582

Moonlight Drawn By Clouds: Episode 7

What a great episode to break 20% ratings with. It had a lot of elements going for it, and packed a surprise emotional punch even in its side stories. There’s denial and confusion and a lot of emotions, which makes for a satisfying episode all around. I foresee many squees being had; if you’ve seen the episode I’m sure you’ll know why, and if you haven’t, what are you doing, go watch!

 

 
EPISODE 7: “Confession”

After Yeong and Byung-yeon make their intrepid rescue of Ra-on from the corrupt Chinese ambassador, they arrive at the palace late that night. A panicked Eunuch Jang bursts into the courtyard fussing over the prince and bombarding him with questions. Yeong tells the eunuch to hold the questions till tomorrow, then tells Ra-on he’ll see her back at his palace soon.

Back at their quarters, Ra-on notices the scars and fresh wounds on Byung-yeon’s back and asks if he incurred any injuries from saving her today. He tells her simply that they came from him doing his job, not because of her. She still feels bad, noting that he didn’t just rescue her today—he also nursed her all night when she was sick.

Byung-yeon gruffly tells her that it wasn’t him. He’s told her that before but Ra-on hadn’t believed him, and she scoffs that there’s nobody else it could be… and then remembers the prince. Now it makes sense how he knew of her mother, if he’d been there the night she’d dreamed of their separation. The blurry face in her mind sharpens, and she now sees that it was Yeong at her bedside.

Ra-on settles down to sleep with a smile on her face, and sighs to Byung-yeon that the palace feels comfortable to her now. She reminds him of something he’d once said: that the palace becomes a livable place when you find someone you like inside of it.

She muses, “I’m worried I may start liking the palace more.”

The next day, Yoon-sung is so excited at Ra-on’s return that he runs through the palace, smiling widely to see her. She assures him she’s fine and asks if he worried, and Yoon-sung replies, “Yes. Please make it so I don’t worry again. You’re a very special person to me.”

Ra-on is startled at that, but he jokes it off: “You’re the only person to make me run inside this palace.”

The prince arrives, and both he and Yoon-sung stiffen a little. Yeong has heard from Byung-yeon that Yoon-sung played an important role in the rescue, and Yoon-sung answers that it was important to him.

Yeong muses that it was important enough for Yoon-sung to defy his own grandfather, and deduces, “You’re telling me not to pay much mind to it because it wasn’t for my benefit.” Yoon-sung confirms it.

The queen cackles in amusement upon hearing of the prince’s actions, wondering when he took such a benevolent interest in his servants. Eunuch Sung chuckles with her, and whispers that there are even rumors in the palace that the prince may be gay. She smiles darkly at that.

The queen is served her tonic, but the court lady serving her gags audibly, to everyone’s horror. (Aha, telltale pregnancy sign, is it?) The court lady begs for forgiveness, but the queen throws her bowl angrily and orders the lady dragged off.

Rookie eunuchs Do Ki and Sung-yeol sit with a group of ladies, demonstrating a new process of removing wrinkles with poison-laced acupuncture needles—heh, primitive Botox.

One court lady shares gossip about the belowground furnace “burning hot” these days—the furnaces aren’t currently in use, which means those enclosed spaces are perfect for secret rendezvous. One of the women, the princess’s lady-in-waiting Wol-hee, fidgets nervously and quickly changes the subject.

The queen’s Eunuch Sung complains to the king’s head eunuch about the rumors disturbing the queen in her delicate condition. The head eunuch says that the king hasn’t visited the bed of a court lady in years, and Eunuch Ma supposes that a politician or official might be involved instead. Hm, why does he look uneasy?

Eunuch Sung says that the queen even harbors suspicions about the eunuch department and ordered that the culprit be caught. The head eunuch considers this, then decides to have all of the eunuchs undergo medical testing. Eunuch Ma (who’s the only one who knows Ra-on’s real gender) asks what happens with the rookies.

Ra-on comes upon Yeong sitting before an untouched meal, which he won’t eat before it’s been tasted for poison. She offers to call the appropriate court lady, but Yeong tells her to do it for him, ordering her to sit. She complies hesitantly, then widens her eyes at how tasty the food is, which makes Yeong smile secretly to himself. Aww.

When she deems the food safe, Yeong barely tastes his food before deeming it terrible, and Ra-on grimaces at his excessively picky palate. He pushes the table aside, telling her to eat instead, and when he threatens to have it cleared out immediately, she hastily agrees.

She can’t hide her enthusiasm once she’s eating, and he smiles, contented to watch her eat. Omgah you two are too cute, I just want to put you in my pocket.

After she’s done cleaning off literally every plate, Ra-on works up the nerve to ask what Yeong meant when he’d told her to stay by his side, back when he’d rescued her. But his answer is matter-of-fact, saying that there’s nothing strange about wanting to keep a eunuch he cares about by his side.

Spoken like that, it seems quite normal, and Ra-on deflates. Then Yeong gets up to leave the room, pausing to turn back and point out, “You are already five steps away.” Ra-on hurries to his side, and he grins that impish grin.

Yoon-sung works on a new set of drawings, all of Ra-on in her female guise, one of them inspired by that day in the rain when she’d held a lady’s cloak over her head. He hides the drawings when his grandfather, Prime Minister Kim, drops by, lying that he was reading.

The prime minister informs him of marriage talks with the minister of rites’ family—that is to say, the plans to marry Yoon-sung and Ha-yeon. After that, the prime minister intends to marry a young woman from their clan to the crown prince. That does tie up the court nicely in the Kim clan’s hands.

Yoon-sung protests that he’s not ready for marriage, but his grandfather barks that this isn’t about Yoon-sung (well, only technically!) and instructs him to do as told.

From a pantry, Ra-on hears whispered voices and instinctively ducks for cover. It’s Eunuch Ma and Princess Myeongeun’s lady-in-waiting Wol-hee, who have been carrying on a secret romance, although Wol-hee has grown tired of sneaking around. She wants for him to be able to declare openly that she’s his woman, but Eunuch Ma is much more concerned about the ramifications of their relationship being exposed. He points out that she could be hurt, but Wol-hee replies that that’s what their relationship is: “If we like each other, we get hurt.”

Before he can reply, the sound of approaching steps sends them ducking too, and from his hiding spot, Eunuch Ma meets Ra-on’s eye. Whoops.

After Wol-hee stalks off with hurt feelings, Ra-on explains that she didn’t mean to eavesdrop. Eunuch Ma just warns her to keep her mouth shut, for her own good.

Ha-yeon barely pays attention to the sit-ups she’s supervising Princess Myeongeun to do, thoughts fixated on the crown prince. He’s always surrounded by lots of people, but she supposes that there must be times he likes to be alone. The princess says that he sometimes goes for a walk in the gardens, and like that, Ha-yeon is off like a shot.

She goes straight to the gardens, pleased to find Yeong sitting there alone with a book. She plays it like a chance encounter, saying that she was just passing by, but finds that Yeong doesn’t respond quite the way she wanted. First he points out that it’s not really a “happened to be walking by” type of place, then gets a rise out of her by teasing that she crawled in through a hole.

So Ha-yeon gives up the act and admits that she miscalculated by trying to fake a fateful encounter. She smiles to see his book, then uses pretty literary words to suggest that he take a break from his book and walk with her.

Ra-on approaches with her arms full of books, but when she sees the prince smiling up at Ha-yeon, she takes a step back, spirits sinking.

What she doesn’t know is that Yeong declined Ha-yeon’s suggestion, which sends Ha-yeon storming off in a snit. She’s particularly annoyed that he gave his rejection with a smile, which had made her heart skip. But then she cheers up, and something tells me Ha-yeon is down but not out.

That night, a drunk Eunuch Ma parks himself outside Wol-hee’s door and bellows for her to come out. Before he can get himself into serious trouble, though, Ra-on darts in and grabs him, clapping a hand over his mouth.

Eunuch Ma turns the tables, grabbing Ra-on by the throat and asking why she’s following him around. Ra-on gasps that she’s acting out of concern for him, and he retorts, “Who’s concerned about whom? Acting like a eunuch—”

It sounds like he’s about to out her secret, but out of nowhere Byung-yeon intervenes and shoves Eunuch Ma aside. He checks that she’s okay and reaches toward her neck, but then his hand gets shoved aside by Yeong. But the intense moment begins to feel awkward, and Yeong tells Ra-on brusquely that she’s fine and turns to go.

Ra-on hurries after them, and asks Byung-yeon if entering the palace life makes it impossible to change your fate (as in, leave the court). Byung-yeon replies that it can’t be done without the king’s consent.

At that, Yeong cuts in sternly to tell Ra-on not to concern herself with the others’ relationship. He states that the law is the law, and while Ra-on concedes that that’s true, she asks how the direction of one’s heart can be right or wrong.

The next day, Ra-on broods by a tree, heavy-hearted at the memory of Yeong smiling with Ha-yeon in the garden. Eunuch Ma, sober today, sits down nearby to brood too before spotting Ra-on and getting huffy about the other night.

But Ra-on chides him for his series of bad choices: getting drunk, going to the women’s quarters, and raising a fuss. She asks what he means to do now, and Eunuch Ma says glumly that there’s nothing he can do. So Ra-on offers to help.

The king confers with the prime minister regarding an incident where bandits raided government stores of relief rations for the populace. The bandits have demanded the resignation of the vice minister of taxation, who has been accused of siphoning off those stores for his own gain.

The king asks why reports of the vice minister’s wrongdoings were left out of the report, but the prime minister asks why the king has been blinded by the words of the ignorant populace, and taken issue with only the officials’ “small flaws.”

Prime Minister Kim presents the king with the mask dropped by Byung-yeon in the chase the other night, and declares that every suspicious culprit involved in recent troubles have worn a mask like it. Moreover, the man at the center of these activities is Hong Kyung-rae.

The name sends the king flashing back to the death and destruction of the peasant rebellion that Hong Kyung-rae had led, and he declares that the man has already died. Prime Minister Kim agrees, but believes his supporters are searching desperately for Hong’s kin in order to revive their efforts.

Now that’s an alarming prospect for the king, and it stokes his fears. He orders the prime minister to have them all caught, insisting that history cannot repeat itself.

That night, Ra-on works on sewing a doll and suggests that a preoccupied Byung-yeon give it a try, to help get his mind off his worries. When he tells her to shush, she grumbles that he’s probably not even any good—which gets Byung-yeon to join her and show off his expertise.

Ra-on claps in amazement and heaps on the compliments, then asks him to do another. At which point he grumpily extinguishes the candle with his sword.

The next day, Yeong and Ra-on come upon a eunuch fistfight in the courtyard, which comes screeching to a halt at the prince’s arrival. A bloodied Eunuch Jang initially refuses to explain the reason until Yeong threatens to send him to the court tribunal, and then he blurts that the others had been spouting nonsense.

Yeong encourages him to explain further, and with great reluctance, Eunuch Jang tells him the rumor about Yeong being gay. The news comes as a shock to both Yeong and Ra-on, and his eyes briefly flicker over to her before he bursts into a big forced laugh, acting like it’s a silly joke that’s not worth the reaction.

But Eunuch Jang persists, saying that the rumors say that he looks at Ra-on like a lover, and that their closeness is out of the ordinary. At that, Yeong angrily tells him enough.

Later in the prince’s library, Ra-on reaches up to a high shelf and ends up dropping the doll in her hands, which she’d been sewing earlier. Yeong gets to it first, and when Ra-on tries to yank it out of his grasp, he pulls on it too, and the sleeve rips.

Yeong orders Ra-on to explain what she’s up to, and she replies that the doll is something to convey true feelings without getting anyone hurt. Exasperated, he reminds her that he’d warned her not to get involved with Eunuch Ma’s issues, but Ra-on counters that she won’t do anything illegal.

“Is it not futile?” Yeong asks. “Even if you know your heart, it doesn’t change anything.”

Ra-on replies, “One doesn’t not reach out a hand to the sky thinking it will touch it.” He asks why, then. She replies, “I know that it is no use, but how can you control liking someone? Even though nothing will change, I would like my feelings to be understood.”

But Yeong replies that it’s quite selfish for the departing party to confess their feelings for their own comfort.

Ra-on counters, “Is it not possible to confess to someone who cannot be?” She says that sending someone away well shows as much of a warm heart as love does. “The memory of having received love could become a lifelong source of strength.”

His gaze changes at that, and she adds, “Although you will not be able to understand that feeling.” She walks away, and he almost steps forward to follow, but stops himself.

Ra-on joins Yoon-sung under a tree, saying that she’s in need of its comfort. Yoon-sung’s face lights up at the sight of her, though he does ask in concern who’s been upsetting her.

“It’s me,” she answers. “I’m the one making myself the most angry.” She says it feels like she’s only causing trouble for the prince, and Yoon-sung asks cautiously if she means as a eunuch. She replies, “Of course.”

Yoon-sung relaxes at that and says that it’s probably the position itself that’s the problem; her uniform doesn’t suit her. He opens the box with him to show Ra-on the hanbok he’d bought before, which he’d said was meant for someone special. He’s been waiting for the time the recipient might accept it happily, and wants to ask her today.

Then he places the box in Ra-on’s hands and asks, “Do you not want to live as a woman?”

Meanwhile, Ha-yeon has tea with her father, and is taken aback at the mention of marriage. Ha-yeon is hesitant, saying that if she were to marry, she would like for it to be with the person she wants to marry, a response that leaves her father nonplussed.

Back at the tree, Ra-on takes a moment to get over her surprise, and answers that she likes things as they are. Yoon-sung presses, saying that it’s dangerous living here in disguise, and says he’ll help her leave the palace and live as a woman. The statement starts out as an offer, but ends as a request.

Yoon-sung tells her that this is what he’s wanted to say since the day he bought the clothes. Ra-on tries to laugh it off, but he remains serious and tells her he’ll wait until she figures out what she truly wants.

That evening, the eunuchs and court ladies gather for a puppet show—Ra-on’s big idea—titled (hee) “The Court Lady’s Man.” Do Ki and Sung-yeol work the puppets and narrate the story of Do-hwa, the most beautiful woman in the land who became a court lady.

Enter the eunuch who followed her around, whom she rebuffed because court ladies are only meant for the king. And yet, Eunuch Wang was the only person she found she could rely on in the palace. When Wol-hee joins the audience, Ra-on signals to Eunuch Ma, who takes puppets in hand, looking determined.

Outside, the queen’s Eunuch Sung hears of the puppet show with disapproval, but it isn’t until he hears Ra-on’s name that he snaps to attention .

Eunuch Ma takes over the storytelling as Puppet Do-hwa is about to spend the night with king, but longing for her lover. She asks Puppet Eunuch why he won’t call her his woman, and Wol-hee recognizes his voice and their story. Puppet Eunuch sends her away, because their love has no future.

Wol-hee starts to storm out, but stops as Puppet Eunuch’s declares, “I wanted to say these words! In a place with many people, in a loud voice! I love you! Truly, I truly love you!” Oh, tears. It’s exactly what she’d wanted of Eunuch Ma, which he’d been reluctant to do.

Yeong arrives just as Eunuch Ma adds, “You may just be one of hundreds of the king’s court ladies, but to me, you are the whole world!”

Gah, that is so freaking sweet. Beneath the stage, Eunuch Ma sobs, and onstage the puppets embrace. Ra-on looks at them with shining eyes, and Yeong thinks of Ra-on’s words about a warm farewell meaning as much as a show of love.

Yeong leaves quietly, and Ra-on looks over just as he walks out, her face falling.

Then Eunuch Jang storms into the courtyard in a huff, berating the eunuchs and demanding the instigator to step forward.

The next thing we know, Ra-on is kneeling before the smug queen, begging her pardon. The prince arrives, declaring that he took her bait in coming here, and will be taking Ra-on now.

But the queen refuses to allow it, stating that the rookie has overstepped his bounds. She reminds Ra-on that all court ladies belong to the king, and slaps her in the face, hard. She looks eagerly at Yeong for his reaction.

In fact, it seems everyone’s waiting for Yeong’s reaction, but he refuses to give it. After long moments, he starts to chuckle and tells the queen that a court-lady-and-eunuch love story is pretty standard parody stuff. He points out that even the king gets lampooned, and asks if she wants every satirist dragged before her for punishment.

That angers the queen further, but it seems he’s won this round. Yeong orders Ra-on to stand, and this time the queen doesn’t stop it. She does, however, warn that the king is already troubled enough and asks, “Are you not afraid of the scandalous rumors about you?”

Yeong stands his ground, and advises that she give it a rest and not blow everything out of proportion. He leads his entourage away, keeping his emotions in check—but not so well in check that it escapes the queen’s eagle eyes.

She’s positively gleeful, in fact, as she notes that he isn’t looking at Ra-on like one looks upon a eunuch: “That is the gaze of a man looking at his lover.”

On the other hand, Eunuch Jang assures Yeong that he did a good job not letting the queen get to him. Yeong turns to look at Ra-on, who bows her head meekly, then continues without a word.

In her quarters that night, Ra-on thinks of Yeong’s words about wanting to keep a eunuch close, and the queen’s reference to the ugly rumors.

The next day, a new crisis is upon Ra-on, because the king’s order to have all the eunuchs re-examined requires her to undergo another physical. She quakes in her boots and almost blurts her secret to Eunuch Sung.

That’s when Eunuch Ma interrupts, then plays off his interruption like it’s no big deal, he’s just off to make a really important delivery from the queen to the prime minister. Eunuch Sung balks because that’s his purview, and he grabs the delivery and orders Eunuch Ma to give Ra-on a thorough exam. Phew, one bullet dodged.

Then, Eunuch Ma just goes over to the exam table and stamps her certificate: PASS. Man, is Ra-on burning through her nine lives or what?

It’s a surprise to her, but he just gives her a little smile. She asks him how long he’s known, and he says it was since the king’s celebration. She apologizes, and he accepts that before then also thanking her.

It makes Ra-on smile, and she says that it offered her consolation to see them. Eunuch Ma tells her that she skirted this peril this time, but that the palace is a place where not even the king’s safety can be guaranteed.

She understands, and says sadly, “If I can leave, I should leave, shouldn’t I?”

Her mood is heavy as she attends on the prince, who notes her glum mood with curiosity. Finally he tells her to look at him directly, only to have her reply that her downturned face is the proper pose for a eunuch. Yeong asks if someone’s been scolding her, or if she’s angry at him for some reason.

With a playful grin, he leans down to look her in the eye, and Ra-on shrinks away, even stepping backward. He’s surprised, and she asks him not to be too nice to her: “I cannot be friends with you, or something else either.”

She adds that she was taught that a eunuch’s place is one step behind the prince—no closer, no farther.

“You’re my person,” Yeong reminds her, saying that nobody else can dictate the distance they keep. But Ra-on seems to have made up her mind, and requests, “Please care for me exactly as much as you do the other eunuchs. To me, that is something I’m grateful enough for.”

Yeong’s face hardens, and he turns and resumes walking, with Ra-on remaining one faithful step behind.

That night, Yeong replays Ra-on’s words about wanting to have her feelings understood, even if the result cannot change. He takes ink to paper.

Ra-on, meanwhile, looks over the pretty hanbok Yoon-sung gave her, thinking over his question: “Don’t you want to live as a woman?”

The next day, Yeong summons Ra-on to the garden, the mood very serious. He takes a long moment before speaking, then finally says, “I lied to you.”

He clarifies, “When I told you to stay by my side, I did not mean as a eunuch. Then why do you think I said those words to you?”

Ra-on looks up in shock, and he continues, “To put to bed this impossible chaos, every night I have asked myself countlessly, and found that answer.”

Yeong grabs her arm and pulls her closer. “Before I am the crown prince,” he says, “I am one person, and one man. That I love you—that is my answer.”

Oh. My. God.

Ra-on is so flustered that she barely knows what to do. (I’m so flustered I barely know what to do.) She shakes off his hand and stammers that he’s the prince—how could he love a man like her, or a eunuch?

“Do not tell me that my heart is wrong,” he says, reminding her of her own words about being unable to declare a heart right or wrong for feeling the way it does.

He has a point, but Ra-on is still left grasping at straws, saying that there are nice loves and bad loves, and that this is one that nobody would support. More than that, it’s impossible.

“I know,” Yeong says. “However, I mean to give it a try, that bad love.”

He steps closer, tiny step after tiny step, advancing as she takes equally tiny steps backward. Then he grabs her around the waist and pulls her close, toppling the hat from her head, staring intently at her face.

Ra-on is all aflutter with surprise and confusion and feeeeelings, but he lifts her face with a hand to her cheek, and she closes her eyes. Oh, he smiles at that.

And then, that kiss.

 
COMMENTS

Hold on, I think I need a minnit to gather my thoughts, because right now they’re just sitting in a pool of sloppy emotions at my feet. It’s going to take some effort to get them out of the primordial ooze of pure squee. I’ll give it my best shot.

Okay, first things first: The confession and kiss make this a pretty awesome episode, but I can’t overlook all of the other reasons I was so pleased with this episode, even before the last five minutes came and shoved those more civilized thoughts out my head. I was already thinking with the plot of the day that it was a lovely handling of a touching story, one that could have easily been a throwaway plot that was there merely to push our main couple along.

I can’t quite pinpoint why I found Eunuch Ma and Wol-hee’s story so moving, and it’s not purely the writing or the acting. But I do believe it’s the same inchoate element that makes Moonlight Drawn By Clouds as a whole such a winner for me—there’s just a really nice, balanced directorial hand that elevates all of the elements and really facilitates full emotional absorption. That’s a word (absorption) that gets thrown around in the Korean drama viewership extremely frequently, though it doesn’t quite get the same attention internationally: the degree to which a drama sucks you in, and makes you feel fully immersed in the world. When you’re wholly invested, you feel everything a little more strongly, a little more keenly, and that’s the quality that this show has in spades, which makes it better than its familiar plot and potentially juvenile premise.

So the eunuch-and-court-lady tragic romance was moving on its own (I shed such tears in Eunuch Ma’s shouted confession), but it was doubly effective for (1) mirroring the main lovers’ struggles, and (2) spurring on their behavior toward each other, giving them half-cover for their veiled confessions earlier in the episode. When I saw that the episode was titled “Confession,” I was both excited at the prospect and wary that of course we couldn’t be talking about the main couple yet, and figured it was a reference to the other storyline. And then the Yeong-Ra-on story up and went that way too, and I was happily surprised to get double the whammy.

I really appreciate this kind of layered storytelling, with the A and B stories running parallel and each getting their own resolution, while dovetailing at the emotional high point of the episode. The construction is pretty familiar in American television, and in the best episodes, the multiple threads all converge on multiple levels—plotwise, emotionally, thematically. There’s an added feeling of satisfaction and resolution when stories meet like that, so that by the time you reach our climax, everything resonates with extra vibrancy and clarity. It isn’t to say Korean dramas lack the ability, but the serial nature of the episodes doesn’t really lend itself to that. And also, I just don’t think that kind of writing is the style in K-dramas.

Frankly I think Moonlight was carrying an extra-heavy burden, because when you stand on the shoulders of tent-pole Hallyu dramas like Coffee Prince or Sungkyunkwan Scandal, you can’t just whip out a mediocre confession and achieve the same effect. Heck, you can’t even be as good; you have to find a way to make it fresh again, and I didn’t know if anybody would be able to top Gong Yoo’s “I don’t care if you’re a man or an alien” speech. (That phrase still gives me the shivers.)

But my hat’s off to Moonlight, because I was squealing pretty hard, and not in the least disappointed with the way Yeong made his grand confession. I love that it was straightforward and stated with clarity, and that he went there with the kiss, knowing what that meant with the historical context. Youth fantasy sageuk or no, it’s still a sageuk, and I do think that provides a heightened effect with regards to the gay-acceptance throughline. It’s also what makes me worry for the aftermath, because he’s a prince with political enemies dying to take him down, and the stakes have just shot through the roof.

But why worry about things that haven’t happened yet, when I can just rewatch that confession? Better that than sitting impatiently, waiting for tomorrow.

RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , , ,

582

Required fields are marked *

That end scene was almost definitely a dream but OMG I'M SCREAMING GIVE ME MORE KISSES!! And if that was real... then I'm gone, my soul will just float away from my body and I'll be gone forever, tell my family I loved them but this was too damn much for me to handle

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

silently LOL-ing in my work place while reading your comment.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

You can't go yet. There are like 10+ episodes left you need to see. haha! Your comment made me laugh. Thanks!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I honestly don't care whether Lee Yeong knows Ra On is a man or a woman. The fact he confessed his love without telling her makes clear: he doesn't care. He loves Ra On no matter if she is a man or a woman.

And that makes the confession and the kiss even sweeter.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

It doesn't matter that much to me right now as well because the confession was sweet and sincere.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

@Jillia - well said, totally agree with you on this one!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Watching this episode at 2AM and squeeeeeeeing silently after that kiss otherwise my rommie might scream bloody murder (she is someone who absolutely can not relate to my kdrama addiction). I am rewatching it multiple times while I wait for the next epi. :D

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

@heavensent03 - to have a roomie but not one that shares your kdrama addiction - my heart goes out to you!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

That confession energized me in a startrek warp where the the planets has nothing but pink skies with baloon and unicorn and fairies and the loveliest flower you could imagine of...
I'm smitten ... By Park Bo Gum... How is it I could sense his desperation, truth and sincerity in his eyes... This is just a play... Make-believe... Just like Tris, that girl from Divergent said "This isn't real..." and cracks the glass off by her fingertips. I felt it real. His honesty was real surreal?
I've been looking for the english translated version of this MDbC but alas have I failed. I just hate(loves) squee surprises like this... Can't someone help me find any link for the english version of the web novel so I can jumpt to the future for better heart settling preparation ?☹️
Now my prayers will goes as "that I wish someone (as cute and hot as Park Bo Gum) would refrain that confession to me when I get proposed..."??

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My heart's all a-flutter now. Just as I am on an emotional high because of the SQEEEEEEEEEE-Kiss, I am more on edge now because more is at stake for the Prince now.

I do hope they just don't end up as star-crossed lovers.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oooh. My. Gawwwd !!! Nothing i can say could resume my thoughts. Gotta survive before. Wooooow !!!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's a bit crazy. I have like a billion other things I need to do. But instead I'm re-reading recaps and comments, looking at gifs and every time I reach the confession part my heart still has that Twinge, even after the Nth time I'm thinking about it.

What is this Moonlight Madness?

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hahaha!! Same with me @michykdrama.
Scrolling the comments, recaps and gifs.
Still waiting for yoo jung's performance like in moon sun. The bond between YJG and KYG even w/o kiss was too romantic. Looking forward to see the romance between bo gum and yoo jung.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I updated with more gifs!!

Because I might as well do something productive while I'm re watching XD

https://mydramalesslife.wordpress.com/2016/09/13/when-there-are-no-words-left-gif/

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

@michykdrama - thanks for making these wonderful gifs. They are my favourite parts from this episode as well! This show is such a wonderful, sweet distraction! Moonlighting Madness indeed!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I will add my thanks as well.

I enjoyed the gifs so much (maybe too much?).

Please keep them coming!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think yoo jung is sometimes overdoing the acting. They should have casted so hyun moon gae won.
Nevertheless kim hyung has caught my attention.
He looks better in grown hairs. Bo gum is new emotions king. Variety of emotions. Loved it oppa

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

She is the right age for the character and she is the best in sageuks. Moon is excellent but she is almost 30yrs old. So Hyun is better in modern dramas.

She is a young 18yr old girl cross-dressing as an eunuch. She is still a trainee and she is trying to keep it together. She has a lot to deal with, nothing is normal in that palace and she is facing death every day.
I'd be a nervous wreck every single day.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

OMG FEELS LIKE I TURNED INTO MELTED BUTTER LAST NIGHT~~

More squeeeeeeeeee if Yeong already knew Raon is actually a girl~

BUT! I'll go berserk if it's just a dream! Don't you dare, show, just dON'T YOU DARE!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

In the subbed version I saw, this episode was titled as profession. I felt confused, "profession?"

After reading this recap only I realized its confession. Maybe by profession, they meant professing one's feelings?

My heart started beating faster when he grabbed her hand and pulled her close. And I loved it when she closed her eyes in anticipation of what she felt he was going to do. Despite all her protests that this love was not acceptable, her closing her eyes gave it away that she wanted it as much as he wanted it.

And the fact that he loved her enough to even accept the possibility of him being gay and being able to confess it to her takes immense courage. Because, unless you tell it to the person, you can always lie to yourself that that's not how you really felt. Once its out in the open, it becomes solid and you can never act like, it didn't happen.

So, I want ra on to be equally courageous and tell him her secret, the way he told her his name because yeong deserves it. Even though there is a possibility that he might already know she is a girl (please reveal whether he knows or not soon, show), it would still be gratifying for him to see that she trusts him enough to tell him her life long secret (assuming he already knows, that is.).

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Not profession but confession. :) Seems like it was a mistake in the subtitles.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ya, I guess. That's why I love reading recaps, they give me clarity. And its super fun to read javabeans's as well as other people's thoughts on this show. :)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hands up

*if you are Shipping park bo gum and yoo jung

Hands up
* if you are Shipping yoo jung and park bo gum

Hands up
*if you are Shipping crown prince and sam nom

Hands up
*if you are Shipping sam nom and crown prince

^_^

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

CP doesn't know. Sam Nom being Ra On. His eunuch being female. I'm standing on this side of this argument. I know lots of people are rabidly certain that he does based on his actions or expressions and something possibly happening behind the scenes that we will find out later but right now, I am sure he doesn't know. No scene has delivered that information (that he found out) to me. All I got was that despite the consequences the CP is gonna go ahead and give the 'wicked' aka wrong love a try.

I could be wrong, and I will be ready to admit it when/if the time comes but until then.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't think he knows that Sam Nom is Ra-on yet but he does know that she is a girl based on the preview for the next episode.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Make some noise for 'bad love'!!

That confession...❤️❤️❤️
PBG why you make our skip so much...?

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

"Make some noise for ‘bad love’!!"

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA ohgod I love this! Nice one!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

So based on the comments, I am the only one who is just pleasantly happy with the show as opposed to squeeing. Ha. I love most of these gender confusion dramas, but I am constantly reminded why Coffee Prince is still the Platinum standard. Two things:

1) Maybe it is the writing or maybe it is the actor, but Gong Yoo's character to date is the only character to treat the girl as a man. Every other gender confusion drama I have ever seen treats the girl like a girl, so it makes it hard for me to believe that they don't realize that the girl is in fact a girl. That applies to this drama as well regardless of whether Park Bo Gum's character found out in episode four or still doesn't know.

2) Again maybe its the writing and maybe its the actor, but the constant need to save the woman ruins the effect. In this show KJY has been saved at least 5 or 6 times and its only episode 7.

That being said I do love the show, but these are just my musings. Also I love Gong Yoo and Yoon Eun Hye. Best chemistry ever and most people still haven't come close, so I may be biased.

0
9
reply

Required fields are marked *

I have not watched coffee prince. Now that I think of it, both the points you mentioned are valid. But, I didn't think of this before you mentioned it all. So, I guess that's the power this drama has over me.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Watch Coffee Prince, you will have no regrets!!!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ok kafiyah, will definitely check it out! :)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

The show selling all the familiar tropes and drama cliques like it's something new and exciting. That's what happens when they put two adorable and capable actors as leads and the people behind the show are doing their job to make it work.

I get the pleasantly happy instead of squeeeee. I'd be squeeing in a few more years when she is in her 20s.

1. This is a youth romance. Gong Yoo was not portraying a 19yr old male.

2. Agree with you that she has been a damsel in distress. I wish the writer would let her use her brain more to get herself out of trouble.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Fair point about it being a youth romance. You are correct on the other points as well.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

With regards to your first point, I have feeling that the Crown Prince already knows that she's a girl in disguise thus translating to his actions towards her. I might be wrong though. Nevertheless what sells it for me and makes the drama so good is due to how well the actors are just bringing their A game to breathe new life to familiar kdrama characterizations.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

For me it's the female lead and the lack of plot.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

What should she do better?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Are we watching the SAME drama?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

he said "Ittda" as in I have, rather than "Isseottda" (in past tense).
He is in love with *her*! SQUEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

late to this party but can I just say, I'll never ever forget as long as I live that victorious languid smile of Lee Yeong's when Raon closed her eyes.

OH MY GATNESS!!!

*FLAILS*

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

"OH MY GATNESS!!!"

I love this. It could be a thing because we love Kim Hyung! hahaha!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Taking Gat/God Byung Yeon's name in vain. ^^;

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

JB's translation is more squeee-worthy than the subtitle, excuse me while I retype those soft-sub.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Depends when you watch it. The edited viki subs are now different from when I watched it like 24hrs ago.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Kyaaaaa!!! He kissed a man and I bet somebody is watching them. Now that he kissed u, u should tell him that u are a girl, Ra On ah...

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I need my own bogum my life... T.T
Bogum ah why you so charming.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Delurked for the sole purpose of joining the squeeing party -

SQUEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE!!!!!!!!!

Man, Bogummy slays so hard, I am dead!!! This OTP better have a happy ending or I will resurrect and haunt the writer and PD!!!!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Does anybody know the song playing during the scene towards the end where the prince is writing something at his desk at night?
According to the subtitles it starts like this "in unexpected thoughts of you I toss and turn during nights..." The chorus starts with "The endless days and nights without you..." It's a guy singing.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

the song is not out yet I think. Since Ben's song (produced by Jinyoung (Yoonsung) is the song released this week.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

AM I THE ONLY ONE WHO THINKS THIS DRAMA SUCKS?

I love Park Bo Gum and Kim Yoo Jung. I high high high expectations that this drama will put a smile on my face.But I find myself with creased eyebrows all the time and even until episode 7.

And I look at all these comments and everybody is squealing.

The script is so fvcking bad, there is no actual plot. Bo Gum and Yoo Jung I'm afraid looks good together as a picture perfect picture but contains 0either they're character or acting isn't convincing me. There is 0% chemistry.

I desperately want to be happy like everyone else. I smiled at the teaser of a prince who prances around dancing Boombastic. But 7 episodes gave me nothing. And the worst part is everyone doesn't seem to think so.

I haven't comment all recaps because the mood is always squeal happy but I can't not anymore because this is unfathomable.

How can this be so much a let down. Is there no one at all who feel the same?

0
14
reply

Required fields are marked *

I went into this drama with zero expectations; zilch, nada, soon, nothing.... And that is what makes me happy. That it makes me smile. Because it is cute without expectations.

As much as a wave DOTS, Doctors etc have been. They failed me. Big time. Disappointed to my core. So no. I have no complaints. But then again. Isn't that the best part. Interpretations. To each their own. It's also interesting to listen to the other side of a squee.

Cheers! Hope the drama gets better for you.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

That's why art is such a glorious, personal choice. The love of art is always in the eye of the beholder. You might not be alone but it's doubtful many viewers who dislike Moonlight will show up on this site. It's almost like the DB Squee-fest over Healer when a disgruntled viewer wandered in and we were all like, "What, who are you? Oh - wrong house - your party must be down the street". Don't worry about your opinion. I severely disliked Descendants of the Sun and Doctors.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't think anyone is expecting a real sageuk from a fluffy script based on a web-novel written by a fangirl.
It's just a squee happy teenage romance.

I honestly think it would fail if it tries to be too serious.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Can't say I feel the same with you. But if this drama is failing you big time, I think you should just drop it and never look back, maybe this isn't your cup of tea at all. I mean I didn't get the Healer hype either and I stayed far far away from the drama and its fanbase, worked quite well for me, I get to explore other dramas much to my liking and worthy of my time.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm sure you are not alone. Outnumbered maybe but not alone. I have surprised myself for liking this drama. I think that the great performance of the two leads have a lot to do with it along with the adept directing.

I respect your opinion and I wish you much success in finding your next drama crack.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm not hating this drama like you but I'm disgusted because Scarlet Heart is clearly a better drama an it's run off the rails because this drama is sucking all the air from the room. I agree KYJ has spent 7 episodes looking "surprised" or looking at her feet. Bo gum is adorable and Jin Young has impressed me with his good looks. He rocks a hanbok like Lee Jun ki with that pretty face. Otherwise clearly the South Korean viewiing audience is very easily pleased I think. I think people are watching this because it doesn't have any idols to complain about.

0
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm not hating you but Scarlet Heart is clearly a bad, very bad drama. Bad in all aspects. All I could see is IU getting wide-eyed, wide-eyed, wide-eyed... at every opportunity. It's funny how people keep on saying SH is a dark drama, therefore it's a better drama. And MDBC is a light drama, therefore it's not a good drama. Whether a story is complicated or not, both can be a success or failure depending on how well it's done. To me, until episode 6, SH is just a childish story, not dark at all. I don't see the glory of Goryeo period in the drama. All princes swooning over one girl? Really? IU's character has no purpose other than remembering bits and pieces of her history lesson, falling in love with her cousin's husband, just to create rift between WS and WW later on. And to very easily avoid being married to the King by injuring her own self, eh, too simple. I wish I could save Junki from it. I'm also disgusted of people who keep on saying MDBC doesn't deserve its success and rating just cos SH is a failure, and people who watch MDBC are simple-minded and only twelve year old kids will love it. I don't agree Korean audience are very easy to please. They are one of the most unexpected audience. Remember Baker King Takgu? Except for the older casts, YSY, JW and the young actors were rookies at that time. KBS did little to promote it. But it was highly successful. Any drama, even with top stars, can be a hit or miss. Beautiful Mind is the biggest disappointment when it comes to SK audience, but should we blame them? Let them watch what they want. Don't try to judge them as if we are superior than them in appreciating dramas.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

For me, Scarlet has a great plot plus A+ actors ( imagine LJK who is a veteran and has a huge fan based ) but the editing, music and directing part sucks when i watched the first 3 episodes. I can't stand watching it so i switched to MDTC. Moonlight on the other hand has a simple and common plot but the execution on the director's and writer's part are superb. They are the reason why this show is a huge hit. Plus of course the great performances of the actors. Sometimes no matter how great the actors are but if the screenplay sucks, it's just going to ruin the whole thing

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

The biggest problem with SH is its editing. Watching it is really frustrating. Everything feels like just a 'touch and go' moments. I wish they could give us more time to get invested in the scenes & characters. For example, HS being forced to marry the king. I was really surprised to see it ended & solved in just 15 minutes perhaps? Please, I want to feel for her, it's forced marriage fgs and to the mighty king. But she's all calm. The next thing we hear is something broken and we see her arm bleeding. Then the king laughed and praised her, and she's off the hook. Later, she dreamt about the next king. The editing is like telling me, ok, we're done with King Taejo, now the king after him. Touch & go. I have no time to feel or think. And the close-up shots need to stop. I can't see their forehead most of the time. It's too much, I feel like I need to scroll up my tv screen.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't think there is any need for comparison of the two dramas or the actors. All the actors are playing different roles and we all have our own personal bias to root for without putting others down.

You say you don't hate Moonlight but you are disgusted because Scarlet is clearly a better drama? That doesn't make any sense dude or dudette.

Go and watch the better drama and enjoy it. Ratings is not everything. If you don't like Kim Yoo-jung then don't watch her lol.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm disgusted that anyone would blame Moonlight for Moon Lovers' bad ratings. If Moon Lovers is such a good drama, why bother about the ratings, and please kindly go over the Moon Lovers recap and rave all you want there. Thrashing this drama won't change anything about Moon Lovers, you're just hurting fans here, can't you hear our shattering hearts?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

read the comments.. and so happy that most did not try to kick me out for commenting. TBH, I still do want to say something about this show despite me not becoming satisfied with it - because I care about this drama. I care about anything that allows me to have Park Bo Gum on screen..

although some compared it to Healer, I must say I swoon, and fell and my heart tick tocked with Healer. Love it so dearly.

still not giving up on this show though.. because I'm the sort who watches everything and still cant get enough of dramas.

I'm watching Jealousy and Scarlet alongside this, but I'm not gonna compare.. that's not my style.. I like and dislike dramas based on each of its own =)

Thanks for everyone who made some nice comments. It puts a smile on my face that somebody actually replied back HAHA

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

too bad that you cannot enjoy the drama as much as others. I have been in the same place with some other dramas (Healer) so I kinda understand, but to explain what the plot is and to point out some moments ...

The plot is a young prince regent who already has no supporters creating even more scorn for him by giving reason to rumors. he has the smarts but he doesnt have leverage, and he is risking the little of it he has by openly showing favor to Ra On. Yeong is boldly swimming in dangerous waters, that is what is the most interesting part for me. The other thing is his friends having their own agendas or commitments with sides directly or symbolically opposing yeong, and being conflicted. Yes, he is their friend, but he is also the authority they need to overthrow, which one is it going to be? I still hope friendship wins over political commitments.

I find the acting very good by the leads. Yoo Jung is showing a girl cornered into an inescapable situation, where her neck is on the line from all sides even without her gender issue, with that, the risk is even higher. she is constantly on her toes, she has to have more smarts than anyone else, it is like she is playing 4 simultanious chess games. but as she said, liking someone in that crazy, treacherous place the palace is, and having allies there make sit easier. Imagine being a young girl in that situation? She is playing it the most realistically of all the cross-dressing characters I have seen. All of Ra Ons doubts and her words are on point, she is always pointing out the consequences of this and that.

Bogummies´ acting lies in microexpressions, tiny changes in his eyes. Maybe it is too fine for some to notice. It is not acting with broad strokes. Yeong seems cheeky, a bit careless, irresponsible, but in truth is well aware of his position. He is very calculating instead of rushing head on into action, but he also longs for simple, warm, human connection so that this constant tension doesnt wear him out. He needs some love and warmth to stay strong, especially cause he tragically lost his mom. I think Bogummy is showing it perfectly, I am not just talking as a fan - I was more impressed by Yoo Jung in the first 2 episodes and thought too much psycho-Min was coming out in Bogummies´ eyes (still does in some moments, but he shows a very wide range of expressions next to that).

In the end, even though romance is in the forefront, it is very nicely tied with Yeongs´ struggles as a prince-regent.
the only thing that is left a little wanting are the female second and third leads. The princess is really cute, I want her to have her own spin-off as a chubby princess in the look for love (and getting left behind to survive on her own). And unfortunately Chae Soo-Bin is totally failing this drama. I like her, but the bar is set too high for her. the character has not made any strong impact for 3 episodes. I dont hate her nor love her. I guess we just have to endure her somehow.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh... if you put it your storytelling the drama sounded better hahaha
I don't catch it as much during watching.. like they don't have real problem so I don't feel the plot moving at all.. except very recently when we find her as the lost daughter of a suspect-rebel..

I do think its turning up episode 8 when we finally get confirmation that he know what she is.

Guess I miss the fan squeal there haha

X.x

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well. The first order of business...... SQUEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE ❤️❤️❤️❤️.... I don't care if she's a man or an alien or what..... I just want this ship to sail. Into eternity.

A year and half and countless KDramas and recaps later, I finally have the excuse to squeee. And comment. And forgive me. Is it rude that I type this while at dinner with friends. Grinning like an the Cheshire cat. Flailing..... Seemingly a complete lunatic in polite society.

What no other drama could make me do...... Choi Han Gyul... I'm forever biased but this ship is sailing into the moonlight for me. Writernim, Production Teamnim.... There better be a ship sailing into the moonlight (with dolphins if possible).

Thank you team DB for always being true to your wit. And reminding me of the love that is Choi Han Gyul.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Why do I feel that Yeong is almost aware of the truth already. And is letting his heart guide him.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Can you die from cuteness overload?!?!?!?!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Park go bum...i command you to stand in line with the other A list actors....you earn it.....!!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh dear, i like bogum a lot. Really like him s lot. Been following him since Naeil Cantabile, I Remember You, Reply 1988. But i cringed in the kiss scene. I can't squee. Kim Yoo Jung looked totally uncomfortable like she was forced into a goldfish kiss. =____=
It's not enough in kiss scene, even if the guy is emoting so much feel, if the girl has an assaulted expression on her face.
Just a side note though, they just broadcasted gay and paedo confession on national TV! Will they go to censor board for discipline (ref producers)?

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think she is very confused and doesn't really know how to response to his love confession and so out of the blue especially since he is the crown prince of all people.
She is supposed to be a young man and she had never kiss a man (or a woman) before.

How do you think she should've response then?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

SQUEEEEE
Btw, now that the romance has actually started can we pay some attention to our bromance too pleaseeee....

Literally want to see more of our Kim Hyung and Yoon Sung.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm here for the bromance too! Can't they all just stay friends?!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Speaking of being immersed in a scene. The last scene in the garden. I was totally their. I could feel the breeze smell the flowers. I should've taken my allergy medicine I'm a little stuffy today. It's like I was a little fairy trying to get closer to hear what was being said. When they kissed I looked away and put my hands up to hide my face. But then, I'm a naughty fairy so I turned to peek through my fingers. LOL

Good art no matter what the medium should engage the viewer. Moonlight drawn by clouds. Bravo

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

OH MY GAWD!!!!!!!!!!! And I thought I was only shrieking at the end of episode 7!! 8 is.....
um...just is.........GAH.

Is that a spoiler? JB and GF - delete this comment if so.

I'll go squeeeeee in a quiet corner.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Omgosh I know right and I thought nothing could make me squeeze more than yesterday's episode.
Let's just somehow wait another few hours for jb to post the recap and then we can all squeeeee as much as we want.
Until then though, I think I'll just carry on flailing and grinning like an idiot while watching the episode again XD

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I know this won't be popular but I just have to say it. I've enjoyed this drama. I just wish it wasn't sucking all the life out of Scarlet Heart Ryeo. I just don't see why this is considered a better drama. They're both good. IU and Baekhyun too way to much criticism for being "terrible" before the drama really had a chance to start. Kim Yu jung isn't a any better than IU. She's spent the entire series looking "wide eyed" at PBG. Which is the same complaint I heard about IUs acting. Seriously folks they should never run these in tandem and I had a feeling those two and their past "controversies" would follow them. Really not fair considering Lee Jun ki is a veteran actor and deserves better. So does the rest of the cast. Maybe casting idols isn't such a good idea. Not because of their acting but because of their fan base.

0
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

@TJ - I am watching Scarlet Heart Ryeo and enjoying it too - quite a lot - but I think the production crew made an initial error in judgment by thinking that casting that many idols and pretty boys at one time would multiply the pleasure of viewers. I think that's what essentially backfired. I adore Lee Jun-ki and Ha Neul - and I really like IU in this and all her other dramas. I just feel frustrated and slightly bored when the scenes do NOT include our main cast. The rest of them (as adorable as they may be individually) just distract me from the story and I lose focus.
For me, the incredible charm of Moonlight Drawn by Clouds (beyond the cast) is the lovely straight line simplicity of the story. It follows the "less is more" rule and enhances each moment with far more power and elegance. It's like reading a great poem and being allowed to pause between stanzas to take it all in. It's like being able to take a deep breath and feeling the air fill my lungs. I love the lovely moments of Scarlet Heart as well but I feel like I'm always bracing and looking over my shoulder for the moment when my senses will be invaded and overrun by too many characters and too much additional input crowding in. This is just my feeling and explanation for the preference.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Your description of what you felt about moonight drawn by clouds is simply beautiful! :)

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think in terms of execution, there's no denying that Moonlight does it better. I don't think it's too much to ask for from a pre-produced drama to have at least some flow, decently timed osts, and logical character development. Especially since the source material for Scarlet Heart is already there and so rich. I just think the production team focused too much on the frosting when the cake wasn't even baked.

Out of all the dramas airing right now, Moonlight has just been a delightful, easy watch. It's unfair to say that its popularity is sucking all the air out of Scarlet Heart, because the ratings were Scarlet Heart's to lose. I actually don't really understand why people are so indignant that Scarlet isn't getting the ratings it "deserves"... It just seems like a weak adaptation of the novel imo. It might be worth it to read/watch the original to gain a sense of what's missing from Scarlet Heart. Perhaps it would've done better as a stand-alone drama that didn't have to bend over backward to find historical similarities and provide gratuitous fan service.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I think the not so favorable ratings of SH is due to bad editing of the first 3 episodes and not because of the actors acting capability. This is IU's best acting performance for me. But i don't agree with u when u said the KYJ is no better than her. KYJ is far more veteran than IU knowing she's a child actress since the age of 8 or younger.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Why is MLDBC doing very well "sucking all the life out of Scarlet Heart Ryeo"? In my opinion SHR does not have much life to be sucked out of to begin with. MLDBC is doing well because it is doing things right whereas SHR is not.

"I just don’t see why this is considered a better drama." Again, no, people are not watching MLDBC because they've decided to consider it the better of the two, but it is the other way around. Because a lot of people are drawn to it and watching it, it looks the better of the two.

"Kim Yu jung isn’t any better than IU." I must strongly disagree with this. Have you seen two very similar scenes where both girls were missing and crying for their mothers? I was annoyed by IU's whining but I teared up when YJ cried in her sleep. Maybe some of it had to do with the ways the stories were written, but YJ at a much younger age than IU is a far more experienced and talented actress. In MLDBC, she is such a shiny happy bundle of puppy that Hong Ra On is whereas IU... I don't get why so many Goryeo princes find her so charming as if she were the only woman in that kingdom. I have seen a few actors and actresses who would not be considered typically handsome or beautiful, but they have that aura about them that make them extremely attractive. IU doesn't have that as far as I can see it.

"Really not fair considering Lee Jun ki is a veteran actor and deserves better." As much as I like LJK, do you think any actor or actress does not try hard to do the parts given to them? Everybody does and in that sense everybody deserves better. However, in real life, not everyone can win. That is why you have to choose wisely and when your choice turns out to be a wrong one, you have to bear the consequences.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm watching Scarlet Heart as well but I have to say, SH is just not well written and the production and direction is all wrong. I do think PBG and KYJ are doing a better job and have great chemistry but the overall writing is much tighter and the dialogue is much wittier and sharper in Moonlight. I was looking forward to SH so I was quite disappointed and continue to be so by the very prosaic writing, unimaginative dialogue and poor editing (really, how many super zoomed in close ups do we need per episode). Also, the writing assumes that we should automatically be invested in the characters and their motivations but they have given us very little to feel invested. What? Just because they're good looking? I think you need something more than that to appeal to the audience these days.

Finally, there is no progression on the story. It has this amazing cast and a lot of money invested in it but it can't seem to get the story going. I find each episode rather slow and uneventful - honestly, can you tell me what has happened since episode 1 except that everyone under the sun likes IU? That's not much of plot driving force. Compare to that, you feel the plot moving forward and you almost feel like time has past and the characters are invested in each other and you the audience is invested in what happens to the characters. That's really the difference between the two dramas and why one is better than the other. It's not the good looking cast or who is more popular. I don't think the audiences are idiots, they can tell what is better storytelling and they are going with that.

I'll continue to watch both but so far I am much more interested in what is happening in Moonlight.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I bet Ha-yeon was watching all the mad adorable love between the prince and Ra-on (omg when Ra-on closed her eyes in consent to what was about to happen!!!! *heart palpitations*)! I also bet that Ha-yeon was not squeeing with the rest of us.... >.>

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love the effect that both this drama and PBG has on us beanies- we lose our shit with every new episode and WHAM! 500+ comments :')

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

No squee here...not a lemming. That ending was a safe, P.C.-driven bit of self-congratulatory nonsense. Ugh.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Just finished watching ep 8 and I can't wait to squeeeee again in ep8 recap with everyone ???

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Moderators, could we please remove all Amie's references, and replies, to rumours of Park Bo-Geum's sexual preferences. It doesn't matter if such gossip is substantiated or not. What matters is that it has no place on this site. What matters is that an actor's private life is private, an actor's sexual preferences are their rightful own (and there is no right or wrong in sexual preferences), none of our business, and have no relevance whatsoever to discussion of tv show characters. As an educator dealing with combatting prejudice of all kinds in life, I beg your pardon for standing on this soapbox.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

So now it's okay for an actual 16-17 year old girl to kiss a grown man in a drama. Why not most girls do what she is doing? Don't study and act and get to kiss all the flower boys??? This isn't bringing out a good image. I hope the rest of SE Asia doesn't follow suit.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Most girls don't do that because they are not a talented, much sought-after actress like KYJ, who "gets to" act opposite flower boy actors like PBG.

And for your information, Korea is not a SE Asian country. It is in Northeast Asia a/k/a the Far East.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Wow you act like this was the first time it ever happened on tv in Korea or any country in Asia.

Obviously you don't know anything about Kim Yoo-jung to make comments about her personal life. How do you know that she doesn't study or go to school?

The door is that way --->

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Wow. That was snarky. But since you pointed out the door...after you.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

PBG and KYJ.... these two... I just can't.... THEY ARE TOO CUTE!! SO ADORABLE I WANT TO SQUEEZE SOMEONE, ANYONE'S, CHEEKS!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

here i go. here i go.. next ep. I'm so excited that i have to say something before i start ep 8.

Okay Breath!!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

So, do you guys think that he is pretty sure that she's a girl? Because it seems like he suspects it, but he was so deep in thought the night before he confessed to her, which makes me think th

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

that he still thinks that she's a completely a guy. So, too him, he just kissed and confessed his love to a guy.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Second request: would you please remove 1.1.1. Amie's irrelevant and unnecessary references to rumours about Park Bo-Geum's sexual preferences. There are no rights or wrongs in sexual preferences and actors' private lives have nothing to do with the characters they are portraying. My gay students and gay friends are just people and they don't enjoy being singled out based on their sexual preferences.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Third Request to Moderators: please remove the thread 1.1.1. etc etc from AMIE referring to actor Park Bo-Geum's gender preference rumours. Commenters should be commenting on the tv show, not on actors' private lives - it is none of our business. As an educator, human rights activist, I believe that even Amie's type of "hey, psst" remark continues the modern world's discrimination with regard to gender preferences.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recap, JB! Just managed to get caught up on the recent ep's the other day.

OMG!! The feeeeeels!! *squeeeeeeals* This is such a touching ep. with many emotions that struck my heart. Eunuch Ma and Wolhee / Crown Prince and Raon! What a wonderful portrayal of the parallel story and I loved how what RO said gave Yeong pause at his thinking. And in turn, it spurred him on to act on his feelings and made his confession. The kiss at the end was just a lovely way to conclude the ep.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hahaha! Everyone is squeeing over the kiss. I was reminded of Coffee Prince confession scene during the kiss scene.

That being said, I was surpised that no one mentioned (at least from the quick scan of the 500 over comments!) about Eunuch Ma being... an Eunuch. Maybe I am being shallow here but is it physically possible for the couple to be together? Perhaps someone knowledgeable could enlighten me on this. I am really puzzled.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Does anybody know the name of the song played while Ra On was eating with Lee Young? Been looking all over for the title :(

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Love this show so much :D

So funny and yet sweet and heartwarming whenever the CP expresses his concern to Ra-on, which she interprets it differently from her perspective..

I can never get enough of their sweet scenes haha..

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Im so confused guys xD can someone enlighten me, Did he or did he not know (Prince Yeong) that ra-on was a female? And he love her as a man? *O* and if he did found out she is a woman, when was it? XD

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I wasn't so happy with a confession + kiss since Gong Yoo's "I don't care you're a man or an alien" confession in Coffee Prince.
Coffee Prince is my fav drama ever because I just can't get tired of this "woman disguised as a man" thing since I was a little girl watching Disney's Mulan.

I love that "Li Shang's complex" that the male guys feel when they think they're gay but still put their love first.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *