronting Dad and when he first found about his world. I personally think his best work is in DS even though the story was ridiculous.

0

My love for Lee Shi Un is undying so he's my fav actor here.

KES made the drama what it was.

I don't really get the complaints on HHJ, especially not crying complaints. I get that people felt she was over done at some points. But I think the character demanded that. OYJ was a lot to hand and unbalanced. HHJ just portrayed her. And I can't recall times when her emotion wasn't communicated to me. It was my first project with her so maybe I'll notice what everyone is talking about one day.

Personally, the first half was LJS best work. But if we're talking about just his acting no one elsea Pinocchio & Doctor Stranger is still my number 1 and 2 best acting for LJS. He got to show the most in those roles.

But that might be because my judgment of an actor is their ability to:
1) convince me that they are feeling what their lines and actions predict
2) gain my empathy and have me feeling the same as them.

Side note: people have been talking about the way actors cry recently. I'm not trying to give the actors an out. But crying without tears is possible. It probably doesn't fit the textbook definition. But I know people who don't cry so much as get upset. More often than crying, for me is shaking uncontrollably and making crying, sobbibg, squealing noises.

So maybe it is awkward to watch. Nothing again @Celine. But that method of crying is entirely possible and sincere. Real people do it.

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

No biggie! :) I do know that it happens for real too. However, with how HHJ did it in that scene in the hospital, it was obvious that she was acting for me rather than really feeling it as a character; hence, I said that her emoting is unstable. Using what you wrote on your judgement of actor's ability, I was not convinced that she was feeling what she's supposed to feel and I was not feeling it from her as well. Apparently even Korean viewers commented on that same crying scene.

I agree about first half being LJS's best work here. His 30 minutes monologue was intense. I also agree that DS, though it sucked quality-wise, was where LJS showed a wider range of acting. Pinocchio's another one too.

0

Oh... LOL I thought she was dehydrated from too much crying during that part and went "Wow, the hospital scene is so realistic..."

0

@Celine, I agree with the hospital crying scene. And it doesn't help that it really reminded me of Yoo In-na's scene in QIHM which basically had the exact same setup but boy was she delivering.

0

@Celine The prison "Because I love you" confession scene was poorly acted from HHJ's part. I think that one and the Kang Cheol 1.0 shot her scenes stood out to me the most but I absolutely agree, the hospital scene was just as bad.

0

True. Dad was really awesome as both dad and killer. I love HHJ but somehow her acting during the last episode didn't work for me. I only felt her during the I love you scen in the car and when she was in the bus stop while raining. Other than those, I don't feel her sorrow. I was really expecting to bawl over this last episode but that didn't come. I wasn't even ecstatic about how it ended.

They really should compensate us with a lot of "what happens to them" epilogue during tonight's episode.

And oh, thank you girlfriday, for sharing our W experience. That was a very looong comment for a final episode. :)

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

@jellybine I agree with you totally. I am glad someone else shares the same sentiments.
I am sure GF took a long time to write those comments, it's almost like an essay of just the ending. Thank you GF!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I, too, felt a little cheated about the ending. I was expecting so much from this show, and yet too many unanswered questions.

Though I still stuck with it till the end, I was not satisfied with the way it ended.

The first half was exciting and unpredictable but the latter part was just meh.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

So many questions left unanswered. I am not expecting for the writer to explain everything, but the big questions about the worlds were not address.

One of my big questions is how did KC manage to go back to the real world when he's done being the main character of the manhwa world?

Him being able to go back to YJ to live happily ever after without that part being explained makes the ending forced to be a happy one. It was easy.

Like what Korean viewers are saying "W's ending has no context". I wouldn't say entirely no context, but really so much important questions were not answered. It's like the happy ending was just slapped on the viewers.

0
28
reply

Required fields are marked *

Exactly! You can't drive a story with big questions where your viewers tune in to know your answers then fail to even offer one. And I agree, the happy reunion seems to come out of nowhere.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think Arang did a good job at setting up a context i.e. the two worlds and their set of rules. That show left me feeling pretty much satisfied with what they intended the world to be and how the characters are affected.

I saw on Soompi that the writer for this show shared the scripts for the public to read or something. Can anyone enlighten me?

0
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

The script can be downloaded here.
http://m.blog.naver.com/happycatmini/220810553778
But they are in Korean and only up to episode 15.
(Don't be cheated by the "16" on the file title. It is really episode 15. I hvnt check out the script in details yet so I am not sure which part are different from the show. )

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Just found the script for finale has been uploaded in a seperate post.
http://m.blog.naver.com/happycatmini/220812749460

0

Oh my! Thanks Sun! Unfortunately I don't read Korean. I guess I will have to scour the net for the English translation when I can find the time.

0

@sun

thank you so much for the link!! I'm gonna print all out and read!

0

@stuffed This! After all the crazy fantasy work in dramaland, only Arang's ending is plotwise logical and satisfying for me. Mirror of the Witch is second but that's bittersweet (more bitter than sweet for me).

W's ending was a bit forced and seemed rush. It would have been better for this to have additional episodes to explain our unanswered questions.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeah, that was one of my main questions:

- how did Chul come back to this world? why did he have to wait until he went out of prison? what was Dad's part in all this?...

- if the theory of Chul was right about two parallel worlds existing and connected with the tablet, why the characters disappeared when they were not of use for the manwha anymore? this was a very good explanation and I could have bought that W was an independent world going on, such as the story "invented" by Dad coincided with what was going on there. Ufff, anyway my brain cannot take more convoluted disquisitions today...so whatever.

- and the most important: where are all the kisses and the everyday romance that we should have seen before "the end"? :'(

0
14
reply

Required fields are marked *

-Kang Chul is self-aware => as such, he can travel between the worlds at will; the final episode blocking interdimensional travel has ended, therefore, he can freely travel again.

-Why did he wait until he got out of prison?
If he escapes prison with dimensional travel, the prison guards have an UNEXPLAINED plothole that might lead to their self-awareness and the manhwa world freezing up?
By serving his sentence, and then dropping off the face of public scrutinity, he can disappear without anyone wondering where went.

-If KC's theory of two independent worlds existing is true, why did we have "sudden existence failure" as threat for various characters in the manhwa world?

Well, obviously the theory is wrong. The worlds are not independent at all, but can influence each other on several levels:

1) The writer can influence the world/its characters by writing/drawing. This has been consistent from Episode 1 to 16. The nurse attempting to kill KC, without knowing why, the faceless murderer, especially that Lawyer Han Cheol Ho who "committed suicide" because the writer wanted it that way.

2) Both humans (Dad, YJ) and manhwa characters(Chul, Face, Han Cheol Ho, that girl sidekick...) can travel between the worlds; sometimes voluntarily, sometimes against their will

3) If the "divide" between the worlds is large, then the ability to influence each other is very disparate => the manhwa world can hardly do anything, the author is invincible, etc...

But if the "divide" lessens, the lines are blurred, then the manhwa rules "infect" the humans and allow them to be affected;
similarly, the manhwa characters in the real world gain "real-world" characteristics, aka the ability to influence and kill humans, the ability to reflect on the existence of a second world, to travel at will between the worlds, etc...

What are the manhwa-world-rules?
1) As long as the manhwa W runs, the real world exerts influence on the manhwa world; this is the cause of the mind-control of characters according to the authors whim, and the cause of the flickering if a character acts against his settings WHILE THE READERS ARE WATCHING.

As soon as the manhwa ends, the flickering/mind control stops, and the manhwa world regains its independence.

2) Tropes apply - hence YJ being able to perform a difficult procedure on the first attempt to save KC in the beginning - a failure might have been realistic, but not narratively/dramatically appropriate.

-Why no "pay-off", aka kisses/romance to calm down after this horrible whirlwind of DRAMA and DANGER and CONFUSION?

... the recent events would have made such a thing very atypical - YJ lost her dad to a tragedy and is still recovering, KC needs to establish an ID in the real world, Su Bong needs to recover and probably find a new job...

The most the show could give us was a hopeful glimpse of an uncertain future, that will be hopefully dreadfully boring and ordinary...and happy.

1
12
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you for verbalizing every words I cannot splurt out. This drama is still messy with all of the loose end and unexplained matter. But it doesn't stray from its rules either. It's still consistent with what has been established. And that's one point that still make me hung up with it.

0

This! I agree with this.

0

Wow.. thank you for your explanation. Now i understand a bit about some unexplained question.

0

WOW...you summarize everything perfectly... there is no inconsistency if we follow the story properly ..the rule stay the same...the variables the same

trust me... i am one of few people who are too dumb for this kind of drama, but if someone can explain the rules like you, then i can understand the story more :)

0

Wow. What an explanation. Thanks, but still, it would have been better if the drama actually showed/supported/established these rules clearly instead of just having Kang Chul and others talking about it. I think that's one of my biggest problems in the second half of this drama. The rules were very clear at the start because they showed OYJ testing them, living them, and being affected by them. Then in the second half, Kang Chul decided/figured out on his own that he could travel back and forth between the two worlds without actually establishing a believable reason behind his sudden awareness (second-time around coz he forgot about it). The way he accepted everything after reading the comics YJ left behind, how he started being so all-so-mighty by being able to travel at will, just felt so inconsistent with the first half.

I'd love it more if the drama focused on Kang Chul trying to validate and make sense of his existence, how he came to be, and the factors leading to him being self aware. I would have loved it if he explored the boundaries of his manhwa world more and learn how the two worlds influence each other.

I would have liked this drama more if it clarifies things every now and then and I don't have to rely to other people's interpretations. I am thankful for those who try to clarify some stuff, but again, it's just the viewers interpretation and not the writers or the directors or the drama. And now that the drama is done, we won't have REAL explanations to everything.

Just glad that this drama ended. I am so done with it and so looking forward to moving on to Jealousy Incarnate.

0

the number of people needing clarificationn for this just shows the drama has not done a good job in explaining it.

0

Thanks for your explanation. I was confused with the ending. I think W is one of the drama that would benefit from more episodes towards the end. I am glad that MBC took a chance with W. I agree that the director is good and the actor that played Dad is awesome. He is a villain that gives me a nightmare, but I cried as well towards the ending. Some awards for W, please.

0

Thanks for your great explanation! *thumbs up* :)

To add my 2 cents worth on why the villains' death were not portrayed to the w comic in real world. Yeon Joo mentioned in ep 2 to Su Bong the rules that because w comic revolves around Kang Chul, what unrelated things others do elsewhere and their thoughts are not displayed in the comic. Thus, when dad killed off Han Cheol Ho, that arc has no relation to Kang Chul coz he already fulfilled his arc of being shot and collapsing on the curb. That arc only pertained to dad and Han. Thus the readers in the real world didn't get to read that arc.
Hope this helps. My take is there is w world, real world and w comic portrayed in real world. So what readers read is not everything that happens in w world. Even the part when Yeon Joo met So Hee at hotel is probably not drawn out in w comic since there's no kang chul in that scene. Yeon Joo probably only appeared in w comic at courthouse scene.

On how Kang Chul came back to real world. In ep 12, he mentioned his 2nd hypothesis of leaving w world when you fulfil the mission for that chapter. Since Kang Chul, Yeon Joo and Dad were summoned to w world for the final episode (at different timelines!). When Yeon Joo sees End chyron she is transported back to real world since she fulfilled her mission. Dad betrayed his character synopsis prescribed in w comic and vanished. Kang Chul haven't fulfil his mission of his character hero description. Thus he had to be jailed for 2 years before his mission is fulfilled and his End chyron comes too for him to go back to real world? This is purely hypothesis to make myself feel better though, lol.

And show, you still owe the 5 kisses!!!!
Pls make up for it by showing all the bts of the kiss scenes in the Special. *pleading wish*

0

Okay after giving it some thought, something came to me, the webtoon didn't show SM/villain dying, because he had already died, remember KC killed the villain (after YJ got shot). So in the webtoon world the villain is already dead. SM is probably a severe glitch, where he got infected with the villain's memories/impulses once the villain died.

Also about why KC took the news so well the second time around, the way I see it is that KC had a month to accept the facts as he waited to meet YJ for some answers, after reading the webtoon. Second the first sequence of events may have been turned into a dream, but the events still happened. Dreams can sometimes be very vivid, and we remember them. So even though KC at that point didn't remember the "dream" his subconscious already knew. This also explains why YJ was being pulled again into the webtoon even after the reset, and she running into KC at similar times as the original sequence.

On a side note, this is also why I choose to believe that in the end, when KC reunited with YJ in the hospital he had regained all his memories, and remembers his "dream"

0

You summed it up very nicely! Thank you! I wish the show explained these things more clearly

0

Thanks, very well explained !! at the end, the writer has explained to us why the ending is boring and ordinary... hahaha...

0

Do-yoon also became aware of existing in a manwha world however. Is he ganna come over to the 'real world' ? Or maybe it's his choice to just keep living his 'manwha' life.

0

Just watch the BTS for ep 16 --- even HHJ complained there were still 3 kisses left :), but the director told her to kiss passionately for the amount of 3 kisses to make up. I felt much better after watching the BTS, sweeter and more beautiful than the real show.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

W's ending has no context, maybe it's because YJ's world is actually a manhwa. See the "The End" chyron at the very end?
*Desperately trying to make peace with whatever ending the writer gives*

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Actually, that is a very good observation - but not *quite* correct.

As i understand it, YJ's world is not a manhwa, but...
a Kdrama, that we have been watching.

The "The End" chyron at the end was simply a subtle way of breaking the fourth wall.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Haha I know. I'm just trying to hypnotize myself into accepting the ending.

0

Actually, when i saw End chyron in real world, part of me is half wishing that is manhwa world too. That would explain how the all powerful tablet came to have such super powers to even pull real people into w world. So w world is like manhwa inside manhwa? That would be so cool. Then that means Yeon Joo is hopping over from her romance story in real manhwa world to guest in a thriller story in w manhwa world, lol. And Kang Chul escaping his thriller genre in w manhwa to be in romance genre in real manhwa. Lololol.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The fact that it ended with no twist for me was the reason I want my questions answered.

If it had ended with the words, to be continued. And then the screen turned into a different color that signifies that we are in another world, would have made it better for me.

At least that way, I would have accepted that these questions will not be answered here. And that more questions will arise. This is what science fiction supposed to do. I just hate that the drama ended as a romance.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

omg yes!! I was expecting a "to be continued" after that last scene and a change on the colours. it would be bold and amazing tbh

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't know if people will see this but for those who are not satisfied, Song Jae Jung uploaded all 16 of the episode scripts on her blog here:
it's obviously in hangul and if you can't read it well...
there's also a W sp episode with interviews, commentary and other stuff that would also help clarify things for viewers. Writer jung already said that the drama was only able to cover a very small amount of the actual scripts she wrote. I'd be surprised if most of the stuff people want answers or further explanation for are not addressed in either the SP or the scripts. idk if anyone is going to sub the SP either (let alone translate 16 drama scripts lol)
So yeah if you know korean, then u have these options available to you. if you don't then...sorry lol (i dont know hangul either, but it's one of the languages im studying atm, so perhaps one day i will. i really want to read her scripts!)

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oooooooooh. If we could get our hands on that, that'd be great!!!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

to be continued.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Another annoying part is that they made reference to the fact that Yeon Joo created Kang Chul and they used that fact to do ABSOLUTELY NOTHING. They twisted the story so much that they lost their way

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I tink the main purpose is just that she is also one of the creator and hence can draw him

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

We got our happy ending!!!!!!!!!

I think this was a great send off for an awesome series. Although it was a bit more tame than what we usually get, I was still on the edge of my seat. Honestly, I had no clue where Song Jae-sung was taking us but it was an enjoyable and somewhat crazy ride. Chul got shot in the first 10 minutes and I was literally screaming, "Really Jae-sung?!" But even that wasn't enough! She had to make him freaking die and disappear before Yeon-joo's eyes. Because apparently we needed Chul to die again. I was legit feeling like Crazy Dog at that 'ending'!

But then we got that wonderful narration from Soo-bong and I let out a huge sigh of relief. I knew he wouldn't die. She wouldn't have killed him right??! That would be crazy!

And she didn't! And they were reunited and it felt so good! I'm smiling so hard right now it's ridiculous!

I'm sad about YJ's Dad but I like that HE made the decision to make the sacrifice for everyone. It was the right thing to do. That was probably one of the best if not saddest decisions he made this whole series.

To say I'm sad that the journey has ended for W is an understatement. I will miss this crazy show so much. Everything was top-notch! The acting, the writing, the directing. It was all good! And the ending... It was everything I wanted and then some!!

P.S- I could have gotten more kisses but that's just my personal complaint.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Forget the convolutedly convenient rules of the drama for a second.

How on earth is it a happy ending when the story ends with the person whose profession is just a writer dying with no one knowing the better to remember him by, when the worst he has done is kill a fictional person in a world where things can disappear anyway. Through no will of his own I might add. Let's say he's a horrible being. Poor guy didn't even went through trial and even went insane. If Sohee manages not to disappear, so should others. You have a FREAKING TABLET!!! Where in my life can I just draw and redraw anything to my convenience??? I sure as hell would use it better.

Is Kang Chul going to have to lie the rest of his "happy" life to Oh Yeon Joo about the most significant thing in her life? Sure, she's not going to start missing her father, and wonder how he's doing, and what's happening to his life on the other side. She's not going to try to find a way to get there. And Kang Chul won't have to lie through his teeth. What a beautiful relationship. What a happy fulfilling life. What a cosplay and mockery of the "happy ending" it touted. As this drama told us itself, Romance should NOT be everything even if you want it to.

Drama, I don't regret knowing you, but I sure as hell regret the way you chew more than you could bite. Arrogance over your own cleverness is a no no. I can't believe I'm saying this, but this drama conned me better than Squad 38 into believing in it.

0
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't think that KC lied to YJ, because the minute he showed her that photo she knew that her father had disappeared/died. This also explains why she cried bitterly in KC's arms. I mean she already knew that KC and SM couldn't both have the happy ending, one of them had to go.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

in the last few eps the premise is that the W world is an ACTUAL world in parallel dimensions, with the manhwa as a bridge of sorts. the only fictional characters in that world are the ones drawn by OSM, so the nurse was actually a real person in that world

and i think YJ understood what happened to dad when KC gave her that picture

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Exactly, therefore the title "W - Two Worlds".

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Exactly my feelings after the finale. Why did OSM had to die and what wrong did he do to deserve that and us to believe that it was for the better? His death to me is equivalent to that of the prosecutor in city hunter and Eun Shi Kyung in King 2 hearts. It was just a sacrifice. And I think that scene when KC showed YJ the picture meant that he told her that he died. He did not lie about his father being alive.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I also agree with @sweet&sour that YJ knew Dad was gone. Because all 3 of them knew that it was either KC or Dad. And to me, Dad giving her his photo was a way of saying, remember me like I am in this picture, not the me you saw at the end. And if dad had been alive, KC would have just said so. Some things are impossible to say out loud because they hurt too much.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Sad, right? Even though she denied having to choose between Dad and Kang Chul, and she insisted that there must be a way for all three of them to have a happy ending together. In the end, her choice to put the rings back on their fingers virtually foreshadowed Dad's disappearance. At least it was very well executed as Dad's own decision after finishing his job as the manhwa's creator.

Why the sacrifice of Dad's character? No-Face was undoubtedly a creation of Dad's hands while he was in a hopeless state. A creation gone so wrong, he murdered countless innocent people in both worlds. A creation so crucially representative of the dark side of Dad's mind that their face and memories became intertwined. I know making up a bad character is not a crime worthy of the punishment of death, but I saw no other logical way out for Dad at this point in the story. He's become so wretched between his uncontrollable urge for violence, his guilt, and his other self inflicted health and mental issues. I thought this was a rather humane ending for him.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

He didn't lie to her! He showed her the picture and she burst crying. She totally understood!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The moment I understood why the webtoon actually had a happy ending and KC was not dead. *goosebumps*

0
11
reply

Required fields are marked *

Right?! I'm glad I noticed the third car Chekhov.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

You noticed?? Wow!!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well, there was one car - KC which was abandoned
Then a second car -YJ the driver got out.

While I was yelling at her not to cross the street with traffic, I saw it.
A third car, oddly not moving. Not signaling for a turn. Not seeming to be waiting for YJ. They didn't even hit their horn to get her attention. Why? Wae? It better not be the assemblyman?!

And then the flashback explained it all, what happened with the assemblyman and the 3rd driver.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Can you please enlighten less astute individuals such as myself? Lol. =D

0
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Dad made himself disappear because he killed the other villain and helped to get KC's happy ending, which is entirely against his pre-setting.

The moment the two villains died and disappeared, the webtoon ended. With KC lying on the curb alive.

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

So in reality, Chul simply had to take out the villain to make the manwha survive? Thats it? That's lame.

We were led to believe that it was something other than that...I would have believed it more if they told me that the tablet was powered by magical energizer batteries from another universe!

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Heck, what I wanted to know is how the webtoon is being sent to the editors and uploaded. O.o

0

I think you misunderstood here.

Of course if KC took out the villains then it would be the end.

However, at first, one of the villains, the culprit, can not be identified cause it has no face no id no character no background.

Later, when the culprit was given an ID which is the author. Then KC could not kill the author because that's Dad. This is the dilemma.

Think about it. There is a main character with a god-like tablet. He could have rule the webtoon world if he wanted with that device. But no he could not. because the villain was dad.

0

Honestly, it wasn't about no-face getting his face or the absurdity of OSM using his face for the killer or even the face swapping that happened. This is about closure. There should have been more depth and meaning in a show that banked on trivial pursuits and illogical metas. And we didn't really get that in the end. So that's my frustration for the day.

I would have even believed if they used shrodingers cat theory. At least that made sense.

The david copperfield act of disappearing was a cheapstake rip-off move to use for OSM's ultimate sacrifice. They could have done better, they really could.

0

anyone else lol'd at the fact that the 2 bodyguards waited outside like good puppies while their employer was beaten to a bloody pulp inside the warehouse?? xDD and they even let KC head inside *alone* afterwards

they deserve an award for being the worst bodyguards ever and DY should sue their asses off for not doing their job

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hmm... I'd rather think the manhwa world got a happy ending but not the W manhwa itself (the one people were reading) since people didn't see the death of the villains but the hero's death.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

What a ride! I loved it. Still processing this last episode, but I loved it the whole series. Watching LJS has always been a treat. More, please! ??

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Okay how many of you did W hand sign before starting the episode?

0
10
reply

Required fields are marked *

I didn't remember until 7 minutes in. So I pause and did the hand sign.

Does that count?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I swore to do it but forgot all about it until now. OMG. Why!!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

OMG same shit i forgot

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Did it right before I started the finale ep--my boyfriend thought I was a dork.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I watched finale in the mid night so nobody at home noticed me doing hand sign while offering prayer n full body W. Haha avoided looking crazy

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I didn't do the hand sign, lol. I just pictured crazy dog doing it again in my mind before i started watching that's all :p
Watched once the subs were uploaded at 3am today morning, lol

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

i tweeted a gif of crazy dog doing it- does that count? xD

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Counts for me!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes it does!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

To perfectly imitate Crazy Dog's, I did it several times haha.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I once had a soul
Now it has a W shaped hole
I'll never be whole

T^T

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm the 9th OP. And we're at 28 comments in like 6 minutes. I wonder how high we will go, kekeke.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Someone mentioned this the 2nd time Chul attempted suicide.

Between KC's close attempt at 19, to his 2nd attempt that the villain denied, to his 3rd success to reset the world, assemblyman having a gun forced upon him and aimed at his own head, appa's sacrifice.

It really was a PSA for suicide. Though I think for the mass public, it was more of a reminder of how fleeting life is. And how we live will matter when we die if we enjoyed the time we had, we'll reminisce positively. If we gave way to doubts and didn't live our lives according to our morals, values and wants, it will be numbing as we face death. For suicidal ideation patients, this should come with a trigger warning.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I once had a soul
Now it has a W shaped hole
I’ll never be whole

But if w is gone, does your last line become "I'll never be hole"?

So in effect, you're not a hole, you're complete again! :O PLOT TWIST!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Mary you are best! I laughed tears :p

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeah!!! I survived! I would have liked a bit more post prison life, but I am so ridiculously happy to get a happy ending that I can't find it in my heart to complain much.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

(based on QIHM)
there will be a time jump
kc will go to the real world

kc will “die” in W
dy stays in W :(

(based on nine)
kc will die in W, somehow will live in real world
kc will meet yj as someone who does not know of their past (NOOOOO)

Finally! I’ve been refreshing since I finished watching.

First of all, I like that the ending DID have logical reasons for the events that happened with accordance to the rules of the W world, and that we did not have KC’s doppelgänger live out the happy ending for us and for YJ. While others did not like what happened to Daddy Oh, I believe that it is the best possible way for him to redeem himself— did everyone just forget how much we hated him before? Through this, he showed how much a father's love is unlike any other. Aside from that, if he had lived, every single day would be torture, with the New-Face’s memories with him, and the memory of him killing his daughter will cause him so much pain.

Second, I would like to say that as much as I loved the ride, the ending felt a bit lacking, and I had a hard time accepting this since I looooove (as in LOOOOVE) W so much, and throughout the drama ever since KC woke up from the “dream,” when things started to get a bit messy (SO MUCH SO THAT THE COMMENT COUNT DECREASED BY A TON HERE ON DB), I gave the drama the benefit of explaining things further in the next episodes to come. However, as soon as I saw the last episode, the things that I wanted to be explained and shown were left unanswered. I blame MBC (sorry I need a scapegoat), because it’s obvious that Song Jae Jung tried her best in writing the drama that she wanted, but it is the station that was not flexible enough to fit all of her ideas in the drama (there was an option 4 in Episode 9, and I also read somewhere that there are a lot of romantic scenes that were not filmed/ did not make it to the cut because she had to make do with the 16-episode limit. I also blame the slow pace in the middle that made people bail out on this drama on the Olympics because the production team only did that so that the flow of the story and the cliffhangers would not be ruined. Oh the what-ifs…

As I expected, the finale had the Song Jae Jung touch (based on QIHM):
1. there will be a time jump
2. KC will go to the real world
3. KC will “die” in W
4. DY stays in W :(
5. there will be an failed meeting (like in QIHM when he disappeared after meeting eyes)

If I were the writer, I would have included the following to make the ending more satisfying:
1. (this is based on the QIHM’s ending) Some sort of dedication for KC, where YJ will take a part in it (probably W the movie or something)… and then KC shooting into fame because he looks like KC so much HAHA
2. SB after the whole fiasco (probably meeting SH just once? I just want him to be happy…)
3. Crazy Dog’s face when he knew that his most hated YJ in the manhwa is his hoobae YJ, and that she is married to the KC that he is invested so...

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

[DAMMIT IT WAS CUT]

...much on
4. the lives of our characters in the parallel world, with DY and SH happily working at the foundation for crime investigation
5. wedding of KC and YJ after they grieve for Daddy’s death
6. Option 4!!!! That bed scene in the hospital is NOT the bed scene that we were expecting!!!

From the pilot episode, I expected that this drama will surpass all of the dramas that I have ever watched and be my top 1 all-time favorite but the ending kind of ruined it for me. ALTHOUGH, I still consider it as one of the top-tier dramas (along with healer, pinocchio, and my love from another star). IHYV remains at the top only because of the gap between this and IHYV’s endings.

Some questions, though:
1. What was in the prosecutor’s last will, and why did KC serve 2 years time in spite of that? Also, why two years? YJ’s age gap with KC when she made him does not match :( Could’ve been more brilliant if their age gap during that time and forever will be the same (I believe they only have a gap of 2 years, so KC should have served a year in prison only. PETTY I KNOW)
2. Is KC still able to teleport between the two worlds?
3. How will KC live in the real world without identification? (whatever, I just want the writer to tell me so my heart is at peace and leave the two knowing they’ll be fine)
4. How did KC go to the real world?
5. What does YJ know about her father? Did KC tell the truth? Or did he lie as Daddy Oh’s will told him to do so?
6. Why did the manhwa not stop with the prosecutor’s knowledge of the truth behind his existence?
7. Why did the manhwa end with the villains dying? I mean, there’s the other thing about the character finishing his story, right?

No matter how vague the ending appeared to be, I will definitely miss this drama that I love so much. Kudos to the writer, actors, and the whole production team! You should check out the BTS clips from the last scene, idk if these two are dating or not:
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CsU8aXtWIAAW08U.jpg MY BABIES AND THEIR INTERLOCKING HANDS!!! THEY’RE SO CUTE I CANT!!!! <3

(PS. They ended with a 9.3% rating… :| Oh well)

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I loved that BTS scene. (Sometimes I think there is more chemistry in BTS than the actual later episodes.) That last BTS had all the happy feels that I was hoping to find in the final episode (with some bittersweet, too--I was touched how sad HHJ seemed to be about leaving her character behind). I'm mentally tacking that to the end of the show.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

In reply to your questions at the end. They mirrored mine almost exactly.

1. Why rot in jail if you can now magically teleport like you used to? But, barring that question, I am assuming he did time for evading police, escaping custody etc. Not for any major crime but still breaking the law.

2. My major problem with this ending is the zero explanation on how he is able to teleport again. I was waiting for him to explain it to her at the very end how he returned. Can he go back and forth? Or is he now permanently in our world??

3. I am assuming he will find a really great forger. Hahaha

4. Refer to #2

5. This question I am fairly confident in answering. He told her the truth that her father died. That photo is very much like a photo one would ise for ones funeral. So he in essence handed her her fathers funeral photo. She cried knowing her dad is dead. KC would not let her go theough life with some sense of false hope he could return. She might plot some grand rescue if she believed he was alive in the other world. (Especially if KC can still go back and forth!!!!)

6. Your guess as good as mine

7. My number two biggest problem with the ending. Why would the story end once the antagonist died??? I call BS big time. The prosecutors death just ends one chapter of the overall storyline. I am sorry, there is always follow up for the heroes once the bad guy dies. The story didn't end once the White Witch died in The Lion the Witch and the Wardrobe. No, we got to see them become kings and queens and return back to the real world. Whatever show...?

A really good show that got a bit ahead of itself. Dad's death seemed anticlimactic. The ahow seemed to have lost some of its urgency. It just wasn't able to play out satisfactorily to the end. Still glad I watched it, definitely made you think.

I do have to pat myself on the back for knowing that dad was going to be the bad guy from episode one.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

the BTS final scene is gold ! especially moment when after their final kiss scene and they just looked at each other for 1-2 second and smiled... love love it !!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Many things are left unexplained. There are loose ends everywhere that couldn't be tied in one single bow. There is no elegant explanation for all of the damned calamity that happened for a full 9 weeks. It is all scattered there for us to pick and rearrange per our own imagination. But I don't care about those every little things anymore. I don't even remember about unanswered questions that keep bothering me for several episodes. I simply forgot them all. All I know is now I feel content that it has ended. A magic story that lost its magic charm is still magic to me. A magical Pinocchio who wish to be a real boy is enchanting me till the end.
No matter in what alternative the story ends, I would tear up. Because someone still have to make a mortal sacrifice in the end of the journey. And that only means sad ending for me. Becoming a widow is as much painful as becoming a fatherless child.

Everyone could be giggling when Yeon Joo wakeup in her husband's arms. But I can't. I couldn't just forget the cost they have to pay for their happiness. I would just curling up in the corner here, whimpering with face full of tears, waiting for the grieve to pass. It is still one of the best drama in my record, but for the time being, I just want to cry.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

"I couldn't just forget the cost they have to pay for their happiness"

This. Everytime Yeonjoo sees Chul, she will be reminded of her own father, who disappeared in the manhwa alone, FOREVER. How's she going to live a happy life with Chul with that horrible realization?

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think she can, if she realizes that untametly it was dad's decision. He had been living in years of misery and regret. He made KC everything he was not. He made KC to be the hero: brave and selfless. However, dad in his final moments was able to be brave and selfless and truly be there for his daughter. He was able to be the hero.

He would have continued to be miserable if he had not made the decision that he did. He may have not lived valiantly but he was certainly able to die that way.

The ending is bittersweet, but still fitting for the main character arcs.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Kang Chul and Yeon Joo would need a very long time to get over the horror I think. To get pass the mourn and grieve. I belive that Yeon Joo knows that her father had disappered forever, and Kang Chul understand this. They are mutually understand the consequence beforehand, and know what her dad wish for them. They wouldn't be truly happy for some times ahead. A year or two. But time would heal their pain. They said "happy ending" but it is really just a moment of rest for them. Where they don't have to be afraid of losing their life anymore. When they can just sit by the river and enjoying the sunset without have to be in nerve wrecked afraid of a flying bullet or flickering hands. They would be fully happy later. When they can accept dad's death and move on with life.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Does anyone know where to find SJJ's translated scripts of W that she released?

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I knew since the day OSM lost his tace that he would have to sacrifice himself. But i thought that the reason they made him die or perhaps suicide wasn't right. I felt like linking the his scenario to that of mental health and mentally ill patients. Like just because people's actions aren't in their control, they don't deserve to die.

Hats off to KES. I hardly cry in a drama but that scene where he looks at OYJ from afar was perfect. He was the best actor in W.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's over. It's over. I can't believe it's over.

I am fairly satisfied with the ending, but I must say I nearly bawled when Dad said bye to Yeon Joo. That was some stellar acting on his part.

I am also glad I did not read that manhwa for the last seven years. I would have been pissed. Just imagine if Conan or One Piece ended like that... Man.

But in the end, thankful for this whirlwind ride of a drama. It was unpredictable, which is pretty rare now in dramaland. W fighting!!!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't want to even imagine what fans would do if Conan ended bad.. Poor writer.. o.o

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Is W really end? Honestly, I want more.

It's happy ending, but I'm a bit sad. I feel both of the leads are not fully happy at the ending scene. I think it's because of Dad's disappearance. Even though Chul didn't tell Yeonjoo about that, imo she knows that.

There's no enough happy moments at the ending to compensate my tears from earlier part of this episode. The scenes of Chul dying and Dad saying love to his daughter are really heartbreaking. For the first time I can genuinely sympathize with Dad.

For the hero and heroine, I really want to see they actually get married. They said that they are married, but they haven't had wedding ceremony yet. Even Chul haven't ever put the wedding ring on Yeonjoo's finger, she always put it on by herself.

Anyway, I'm still glad that it's good happy ending.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm just gna assume that the last chyron meant that OYJ's world was also a manhwa. Yup. That's what I am going with.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I actually thought that when the chyron showed up.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

@Melrak follower above said this above:

"As i understand it, YJ’s world is not a manhwa, but…
a Kdrama, that we have been watching.

The “The End” chyron at the end was simply a subtle way of breaking the fourth wall."

And I agree! ?

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Man, that chyron was for us too see, to eject us out of the kdrama, putting us back in our own world. The ride is over :(

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

well that was.. anticlimactic..

it's like they've used up all the 'real' endings in previous episodes and this is the leftover

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The finale is kinda anticlimax. I was like, "Wait..that's it?" They didn't even explain how KC came back to the real world. I suppose we should just assume that he regained the ability to summon himself into the real world even after the webtoon ended, after he was no loner the protagonist of the webtoon.

Such a big disappointment despite the apparent "happy ending".

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeah. The drama promised too much. I wanted a happy ending, if possible, but I really wanted it to make sense.

Although it's not the brilliant drama I thought it would be, it was still pretty good. But I'm gonna have to mourn a little because for 9 amazing episodes I LOVED everything about this drama. I was sure it would find a place in my top 5, but sadly, no.

Still, A+ for effort! And I appreciate the writer's ambition. I hope more writers take these kinds of risks.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

In my drama records:
W Two Worlds (2016)- 6 EPISODES

(although EP 7-11 had their good moments but the continued momentum and excitement were in 1-6)

I still give props to SJJ for effort but I think she got confused with her own writing. Someone commented before that the complexity of this drama is also its undoing in a way. I wished SJJ finished all the script beforehand. It turned out she was writing as the drama went along.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

i have no idea that this drama has promise something grand in his hand...even song jae jung only hoping people will at least can follow up until 4th episode

i guess.. with Nine and QIHM name attached to her name, people anticipate too much for superb ending ...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

From what I read in the discussion of epsiode 15, some of us predicted correctly; in the end, it had to be the author who made the sacrifice. That letter read by KC in the prison brings everything to a full circle. So good.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

We were all hoping for a heroic moment for Su-bong in this episode, but it didn't happen :(

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

this drama... oh my goodness where do I even begin? what do I even say?

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

No matter what anyone says, I still whole-heartedly loved this show to pieces, despite the loose strings..

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

What a great drama! Of course, it had its plot holes and continuity problems and everything, but it was so entertaining to watch. I haven't watched something with so many twists and surprises in quite some time so I thoroughly enjoyed W! Thanks for a wild ride, W!

I am so happy that it ended happy between KC and YJ. KC was able to overcome his predetermined fate and make his own fate. I think that's something I can learn about myself: there is nothing determining what I can and cannot do in my life. Of course, things might not always go as planned, but I can move forward. It was sad that the dad had to sacrifice himself, but it was a redemption on his part for being somewhat lacking as a father to be able to give his daughter the chance at a happy life with the only decision he had left.

My Wednesday's and Thursday's won't be the same anymore now that this is over! Thanks again W and thanks to dramabeans and all my fellow beanies for making this drama such a fun experience!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The ending was okay but feel a little rushed. So much questions are not answered like GF said and i'm sad that dad had to gone like that. But still W was fantastic drama with fresh story, great artwork, music, directing and acting. I will surely check this writer drama in the future.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Show, thank you so much for:
-- a wonderful story. Eventhough it was a bit hard at times to follow, or some might question the (lack of) logic, I thank you for the nonetheless great ride,
- shocking me with your story twists,
- the wonderful OST and choices of instrumental music,
- the beautiful visuals, the colors...
- the awesome visual effects and beautiful comic strips,
- not letting your cast wear strange clothing, with the exception of the traffic light suit and in my opinion, checkered suit,
- forgoing the Subway PPL,
- letting me guess that the W world didn't freeze after the ending, that DT, SH and others do still continue to live on,
- giving a nod to us through Crazy Dog,
- making me despise a villain and yet making me cry when he/Dad sacrificed himself,
- breaking my heart when KC needed to see his wife one last time,
- and an unforgettable cast. I will so miss SoBong, YJ and KC.

Thank you, Show !

And thank you DB team for all the recaps !

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

+100

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

So I just read some of the previous comments about the ending.

Personally, I liked it. It was bittersweet. But I was okay with it, considering all that just happened to the characters. I'm not sure that I would have felt that happy if we were watching KC dying, Dad dying and then wham, time jump, KC and YJ married with kids and happy.

When YJ asked KC about her dad and he remained silent, I took it as she understood what happened. She knew that only one of them (KC or Dad) could only survive. And with all that happened , I took the meaning of 'happy ending" as the stops to the killings and madness, and them being safe. I didnt take it -anymore- as KC and YJ being all lovey dovey. That would happen in time. For now, them being reunited without worrying about being killed or separated at any time, is a relief.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

uhmm okay... it ended.

That was the longest, uneventful final episode I've seen (at least in my recent memory). It was a huge letdown and I'm not surprised that after spending comfortable time in the double digit, the last episode's ratings dropped.

I wonder what happened to Song Jae Jung. The first half of W felt like it was written by a brilliant writer and the second half by someone else. Everything fell apart when KC went back to the real world the second time. It was there that things start to really crumble.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

But the way they reversed the ending is amazing, I would not call it uneventful?

The rating drop was due to the holiday btw.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I figured he couldn't have died just yet, so it was not a great reverse for me.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

"The first half of W felt like it was written by a brilliant writer and the second half by someone else."

So true.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ummm...what. the. f*ck. How on God's green earth did he get back to the real world (and obtain a car)??? That was the whole problem for the last few episodes - in that he couldn't get out! If he could escape once the final chapter concluded, then why did he choose to rot in jail?? I am confused and conflicted. Too many feeellllzzz. Anyone have a satisfactory answer as to what the hell just went down?? Help me!!!! I want to love this drama, but I just ended up getting confused. Also, why would the story end once the antagonist died? Sorry, that's never the end of stories. The story didn't end once the Death Star blew up and Vader was tossed into space, no, the heroes got medals while awesome music played in the background. Wow, I ranted quite a bit...sigh....I'll just stop now. ?

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank God, Song Jae Jung provide us with 8 minutes imaginary sequence made by Yeon Joo. If you even wonder how the hell things are working, you can always go back to early part of episode 13. A repeat explanation is redundant for duration's sake afterall. Kang Chul in fact still can travel between both world. And he is the only human being who is capable to do so as he is the only one who knows how. He's unable to travel the first time because of the final episode arc. When it is ended he can go back again between world. He choose not to after the second times he go back to jail because he have to serve his purpose back as hero so he can come back clear to Yeon Joo. Escape one more time as a fugitive wouldn't do him any good. The mystery is what had happened to hypothesis number. 3? Is it still in place? Because apparently as the manwha story has ended, it doesn't need to suck in and out character from the real world for plot's sake.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

This exactly! The show did suffer from the preemption, but the rules are laid out through the episodes and actually remain remarkably consistent. I also appreciate the writer for respecting the audience's intelligence, I hate those shows that treat us like toddlers and explain Every. Little. Detail.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think Episode 13 started the problems for me. Kang Chul explained and talked about how his world runs on its own independent of the real world and most viewers just took it in. Even if it's all just talk without validation. Then he decided that he can summon himself, and he did, and all was good. Like really? Just because he said he could and he wanted to, he does just that, and we are supposed to just accept that?

This is so different from Nine, where Sun Woo tested the incense sticks and by doing that, realized that he could changed events from the past and also learned how it could work to his advantage. I expected W to be like that, with Kang Chul validating his existence and getting to know how his world works. But instead, they left gaping holes everywhere and focused on solving a crime that the author can just easily eradicate by giving them amnesia.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

As for why the story ends once the antagonist die, I assume it's because that antagonist also happen to be the manhwa creator. Thus when the creator dies, the story literally ends too.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

If I could change the ending, I would have Kang Chul's storyline in the manhwa end but have SooBong magically become the manhwa character with SoHee as his love interest... struggles of a manhwa second-in-command rising above (something) to become the best manhwa writer in the manhwa-world-dom... with something dangerous but not as murderous as No-face/New-face and Assemblyman Han.

Also, Assemblyman Han would have utilized the tablet more and become so consumed with the God-like powers that Kang Chul swoops in under his nose and causes Assemblyman Han to create his undoing that brings him to justice in the manhwa world.

I think it was mistake on writer's part to make New-face take YeonJoo's father's face... should have just made New-face take Assemblyman Han's face to make ultimate villian. In that case, story resolution sould have been that he finds a new purpose or, as stated above, meet his demise... But if New-face needed to become and consume YeonJoo's father then YeonJoo's father should have had internal battle with No-face/New-face and won victorious--> returned to old self and return to reality alive but changed man (Daddy 3.0)
... But sadly there are so many things left unsatisfactorily answered

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

the ONE time a drama actually needs an extension.. ofc there was none
i hope some kind soul would translate SJJ original scripts so that we'd know the real story in its entirety without things being sacrificed for airtime

all in all, still a great drama

one major beef about this final ep (besides the rushed ending) is how sloppy it is. multiple continuity errors (i had to giggle at the car scene where an unconscious dad magically disappeared from YJ's side during KC's love confession lol) and just sloppy editing and awkward acting in general. it's like everybody lost energy at the end or something

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My heart is all over the place.

I genuinely did not expect KC to get shot by Councilman. I kept waiting for the other shoe to drop- he is wearing a bullet proof vest right right? (And why the heck doesn't KC wear one anyway! If I were YJ I'd deck him out in top-to-toe swat gear stuff.)

And then when the reincarnated Truck of Doom zipped by YJ I actually STOPPED the show to see how many minutes were left. It was a very nice touch to use The Truck that way though. Even Truck got a new purpose in the show!

I laughed whenever Crazy Dog came on screen. His expression after finishing W manhwa was true to life- that would have been my reaction too.

I was sad that Soo Bong didn't get more screen time. But Hands Up if you laughed at him crying and wiping his eyes through his glasses (*again!*) it's like a running gag now. I couldn't help but laugh.

And although I didn't shed a tear before this the entire show, I did at the end when YJ woke up and saw KC lying next to her. Her silence and hopeful but disbelieving gaze was more poignant and moving than all her sobs before this.

So nicely done show. I accept the bittersweet and open ending. (So many questions still though!) but I wish KC and YJ to live out their days Option #3 style. With some times for Option #4. ?

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Uri Truck of Doom is working hard to break out of his (her) typecasting.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

That's one thing I loved about Song Jae-jung's writing here, the way she used and reversed kdrama tropes. When OYJ tried to cross the street I bet everyone was like "please no truck of doom, please don't" but then it was used in the most brilliant way ever. ??

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you girlfriday! I have been so looking forward to your W's recaps and I look highly to them. Respect them a lot and always 100% agree with them.
I love the ending, love the writer-nim and the director so much, the end result is so beautiful and touching. IMHO it's logical and satisfying.
The dynamic is a lot like QIHM. QIHM has better chemistry (between the lead chars) but W has better story and logic.
Gonna miss this drama a lot and hopefully sometime in the future there will be one that can replace its place in my heart.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

And I have to add:
The Writer and Producer must surely be fans of Puuung who did the illustration book showed in Episode 7.

I got the book and so many scenes in the book are in the show! In this episode alone there are 3. And 1 of them is almost an exact replica, down to KC and YJ's outfit! (The last scene at the end)

So I did a post to share this episode's book pics with you guys because both the show and the book have become extra special to me because of it. And I'm imaging KC and YJ as the characters in the book and it's doing weird things to my heart (in a good way!) because to me they get their happily ever after.

https://mydramalesslife.wordpress.com/2016/09/15/true-love-for-the-w-romantics-out-there/

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The experience of folllowing W, not just the watching, but also the thinking the discussion the realization the existential doubt the feeling, every ting, I will remember for the rest of my life. This is a wild and beautiful journey. I doubt I will ever have it.

I almost loved all the episodes but a few of them stood out. Epsisode 3, 5, 7, 9, 10, 11, 14, they are my favorites.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

the last time i followed a drama so obsessively on DB was Healer, and it's true, the weekly waiting and group spazzing do add to the whole watching experience

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you so much Girlfriday!
I enjoyed this ride and think I may have started withdraws as soon as it was over.

This link is for everyone who thought the kiss at the end was too short (they edited it down! Why would you edit that down?) and for all the OTP shippers!

https://m.youtube.com/watch?feature=youtu.be&v=bUQSoDcsFy4

0
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

If you watch the video, don't miss the hand holding at the end hehehe -

*shamelessly ships couple in real life?❤️?*

Against my shamelessly shipping policy.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

PD has totally wasted LJS's mater kissing skills. Not just this one. Each of Every one.

example.

The third kiss, lame slow motion and no close up on KC's hand on YJ's waist.

The fourth kiss, lame slow motion and no close up on the mouths

The last one, no real close up and lame slow motion again

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

True, that would explain to some extent why some people felt a lack of chemistry between the leads - when chemistry is clearly evident in BTS.

I can't even blame it all on censoring; although I'd like to. Even though Healer wasn't everyone's cup of tea, I think it was the absolute best at showcasing natural looking physcal affection and kisses. I would even rate it one step higher than OHYA. I wish whoever was responsible for the way the skinship came together for Healer would have worked with this drama. :)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

the kiss is fine... its more than LJS ever done in his acting career...the angle doesnt matter to me...
as long it sweet and not horny looking, their kisses win!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I like the kiss in the last scene of W, however I like the unedited kiss better as seen in BTS.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I felt like this final episode should have been 2 hours long. I wouldn't have minded staying awake til 3AM. I was glad it was a happy ending and cried when dad sacrificed himself for the sake of our OTP's happy ending. We the viewers have as many questions as the manhwa fans. Crazy Dog, I totally get you. 0_0

Nonetheless, it was one exhilarating and heart-pounding journey to the end. Despite the unanswered questions, I loved it to bits.

Thanks DB and GF for the recap.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I am at work but I am satisfied with W ,
I knew people get confused and etc near the end but I found the rule is clear but they sequence of event never really get shown,
this drama nees to used split screen so people can easily see what event happen at the same time,
the romance is my favorite (which most people dislike), I like it because it more rational than dreamy kind of romance, it's like marriage than dating,
for the ending,
Idk why I am not complaining, probably because OSM did abuse his authority, have attempted murder, a bad dad and husband, and he draw the big fault when he grant the killer wish. Life is just that, no happy ending is clean happy ending, you just look at one perspective if you think it's a full happy ending.
And the writer even said sorry for having 16 ep
-----
*sans you already comment a lot the last 2 day, you need to work.... T.T
will comeback later....

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeah, me too. My little grips about W never lie in the rules. Everything in that front was pretty clear.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Cannot agree more! ?
It might be lack of its grande theory of everything, but I don't think it is that confusing. The rule is still stand clear. And you are right. What makes most people confuse probably because of the time and event sequence. Once I understand the timeline of event, I understand why they are the way that they are.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I can't believe its over!

..because I was kind of expecting more.

But, at the very least, W is the first show that I've actually found Lee Jong-seok attractive—the first show I saw him in I didn't like him much, and then eventually I at least understood that other people found him attractive, even if I personally didn't... but... idk. I LOVED him in this show. So there's that.

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Not exactly the same because I have found him attractive for almost 3 years but the new faces that LJS has shown us in W made me love him even more. It's like I always like him but right now I realized I really love him. LOL. I am not making sense.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

haha no, I get what you're saying :)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This. I always thought he looked a bit too juvenile, and his nose is...well...unfortunate. However, in this drama he looks all grown up, and he is a sexy, schmexy man. His nose is still wonky, though.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

yup, never interested to watch LJS in Doctor Stranger or Pinocchio...
He doesn't look like a pretty young boy here
and I found LJS and HHJ have face resemblance in certain angle...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm with birthday boy Lee Jong Suk in this one. This ending was okay, but I'm pretty sure jagganim could have done a kickass tragic ending.

That's my problem. The ending was just okay. After the spectacular twists and us being wrung out midway through the series, I was expecting more of a bang, or even a last-minute cliffhanger that would boggle the mind. This ending is positively humdrum. Although I must say, maybe the lead characters have had enough excitement to last them a lifetime, that the lack of it is as happy an ending as they're going to get, so maybe that's poetic justice and the happiest ending for them.

Thank you for the ride, show. I can't say I loved every minute of it, but it was highly enjoyable for the most part. Otsukaresama deshita.

Looking forward to the next projects of the dudes. :D

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

First half = AMAZING.
Second half = Meh.

At the end, I just really wanted to Soo Bong to meet So Hee….

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Not enough Soo Bong in the end and he did not even get a proper reward for all the shit he went through helping KC and YJ! Poor guy

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Lol @ Soo Bong shouting at Crazy Dog to shut his mouth. I thought, in real life someone would freeze or even break down crying if someone shouted at them like that but C-dog is just like huh?? But then I remembered something that an italian tourist said to my mum once, "KOREANS ARE CRAZY!!"
So, Crazy doctor must get yelled at often by other crazy koreans and this is normal...

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think Crazy Dog is used to patients and their guardians sometimes shouting at doctors when they're too stressed. Maybe he assumed it's the same in this case.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

So....yeon joo does not return to real world when kang chul keel over and thought dead , iti s when dad cease to exist at the same time at the bus stop..when he decide to draw his face on the no-face, we should already, he will be on the road with no return whatsoever...its bittersweet that with his sacrifice, yeon joo also been relieved by her roles as manhwa character...

All in all..its good ending..i know a lot will feel disastisfied, but SJJnim done a good job...acting can be improved, editing also the same...but try not to label this drama as one of the worst as this drama never intend they to be...

Another one, i've seen comment saying yeon joo is the worst female charactee in kdramaland, no....She's NOT..PLEASE DONT LABEL THAT WAY..she may not the best, but she's not the typical candy or the strongest either, she's sad but she's not sitting idle doing nothing either...

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

*already known
* not intend to be the best either

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Not sure how I feel about this finale (thank you for the recap, GF, by the way!) . . . I'm glad for the happy ending, but I think the writer set up too many questions which she couldn't satisfactorily answer, or even explore.

I felt sad that, for a character who comes to self-awareness and strives to make choices, in the end, Kang Chul (and Yeon-joo too) had no say over his 'ending'. His 'creator' had to draw a happy ending for him. I suppose that's right in many ways, as only the one who creates can also end the webtoon, but . . . and he was a a literal deus ex machina 8-)

it also felt strange that we spent significant time in the last episode establishing that Dad was unstable and likely to be murderous, especially in the webtoon world, and yet, here he is, able to stay sane and collected enough to deal with Han, plant his confession, write a letter to Kang Chul, and decide (?) to die. (I was also puzzled by that moment - if Kang Chul didn't actually die and end the webtoon, how did Yeon-joo get ejected? Technically, based on the 'you must die or I must die' scenario Dad espoused, Dad should have died when Kang Chul lived/ came alive (?), not when Yeon-joo was running across the road. Never mind).

And, yes, who is uploading that webtoon? Why would the villains' deaths not be shown???? In previous episodes, when events occurred, they appeared in the webtoon (e.g. Yeon-joo being shot). How did these deaths just 'disappear' off the screen?

Also felt sorry that Yeon-joo was left to mope. Why does the writer always do this to her female characters? They start out spunky and descend into puddles of tears. In addition, with the renewed relationship, the power dynamic is ever more skewed in Kang Chul's favour - he can teleport in and out of the W/ real world as he likes (accepting that there is a parallel universe which continues even after the webtoon ends); because the webtoon has ended (and the tablet has disappeared), Yeon-joo's 'creator' status has ended. He can come and go if he wants to, while she waits for him without being able to be 'part of his world'.

Still love the show and the questions it raised, especially in the first half. Just not sure if I would recommend it as one of the writer's better dramas. Great acting all around! (On the topic of which, I had no problems with Han Hyo-joo's crying scenes, not sure why she's had so many criticisms where that's concerned.)

Thank you again, GF, for the recaps and insights!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

"it also felt strange that we spent significant time in the last episode establishing that Dad was unstable and likely to be murderous, especially in the webtoon world, and yet, here he is, able to stay sane and collected enough to deal with Han, plant his confession, write a letter to Kang Chul, and decide (?) to die. "

I felt strange about it too. As to Dad's disappearance, in the voice over, SB explained that because Dad's actions went against his setting in the most fundamental way, so he was edited out.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Comment was deleted

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes "W" is not perfect, and it could've have been. I still don't know what to say, it is like this show left me a bit speechless. Yes I wish it had been extended by at least 1 episode, and better explanations to some things. However "W" so far, remains my favorite k-drama, despite its flaws. Things I learned from the characters' arcs:

YJ: Be careful what you wish for, you just might get it, but never-the-less still dream.
KC: Free will is the essence of a real life, and of being alive.
SM: Never take a story lightly, you just might get eaten by the story world itself as the characters come to life to haunt you.
SB: Therapy is just what the doctor ordered
Mad Dog: The voice of every frustrated k-drama viewer in the world
Do Yoon: Always be a loyal friend, and stay strong even when things don't make sense
So Hee: Never have only one purpose in life, after all life is beautiful because of its endless journeys

In the end, the W world goes on, and I like to believe that in the end KC got some gold bars from the W world, in order to have enough money to build himself up and get his paperwork done. He bought the same penthouse in the real world that was in the "W" world. I also choose to believe that KC remembers his "dream" when he went to YJ, so he and YJ share the memories.

The only thing that I think really didn't make sense was KC staying for 2 years in prison, I still don't know for what, when he could've simply teleported. However in real time it was only one week, so I will guess that it took KC a week to get his powers back after being shot. I will also overlook this one glaring plot hole.

I would also like to believe that KC and YJ had a happy and stress-free life, after everything they went through - especially YJ. I wonder if she is still a resident at the hospital by the end, because she must have had a lot of absences by then. I would also like to believe that DY crossed over as well, or that the W world became fully real just in a different dimension, because it still goes on even when the story stops uploading.

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

About KC staying for 2 years in prison - I'm not sure if the subtitles were correct, but I think Su-bong's narration stated that KC needed to leave the W world 'cleanly'. I suspect he was serving time for having fabricated his death (that was one of the charges read out in the courtroom scene) and breaking out of prison? I guess he didn't want any unfinished issues to linger in the W or webtoon.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

sorry, 'W or webtoon world'.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

he needed to serve out his prison sentence because if he ran away, he'd be a fugitive/criminal again. and he might still need to go back and forth between worlds. also if he's still a criminal, with a 'story' so to speak, it might trigger the manhwa to restart again- i think he just needed a full closure in that world before going back to YJ

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I can see that

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Damn. I shouldn't read the comments before watching this episode :-/

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

@Liza

You are not alone?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I really really dont like narrations. And yeah why would readers not know of the true ending? Its pretty much obvs anyway that two worlds are being discussed in the manhwa, that the creator is inside, so why will it be edited out just coz it goes against the killers personality? Hmph.

But anyway, still... Prob giving this 8/10 as a whole. Because I did enjoy the show. I still love Su-Bong, and his final meltdown with Crazy Dog was freakin hilarious, if they give me a Su-Bong special I will forgive them for this "secret ending" from the readers. ?

Ah what do I do now with Wednesdays-Thursdays? ??

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I d ok nt know what your taste in dramas. But here are the Wed/Thurs dramas that are currently airing or coming soon.

Shopping King Louie - 7 days left
On the Way to the Airport - 7 days left
Jealousy Incarnate - ep 7 aired today

I am really enjoying JI and I'm glad W2W & JI doesn't have to fight for my attention anymore. But I am definitely watching SKL and I am most likely going to check out OtAttA. Sooooo many dramas.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I just finished it a couple of hours ago and feel like a deflated balloon. There were so many twists that the knot in my stomach still hasn't untied itself.

Isn't the ending too ordinary? I must obviously be like the manhwa readers and thought KC dying was more acceptable.

I am having more issues with the dad dying. Then on noticing the OTP are together at the end. How did he reform from a useless dad and sloppy writer to developing a conscience. And have the ability to tie up the loose ends. He was never that altruistic and way more self-centred.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm not even sure how to react. Yes, it's a happy ending since they ended up together, but the way the manhwa ending was a rip-off. Let the fans know their beloved hero is alive. I feel cheated on their behalf. But overall it was a great show. And No-face/New-face goes down as one of the best villains I've seen in a long, long time. Hats off to Kim Eui-sung for his acting. LJS and HHJ were phenomenal as always. And I'm glad we got one more Su-bong outburst to send us off. ;)
But still so many questions left unanswered. But I guess that's how life is. Things aren't always wrapped up perfectly in a neat little bow. Sometimes you just have to accept the good things for what they are: a blessing.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm glad to see I'm not the only left wanting by the ending. It was a very promising drama and I was hooked with the first few episodes. I honestly expected a little more closure to the story--- it felt like it was rushed to me. 16 episodes is too short to really wrap up a story this complicated. we all have the same questions we want answered but since this isn't a perfect world we have to accept what's given us. All in all, it was good but not great. I still enjoyed watching the show despite the confusion and weird/changing rules.
Maybe it was how it was supposed to be: it's a show where the audience is not supposed to not overthink and just hang on and enjoy the ride.

Congratulations to everyone who played a huge part in bringing W: Two Worlds to the small
screen and thank you DB and GF for the recap.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Edit: ...it's a show where the audience is not supposed to overthink and just hang on and enjoy the ride....

(I hate typing on my phone)

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

@Aria

I hate typing on my phone too?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I hate typing on my phone too, especially moving vehicles :3

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I. Have. No. Comment.?

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Your "no comment" reminded me of KC's "no comment" after he kissed YJ in the car in front of the cafe. I was dying to know what he meant when he said "so this is the feeling". ?

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

one more question left unanswered.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My interpretation of "so this is the feeling" is actually a positive one: when you kiss someone you are attracted to, that kiss is sweet enough to make your heart racing. I think after that kiss KC felt much closer to YJ, like he loved her in his dream.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

ok I'm glad GF also felt dissatisfied with this ending because once the finale ended I literally let out a disappointed whine... "what?? that's it???" Especially after that rollercoaster ride in episode 15 - I was screaming on the edge of my SEAT for that one. And heck yES we got cheated out of SO many cuddles and SO many questions left unanswered!!!! I wanted to see more of what their life would be like afterwards aka MORE CUDDLES! How does Kang Chul create his new identity in the real world? Is it really possible that Dad just disappeared like that?? And if the hero does triumph in the end, shouldn't the manhwa depict that?

I guess that leads to discussion about who the manhwa was really about - Kang Chul, or just the destruction of the evil/ villains in general. Dad sought to eliminate the evil in his life through W, and it's kind of sad but maybe he realized that yes the evil really did come from himself...so it comes full circle that he ended up disappearing. And it makes sense that Kang Chul, the one good thing, survived.

Also did anyone else freak out when Sohee visited Kang Chul in jail? I was like NOW HOLD ON JUST A MINUTE HE IS NOT ABOUT TO MOVE ON WITH HER AND FORGET YEON JOO.

But yeah..like how did Kang Chul even get into the real world? What happened to that world? Did everything and everyone just disappear? Wouldn't Chul be really depressed about that?

There is a W special coming out right? Will the epilogue to the epilogue be released then? lol....

I did love the scene when Yeon Joo wakes up in Kang Chul's arms though. ugh goals

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think this show should have been longer.. it was a little rushed and now we are left with so many questions unanswered
Anyway, I'm gonna miss it. Alot

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

yup I was so afraid, why would so hee come back in the final episode. the scene was included in preview just to tease the viewer haha...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Personally I think W deserves an extension for further explanations on what happened in the manhwa world after it ends. Would the time freeze like in Ep 6 or would time still move forward? What happens now to So Hee and Do Yeon? It was stated that So Hee has gotten out of the predetermined set-up by Dad but what about Do Yeon who knows about the two worlds.

I just have so many questions I want the writer to address. But overall, we have a happy ending and there's nothing I have to ask for.

0
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think it would be great if they did a season 2 of this drama

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Haha.. It was fun to see you in MDBC comments yesterday:D Good luck neener! Make us kdrama fangirls proud!

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh this was meant @neener's comment below

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks! I did survived, not sure if I passed ?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I just wanted to be assured that there's no more tablet hidden somewhere. Thought that was a lazy tool that was overused in the latter episodes. Even Harry Potter didn't use the Room of Requirement that frequently

0
reply

Required fields are marked *