149

Sword and Flower: Episode 20 (Final)

I’ve had pretty bad luck with finales lately (in that I’m starting to forget what it feels like to watch a good one), and while the ending for Sword and Flower doesn’t strike like lightning out of a clear blue sky, it does serve as a textbook example of everything that makes viewers wary to start a show without puppies and rainbows built into the premise. It’s everything we hate about bad finales all rolled into one.

So despite its interesting start, strong visual palette, and a few great actors, in the end it all comes down to a show’s ability to weave a coherent narrative. Turns out that’s a necessary prerequisite to gain the indispensable asset that is a viewer’s trust—because without that, this show becomes the very reason why we can’t have nice things. (But a nice drink before diving into this hour might not be a bad idea. Cheers!)

 
FINAL EPISODE RECAP

After telling Mo-seol about his crazed plans to become king, Nam-saeng goes to the actual king to report that everything’s going according to plan. I’m sure he’s only told Jang half of the actual plan.

Jang is dubious about the whole thing and asks Nam-saeng what would happen if he decided to tell General Yeon everything. “If you betray me, I won’t let it go like father did,” Nam-saeng warns with his usual smirk.

Nam-saeng visits the imprisoned Mu-young to see if she’s any more inclined toward revenge. She blankly asks what she should do, which translates to “Let’s do this!” in Nam-saeng’s world.

He tells her she only needs to prepare her sword while he does the rest, and gives her a cheeky reminder to use one blow to kill General Yeon this time, since everyone knows how the last attempt worked out.

When she asks why he won’t do the deed himself, Nam-saeng chuckles. “How could I kill my father with my own hands? Who will follow a man who has killed his own father?” Whereas people will just see it as revenge if she were to do it.

It’s a win-win for both of them, since Mu-young will become queen and Nam-saeng will become Dae Mangniji. But then he drops the bomb: “And as Dae Mangniji, I will marry you.” He couldn’t be creepier as he grips her shoulders and asks her if they make a good couple—of course, in his mind, why wouldn’t she be chomping at the bit to marry a psychopath?

Mu-young is clearly playing him to get what she wants, since her inner thoughts reveal that she has no intentions of marrying him. Her words say differently as she requests to see Geumhwadan so that they won’t ruin “their” plan. Crazypants McGee actually trusts her enough to let her go.

She convinces Geumhwadan that she’s leaving to start a new life with Choong and that it’s time to leave the past behind. They believe her.

Meanwhile, Choong and Bear Teacher manage to find the shed Nam-saeng hid the princess in during their search. Inside is her portrait necklace and a list of the intelligence agents, but soon Nam-saeng materializes in the doorway: “I knew you hid the princess here!” Huh? Is he trying to frame them?

Short answer: Yes. Long answer: He planted evidence in the shed to prove that Choong is working together with the princess, and that he even worked with Bear Teacher to break her out of prison.

But Bear Teacher speaks up to defend Choong, claiming that he acted alone in helping Mu-young. Choong sends him a look, but Bear Teacher just gives him a reassuring nod—he’s got this. He makes up a feasible excuse for why Choong was seen with him and goes on and on, causing Nam-saeng to start rolling his eyes.

Bear Teacher addresses General Yeon specifically, and the two share a wordless gaze. It’s like they both know that he’s lying to protect Choong, so General Yeon has no choice but to feed into it when he orders Bear Teacher imprisoned.

Nam-saeng is incensed that Choong won’t be getting punished, but there’s nothing he can do. His plan backfired.

Choong visits Bear Teacher in prison to ask why he took the fall for him, and his teacher replies that he did it for General Yeon, whom he’s served for many years. If Choong were in jail instead of him, General Yeon would be without Choong’s protection. Especially since they don’t know Nam-saeng’s plans yet.

“Your eyes are not those of a warrior,” Bear Teacher notes. “How difficult it must have been for you to kill people with such tender eyes. However, there is something you must finish. Please protect your father, General Yeon Gaesomun.”

Nam-saeng dogs his father’s steps to nag him about his unfailing trust in Choong when his better son has never betrayed him like that. He declares that he has no more confidence to serve his father as it stands and asks to be sent to another post outside the capital so he can think on his faults.

But when his father tells him to do just that, Nam-saeng finally breaks down. “You’re not even going to ask me to stay? Just once, can’t you say, ‘You’re also my son, I have faith in you too. Don’t even think about other things and stay by me.’ Can’t you tell me that just once?”

Tears fall from Nam-saeng’s eyes as he asks for what he knows he won’t receive, and it’d be a nice character moment for him had it come before he decided to murder his father. This would’ve even helped to bridge the gap between Nam-saeng seeking his father’s affection and Nam-saeng seeking to, y’know, kill him.

But it’s not that real of a moment after all, since Nam-saeng walks away from his father with a maniacal chuckle. I wish this moment of sincerity had been real. Even just one humanizing scene could do wonders for a character as far gone as him.

While his minion recruits intelligence agents to his side, Nam-saeng visits Mo-seol’s dad and lightly threatens him into handing over a list of all the generals who have pledged allegiance to Nam-saeng, Mo-seol’s dad included.

Mo-seol confronts her dad over his treachery, but he defends himself by claiming that he’s standing on the winning side—and that winner is going to be Nam-saeng.

She’s against this idea, since it means her father will be participating in a dangerous coup. (And we all know what happens if you lose.) That’s why he asks for her help in keeping it a secret. Nam-saeng has half the intelligence agents on his side as well as the king, so they’re sure to win.

Jang thinks on his options as he prepares to write Nam-saeng’s appointment letter promoting him to Dae Mangniji. There’s Nam-saeng claiming to offer him a second chance, and then there’s General Yeon, who’d aptly noted that Jang was afraid of what Goguryeo would be like without him. Which side will he choose?

Mo-seol uses her top spy skills to find Mu-young so that she can ask her if she really plans on killing the father of the man she loves. Mu-young replies that General Yeon is only the man who murdered her father to her, to which Mo-seol replies with almost a shrug—if she kills Choong’s father and becomes his enemy, it’ll only be good for her.

Mu-young’s expression doesn’t change (ever) as she tells Mo-seol to not tell Choong about the plan if she wants that to happen. But Mo-seol instead draws her sword and proclaims that she’s come to kill Mu-young. “Had you died earlier, none of this would have happened!”

She lunges at an unarmed Mu-young, who manages to dodge a few blows before Mo-seol knocks her to the ground. Raising her sword for the killing blow, Mo-seol asks if Mu-young will only stop once she ends up getting Choong killed. Then she brings the blade down…

But before she can kill her, she’s stabbed from behind. It’s Nam-saeng, wearing his usual cheshire grin even as he says that Mo-seol is the only person he’s ever felt bad about killing, and that he couldn’t let her live to tell everyone their plan. (His regretful face is the same as his I’m-so-happy-to-be-murdering-today face, so it’s honestly hard to tell.)

With her last breath, Mo-seol stares at Mu-young: “Stop. You have to stop. You cannot kill Yeon Gaesomun. Don’t make Choong suffer any longer.”

Then Nam-saeng twists the blade and wrenches it free, causing Mo-seol to collapse to the ground.

Nam-saeng acts as though he just killed a fly as he tells Mu-young that they’ll have to move, since Choong is combing the city looking for her.

Nam-saeng: “I told you, didn’t I? Brothers, friends, parents… they don’t matter to me. I will kill anyone that gets in my way.” Yes, Nam-saeng, you told her. But you’re at about a nine right now on the psychometer, and you might want to tone it down to a healthy three if you want this girl to marry you. (We know it’s not going to happen anyway, but he could at least try.)

Choong finds Mo-seol on the brink of death, and she blames him and Mu-young as she chokes back blood—if Mu-young had truly died three years ago, she’s sure she and Choong would have been happily married.

Then she tells Choong that Nam-saeng plans to kill his father on the day of the military parade, and Choong’s first question is to ask where the princess is.

Mo-seol calls him cruel for worrying about the princess first when she’s the one who’s dying, and I love that he’s sorry without actually being sorry—he’s not going to lie to her even on her deathbed about where his heart lies.

Then she dies.

Mu-young finds Choong walking alone (why bother) and leads him to an equally secluded but more scenic area. When he tells her he was worried about her, she replies that he has no reason to be—she’s given up on her revenge. Choong: “Then… can you leave with me?”

“Why should I?” Mu-young asks. “I no longer have feelings for you.” Auuugh. This is not happening right now. Mu-young skipped the noble part and went straight to eediot.

At least Choong sees through her bullshit and knows she’s lying, even when she claims Nam-saeng didn’t threaten her and that she’s made this decision on her own. “Then it’s my decision to protect you,” Choong states matter-of-factly.

He tells her the reality of the situation—He won’t tell her what to do, but he’ll stop her any way he can. He warns her against letting Nam-saeng use her to kill General Yeon because that will sign her death warrant…

Until Nam-saeng’s voice calls from behind: “You’re wrong, Hyung-nim.” He’s standing four feet away with armed guards again, which makes me think that everyone in this show must be terribly hard of hearing. Also, aren’t you people supposed to be spies? Or something?

To make matters worse, it was apparently Mu-young who drew Choong into the trap. Nam-saeng: “You don’t need to protect the princess, because the princess won’t die. How could a husband kill his wife?”

He slings an arm around Mu-young’s shoulders and taunts Choong: “You didn’t think that far ahead? I’m going to marry her and make her my queen.”

Choong is dragged off by the agents while Mu-young brushes Nam-saeng’s arm off. “You must keep your promise. You cannot kill him.” Dafaq. Is. Happening.

Geumhwadan hears about Mu-young’s wedding news with worried faces, all of them wondering if she ditched them so she could become queen. Shi-woo and Leader So keep the faith, with the latter thinking that Mu-young is the one using Nam-saeng to attack General Yeon, not the other way around.

But they’re sure she won’t marry Nam-saeng afterward, which prompts Leader So to guess that she plans on committing suicide after she kills Yeon. Wait, IS that her big plan? She’s going to choose revenge in the end and then just give up?

Jang receives a mysterious message while Mu-young polishes her sword, remembering how her father and brother were killed. She cuts her hand in the process and thinks back to her father’s words about the sword protecting the flower. A lot of good it does her.

Jang goes to the market in disguise to meet with Mu-young, who’s looking so shut off that it almost feels like a blessing that she’s speaking in complete sentences. She’s come to bid her cousin goodbye, warn him that Nam-saeng mustn’t inherit his father’s seat after his father is gone, and to leave Goguryeo in his hands. She’s given up on taking his place.

“Do you have to do this? I’m afraid of Goguryeo without Yeon Gaesomun,” Jang admits. “Without him, Goguryeo will not be able to fight off Tang.”

Mu-young turns to him: “You’re the king of Goguryeo. You have to make the right decision.” Her eyes fill with unshed tears, as do Jang’s.

Jang tells General Yeon to cancel the military parade in an effort to save his life, since Nam-saeng is plotting against him. General Yeon isn’t even fazed as he assures the king that nothing will happen, causing Jang to ask in a small voice what it would mean if he was working with Nam-saeng.

“Your Majesty, I believe in you,” General Yeon replies. “If it’s a decision you’ve made for the future of Goguryeo, then I will respect your decision.” So Yeon is basically telling him it’s all right to kill him if that’s what Jang thinks is best? Did I miss the scene where everyone died inside?

Mu-young pays a visit to Choong’s prison shed. “I came to say goodbye. This isn’t about my revenge… I’m going to end this fight once and for all.” Okay, but it is really just about your revenge, isn’t it?

She doesn’t have a good answer for him as to how she plans on not handing Goguryeo over to Nam-saeng other than that it won’t come to pass, because “If there isn’t anyone left to be killed, then no one will be killed.” She says that like it makes sense, except for the small part where it doesn’t.

It dawns on Choong that she’s talking about a world where she and his father won’t exist, so he knows she plans on dying and starts to panic.

“Can’t you leave with me now?” he asks. “Why don’t you ever think about me? Why don’t you think about leaving me behind? Do you know what my life has been like without you? Why would you give me that pain again?” These are all very good questions, and ones that Mu-young doesn’t have the answers to.

Mu-young cries as Choong asks her to remember the meal they shared while his mom was hanging laundry nearby, and how happy that moment was.

“All I ever wanted… was for us to live together,” Choong says though his tears. Mu-young turns around, and they both share a pained look before she forces herself to leave. Not even one word, Mu-young? Really?

Choong struggles to free himself and kills the guards outside in order to follow her. Aww, puppy.

The military sit-and-stare parade is interrupted by Nam-saeng and the legion of agents loyal to his cause. They’re all carrying swords, but when they’re revealed to be made of wood (real weapons aren’t allowed/boring enough), they’re allowed inside.

Geumhwadan sits in the exact same spot as they did for the last military parade, and in the exact same disguises as before. Hahaha. This must be a joke. Even if you banked on the idea that their faces are unknown, Leader So was imprisoned by the agency for three years and had a portrait of his face in circulation. I can’t.

Jang knows something is up when he doesn’t see Choong with Nam-saeng’s legion of agents, and that’s because Choong is currently fighting his way through hordes of other agents loyal to Nam-saeng for reasons us mere mortals couldn’t understand. (Side note: Were there no actual soldiers in Goguryeo? Or citizens?)

General Yeon announces that he’ll be rewarding Nam-saeng for his accomplishments by sending him away, and if this scene looks and sounds exactly like the prelude to General Yeon’s coup, that’s because it is—the powers that be must have figured that we loved that scene so much we’d want to see it twice!

Choong sustains heavy injuries as he fights alone through never-ending swarm of agents as Nam-saeng ascends the steps toward his father. There’s a sense of deja vu as Nam-saeng knocks the scroll out of his father’s hands to flip the table over in slow motion…

…In order to draw the sword hidden in the floor. Oh, they were actually serious about this shot-for-shot remake. So Nam-saeng is repeating his father’s coup down to the letter against his father, the man who did all of this first (and better)? I feel like I’m in The Twilight Zone. What am I watching?!

Nam-saeng orders his father to step down as Choong slowly shuffles toward the palace gates covered in blood. He drops his sword and looks like he’s about to keel over.

“Are you really going to kill me?” General Yeon apathetically asks to the son holding a sword against his neck. Nam-saeng is all, Who, me? Never!

The doors swing open to reveal Mu-young dressed in her princess’ garb. As she walks toward General Yeon, Choong walks toward the assembly. He keeps passing guards and other agents who don’t even spare him a second glance, which I guess means he’s made it to the boss level.

The members of Geumhwadan just gape at Mu-young as Mu-young draws her sword and passes them. Seriously, why are you people even here?

Choong reaches the hall by the time Mu-young reaches his father, and none of the agents try to stop him. Nam-saeng eggs Mu-young on, but seeing Choong causes her to hesitate.

That’s when General Yeon speaks up to say that her father’s rule wasn’t what Goguryeo wanted, even though Mu-young remembers how her father once accused Yeon of acting out of fear—he was always afraid of Tang.

They go back and forth over who’s vision for Goguryeo was right, all while Nam-saeng just urges her to get it over with. It takes one order from Choong for the agents to lower their inexplicably-real swords, which kind of makes the whole agency betrayal moot, doesn’t it? If they’re still loyal enough to follow Choong’s orders, how did things get to this point?

General Yeon: “How is this any different from when I killed your father? You’re not fighting for Goguryeo. You’re fighting for your own personal revenge.” He adds that she’s welcome to kill him if she truly believes she’s right… and if she truly thinks she can protect Goguryeo from Tang.

Mu-young turns around, and Choong slowly shakes his head when their eyes meet. She announces to those gathered that she’s not here to kill General Yeon, nor is she seeking revenge any longer. She asks them to shed no more blood for the sake of Goguryeo so that they can protect their country. “These are my last words as princess of Goguryeo.”

She raises her sword to kill herself, but Choong rushes forward to grab the blade with his bare hands. Choong: “You cannot die before I do.”

Nam-saeng laughs—he knew Mu-young would flake out. He then calls on Jang to finish the job, and when he doesn’t, Nam-saeng invites anyone willing to kill his father.

“I am Dae Mangniji!” Nam-saeng yells as he dramatically unfurls the scroll Jang gave him as part of their agreement (that he’d appoint him to his father’s position). He reads it aloud triumphantly: “The Dae Mangniji of Goguryeo is now… Yeon Gaesomun?” Wamp wamp waaaamp.

So Jang betrayed him after all. I love that General Yeon, acting as Dae Mangniji, simply orders Nam-saeng to not let the door hit him on his way out.

Nam-saeng fixes all his anger and hatred on Mu-young, claiming that it’s all her fault. He raises his sword to stab her…

Suddenly, Choong spins her around so that he can take the sword meant for her. Ughhhh. He couldn’t have just… pulled her in the other direction?

Mu-young looks surprisingly unmoved as Choong sinks to the ground. “I kept my word,” he says with a small smile. “Princess… You must live. I beg this of you.”

“We will die together,” she says instead. She draws her sword and leaves Choong to collapse on the floor alone while she brandishes it at Nam-saeng. It’s cool for a second because you think she’s going to fight him…

But you’d be wrong, because she just gives him an open invitation to stab her through. They even have the audacity to cut to the Geumhwadan gang watching this all happen like it’s not their job to protect the princess.

Mu-young falls next to Choong, and the two stare wordlessly at each other as they die, because they can apparently use telepathy to communicate instead. (No joke.)

Mu-young: “The moment I met you, I thought that I would spend the rest of my life with you.”

Choong: “…Thank you.”

Mu-young: “I thought that you would always be by my side.”

Choong: “Thank you.”

Mu-young: “On the day my father died, I hated you so much I wanted to kill you.”

Choong: “I’m sorry.”

Mu-young: “Your wish for us to stay together for the rest of our lives came true.” Okay, way out of line. Couldn’t you at least let him die thinking you gave a damn?

Choong ekes out a smile as Mu-young’s last breath leaves her. They both pass away.

Cut to: Everyone reacting(?) to what just happened. Slowly, everyone fades away except for Mu-young and Choong. They fade away last, and the dates of General Yeon and Nam-saeng’s death flash on screen along with the date Goguryeo fell: 668 AD.

The end.

 
COMMENTS

 
RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , ,

149

Required fields are marked *

that's it?????!!!!!!

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

THAT WAS THE SAME REACTION I HAD!!!!!!!! Jesus Christ, I was so confused with this episode and then they just... died. Da Fuq.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Good thing I haven't started watching yet. Pass.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yep, me too xD. Two pass.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Same.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

AMEN

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

That ending was worse even than Dr. Jin

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

OK, let's put aside what I think of the acting and let's focus on the morale of the story:
You have a crazy psychopath in the house (who doesn't even hides his intentions) and he can wander in that palace without nobody tailing him or spying him or whatever?
It's like letting a fox in a coop. Happy killing party!
I would have:
1: Killed him preventively or
2: Put him behind bars or
3: Sent him in exile VERY far.
You know what I want to do? Distributing Darwin Awards to the leads in that story. Really too stupid to live!
#SurvivalOf TheFittestEvenIfHeIsAnA$$hole
You just can't take seriously a script like this and frankly I had a heartfelt laugh at the end. Sorry for those who shipped this couple cause really it's a pathetic ending, not even a heroic one. Kampai!

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was either laughing or bored. There was one moment when i got all choked up: the death of Mo Seol. I don't know why but it touched me. She was a good character i think ..at least i see what the writer was aiming at. Sure she was always skulking...and for a skulker she certainly missed out on a lot. And she had some true plot-purpose when she tried to kill Mu-young. And her death scene was lovely.

How some folks can die quickly from a sword and other folks be walking around a day later after being gutted with a sword or being lanced near the heart is always a wonder! Mo-Seol's death was tragic and touching...and felt real. Love that actress.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

Can we give a shout out to the WORST STABBING BY SWORD EVAH!? Because I just cracked the heck up when Nam Saeng "stabbed" the princess. It looked like he was trying to slice her skirt. Not even succeeding, but just flipping the skirt to the side.

Seriously show? You didn't reshoot that one? Had you all given up and gone home? ::throws things at screen::

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

LOL! YES! That was one of my spoiler comments yesterday. I kept thinking.."But, bu...bu..but..he stabbed her between her legs!"

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Me too. :'(

So sad for Mo Seol.

Also: "He keeps passing guards and other agents who don’t even spare him a second glance, which I guess means he’s made it to the boss level."

This wins the internet today. :D

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I expected a sad ending but I didn't expect that that's the way it was gonna play out. I feel the exact same way I did when I watched Chuno's ending. I hated the final episode and like I did with Chuno, this show only has 19 episodes and I'm just gonna forget that ep 20 ever happened.

Now for my rant.........

Moo young's revenge made sense because she was seeking vengeance for her family but what didn't make sense was how she was gonna accomplish it. Did she really need to cross dress her way to the agency? That's when my faith for the show started to waver because it's at that point that the show really went downhill and if it wasn't for Uhm force, I would have stopped watching. But then ep 17 was actually good (IMO) and so was ep 18 and it brought back the reason why I fell in love with the show in the first place and that's because of our main couple, they had amazing chemistry and I wanted a happy ending for them at all cost. And so when you give me that awful ending, I couldn't help but hate the whole episode. And it all goes back to Moo young's revenge, if she changed her mind about killing Yun Gaesomun, because she realized that her revenge was only personal and it would not help Goguryeo, why would she still show up there? To give a final speech and to kill herself in front of everyone? What was even the point of that? Would anything actually change if she dies? And because of that she got Choong killed. If only she just listened to him they could have run away together and lived. And they could have survived too because the only one who's gonna run after them is Nam Saeng and he could have been stopped by Yun Gaesomun. I believe that he did want Choong to be happy and not to turn out like him.

There was never a doubt that Choong would risk his life for Moo young so it was not that surprising that he shielded her but I was surprised that Moo young challenged Nam Saeng to fight and then she dropped her sword to be killed. Why not just do that herself? She was gonna do that anyway. I really thought that she was gonna fight to kill Nam Saeng to avenge Choong and his mom but she didn't even try. If she loved Choong that much to die with him, why couldn't she love him that much to run away with him and to live happily?

I still have A LOT of things to gripe about but I'll stop right here, I might end up hating the show if I focus on hating the finale.

To HeadsNo2: Thank you so much for the recap, I always love reading your insights every episode. Can't wait for your next recaps

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

After Dr. Jin, now this?

#respect

Thanks Heads!

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

The k-drama gods have not been nice to our Headsno2.
I think heads gets stuck with most of the duds in terms of recapped shows.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Me thinks she would have done recaps on "Cruel Palace" if it wasn't a 50 eps sageuk.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recap heads, I'm glad that this drama is finally over, I was starting to hate it but I'm still glad that I watched it because it made me discover Choi Min Soo and Kim Ok Bin, they were amazing in this and so was Uhm Tae Woong. It makes me sad that they were wasted in this, if only the writer wasn't on crack and actually put in even an ounce of effort. And questionable editing and redundant face shots and long pauses aside, I love the directing and especially the OST, I can't tell you how many times I've listened to Dear Love for the past 2 months

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

yes, yes, yes, to everything in your comment. My thoughts exactly. I loooooooooved that OST! And although those redundant face shots were very in-your-face, i loved the boldness of the eccentric directing.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hey carole, yeah the ost was probably my only favorite part of the show, I always rewatched the scenes when dear love is playing.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My thoughts exactly!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes I really hope they release the full OST! Love the instrumentals.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Best comment ever. Why do we need words when there's a .gif like this? Thanks Heads for staying to the very (bitter) end.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Agreed!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

What the...........?!?

If this drama's going to have sad ending, no drama can beat Ja Myung Go imo. That's the best Romeo Juliet Korean ver ever!!

But if it's going to have a good-but-not-so-sad-ending, the writer should have learnt from The Princess' Man or Huan Zhu Ge Ge!!!

Next time pls choose the right drama Uhm Force~!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

ok so the first scene of the entire series? That never actually happened in the context of the drama because moo young was already dead even before Goguryeo fell. That first scene was one of the reasons that I stuck with this because it made me curious as to what happened that led up to it, I don't know anything about the Goguryeo era so I don't know what was gonna happen if they followed history. I expected that they're meeting would be momentous somehow spark the fall of Goguryeo because she kept emphasizing it at the start maybe the writer meant to follow it through but they didn't have enough time, i was still expecting that it was gonna circle around but alas we just got title cards.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

oh wow, yes! Wonder if the writer forgot he did that first scene.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

I know! That's what I thought when I first watched the final ep.

(Ok, to explain, I don't understand Korean, so I watched it before the subs were up, and already wondered where that scene went. Not that a second watch with subs made the ep any less wtf, to be honest)

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

sadly, that first scene with the Princess saying maybe things would have been better if they never met behind the back drop of a burned out castle suckered me into watching this abomination too....i really got interested and wanted to see something about the fall of GoGureyo

unless that scene was supposed to be about with just the 1st act where just the king was killed...but i doubt it.

just awful.....which is sad because I found the actress playing the princess to be somewhat likable...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

most comprehensive comment ever!

thanks Heads!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

let´s have them reborn as beetles, cause there is a load of s*** here they need to deal with.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Accurate gif is accurate. Why...how...WHAT? Words cannot even form to explain the confusion and madness that was this finale. Where did the plot go and why did this...huh...what...

I would make more sense but I'm flabbergasted.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

My love for Uhm Force was not enough for me to continue with this drama. I stopped at episode 6 when I realize that I am dozing off in the middle, and its a bad sign. Though I am still downloading it.

I honestly love the visuals of this drama and I was hoping that this could be my first Goguryeo era drama but failed.

Thanks for the recaps and for enduring up to the end. Fighting!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Okay so that's your comment a GIF lol, this is definitely in the running for the year end award of most screwy drama endings scratch that most screwy drama ever.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

It literally hurts my soul how bad this was, I've defended this show through its many shortcomings, but this is too much for me to handle. It's a damn pity, too, because the actors (NMW not included) did a good job, and the directing continued slick and awesome till the last moment. I understood what they were going for, it's just that the writer wasn't up to the task.

I honestly have no problems with sad/tragic endings, it's mediocrity I despise. And this was such a case. I still believe the biggest problem was the pick for main villain that made the plot implode. I've put all the blame on No Min Woo before, and while I still believe his acting is simply ludicrous, the lazy build up for Nam Saeng as a character was what killed this show dead.

I'll take refuge in the glorious first 10 episodes and forget all this happened.

/rant

PS: thanks Heads for your hard work recapping this one. Let's hope next one is the charm ;)

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

This exactly. It stings because this could have been great -- the first ten episodes were great. And then the combination of the liveshoot and the sucky writing destroyed it.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

omg! tyra screams top it all. Since i am gonna watching this finale, borrowing dee's words, joke on you show, joke on you.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

*not gonna*

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

No.....after part of the credits were rolled, the scenes rewound to show the four Geumhwadan fellows and some of the loyal spies quickly picked up the bodies of Mu-young and Choong and sneaked them out of the palace. They were still alive! Remember earlier when Mo-seol was similarly stabbed by Nam-saeng and left to die in the woods but managed to make it back to the headquarters and had a long conversation with Choong before she died? Well, it seemed that Nam-saeng's swordsmanship was not so lethal after all.

With the immediate and tender care of the Geumhwadan fellows, Mu-young and Choong recovered. They decided to leave everything behind and live peacefully together forever. The end.

I hope the above scenario was not too far fetched. :-)

0
9
reply

Required fields are marked *

hee hee.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

So then, what is the moral?

For Yeon:
The one who seeks power in his workplace and attempts to aid his country loses his family?

The seeds of betrayal one sows in another person's house will bloom and blossom in one's own house.

For Princess:
Listen to daddy: choose the flower, not the sword: Hasn't Shark taught you that Revenge ends with folks dying? Good heavens, girl...you should've chosen daddy and gone off peacefully and leave the revenge and sword behind!

Hasn't heartless City taught you that the whole spy/counterspy undercover thing never works out? Did your minions accomplish anything really in the long run?

For Choong:
Wrong birth, wrong place, you were totally out of your element. Those abandoned by their high-born fathers should just move on and not get caught up in their father's world. Your mother was a slave. Live like a normal person because you will just be too conflicted and insecure to challenge your high-born woman or your high-born dad.

For Nam-Saeng:
If you have a needy dad, getting mean and spiteful just to get back at him isn't gonna work...and if everyone in your family and your circle are repressed and secretive..be secretive as well. I can understand how the family secrets and repression can get to a person but try to hold your emotions in. Truth isn't gonna work in such a setting. Learn to be sneakier, learn to plan.

0
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'm just so mad at the writer for ruining a fascinating piece of history with this drivel.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

He kind a did a good job with it in the beginning until Nam-saeng's character showed up then he didn't quite know what the heck to do with him.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Carol, we did suffer through a number of sucky dramas with great actors and some amazing music (Shark is one of them).

I don't believe this drama was about love. It was about the father and the son, mostly. The general was the one who held my interest.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

yes, the music was soo good. Maybe I should just sit back and be grateful for that. If not for Blade and Petal I wouldn't have gotten to know and love Dear Toxic Love

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeah, this was my feeling, too. The series seemed to be more about the tragedy that can ensue when people who think differently care about each other. This is why the ending made a lot of sense to me. Mu Young sensed she had not real future with Choong, because she only understood honor, duty and war, while he was loving, forgiving and warm-hearted. Honestly, does anybody see them as a happily married couple living a normal life together? I don't, lol. I'm not even sure how much love there was on her part - maybe just fascination, infatuation, admiration...? Choong, on the other hand, really loved her, not expecting her to love him, knowing she was incapable of that. This is why she felt she had to kill herself - as a last gesture to spare Choong the pain of living with a woman that could never have the same deep feelings for him that he had for her.

As for Yeon and Choong, it's almost the same thing. Yeon recognizes Choong's humanity, which is why he is relatively indulgent with him. I think he also recognizes his own inability to get over himself and his misguided pride - this is why he can't punish Namsaeng, who defends his killing Choong's mother as perfectly lawful.

Also, from a symbolic point of view, how could Mu Young and Choong live while Goguryeo was dying? It makes no sense for them to run away and live happily ever after. On the other hand, it makes perfect sense for the three "crooked" characters to be there for Goguryeo's funeral: Yeon, Namsaeng and Jang.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

For me, the show ended when Mu-young was standing in front of Yeon and Nam-saeng with her sword.

In my head, instead of giving up, she pretends to kill Yeon and kills Nam-saeng with one blow instead. Then Geumhwadan actually does something useful and help her and Choong escape, though to be honest Yeon and Jang don't try that hard to catch them. They live happily ever after somewhere far far away from Gorguyeo.

Yes, I know this means Nam-saeng dies when historically he lived a lot longer. But the writer killed off Yang Moon and couldn't even remember what he wrote for the very first scene of the series, so I'm sticking with my fantasy.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

When I adapt a story or revise it, I know I liked it. In this case, lots of folks will be revising because this was such a good possibility.

My adaptation would have Nam Saeng from the beginning. We would see his seething and we would hear him internalizing/soliloquizing about the conspiracies and secrets of the court. We sould see him as the unloved son of the real wife while he realizes that son of the concubine is the one his father truly loves. We might even have a scene where his father scolds him for not knowing how to keep his plans close to his vest. Maybe I'd show a scene where he asks his father to take him to the court and his father denies him and makes him ashamed. In that way we can see his need to please Daddy and we would see that he doesn't know the princess.

Then I'd place Mo-Seol in the beginning also. We would see her desire to please her father and maybe we could see her friendship with the Crown Prince because Lord knows Crown Prince didn't get a lotta airtime. And we'd see how she had to learn to follow Yeon Gasemon because of some weird stuff with the Tang. So we'd see her conflicted a bit. And she would be the foil for the Princess. I'd also show Mos-seol's friendship with Nam Saeng, since they're such good friends.

Then I'd show our hero and heroine as children.

Yep, I'd add a prologue. Maybe include some other issues so we see the wideness of the world. And of course Bear Teacher's nobility...and maybe even Bear Teacher is aware of hero's mom...since he's depicted as being so faithful to the family.

Then when Nam Saeng and Mo-Seol enter the drama later, we would have some foundation for why Nam-Saeng isn't going to play around with secrets and why Mo-Seol has turned to Yeon Gasemon's side.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I've been keeping up with this show through recaps...man that seems like an epic failure of an ending. That was it? Seriously? ? What are they smoking there? Lol

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

"Even if you banked on the idea that their faces are unknown, Leader So was imprisoned by the agency for three years and had a portrait of his face in circulation. I can’t."

Seriously, this annoyed the hell out of me. And, what was the point of them even being in the military parade when all they did was to sit there and look shocked.

Geumhwadan - the worst protection agency ever.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

This is the WORST ending ever after BIG. A big disappointment indeed.

0
7
reply

Required fields are marked *

BIG has a bad ending? Unhappy, illogical, inconsistent, all of the above? I was about to start watching, but if it's ending is poor, I won't bother

0
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

The BIG ending was so bad that a merciful fan edited a good version for it: The one everyone wanted to see.

0
5
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you - that's 16 hours of my life you've just saved me!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Where can such a glorious thing be found? Google searching only brings me complaints about the original ending.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't know if it still exists but it was a YT video, in a post at the koalas's playground site (recap for the last episode maybe?).

0

Hope this helps. Haven't watched it yet myself but I think this is the one you guys are talking about. http://koalasplayground.com/2012/07/26/fanmade-big-mv-shows-ending-with-original-kyung-joon-and-da-ran/

0

There was some kind of recap here on Big, it was hilarious to read. Total opposite of Koala's recap.

0

yay! now we can pair dr jin with sword and flower as best buds! -.- best gif to sum up everythingggggg.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Okay..from now on I WILL not trust anything k-drama fortunetellers say.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

From this writer, other sageuk writers at least remember what they wrote in the beginning.

They showed Mu-young in the beginning clearly alive after the fall of Goguryeo but in the end she dies before Gorguryeo fell. This was just a 20eps sageuk, how can he not put together a script that makes sense argggg.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yup. Even though i dropped this series halfway, i still remember that scene very vividly. Princess was still alive after the fall of gorguryeo.
What was that then, a dream? False hope? Lord..

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I wonder that too. I was expecting that to be the last scene of the drama.
I felt that at the end everyone gave up and no one even tried to do anything.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Wtf mannnnnnnnnn. What a waste of talented actors and beautiful directing

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

-Such a stupid ending. I was like "What the hell" the whole time. It was too rushed that I have the feeling that the writer couldn't think of anything else and just wrote whatever came to his mind.

-Nam Saeng, I'll never forgive you.

-Moo Young, why are you making this poor man cry all the time? http://i630.photobucket.com/albums/uu26/dramabeans/drama/2013/swordflower/swordflower20/swordflower20-00396.jpg

-I felt really bad for the general. His own son tried to kill him.

-Choong could've fought Nam Saeng, why didn't he do anything and just stood in front of the sword; I don't get it.

However, I love Uhm Tae Woong (who wouldn't love Uhm Force?), Choi Min Soo, Kim Ok Bin and Ohn Joo Wan. Great acting.

The last but not the least....;
MAY THE UHM FORCE BE WITH YOU!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Was seeing this week's episode of 1N2D that aired on KBSWorld and the guys really reeling in into UTW on how he's quite upset with the rating of this show. Sad to know that he is really feeling the low ratings. He was also saying to Tae Hyun after joining 1N2D how the scheduling is quite killer when he in a a project. That nice walking trail in KangNeung.CTH and UTW were really talking some honest stuff there.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

That gif in the "Comments" section is just as perfect a Javabeans saying "MORE HEIRS. THE END."

I was intrigued by this show but too lazy to watch it, becausenot a lover of sageuks or fusions for all that it matters. I stuck with the recaps before deciding if I was going to watch it after ot aired... I won't. What a waste of talented actors.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

As Javabeans*
I'm not a lover*
After it*

Stupid phone.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

your comment sums it all. Thumbs up for the expression of the gif.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Aww I feel so sad for UhmForce, he mentioned on 1N2D that he was upset about this drama's ratings. :(

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh wow.

Poor you. I did download the whole series intending to watch it. The whole premise sounded like a bittersweet romance.

I think I am now going to delete all 20 episodes off my HD.

But oh dear, poor you who had to actually watch and recap all 20 episodes.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well, the first half was legitimately pretty good. I'd just watch up to ep 11 and then make up your own ending.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yes, good advice. I wouldn't have made it to end if the first half of this show wasn't great.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Uh.

................................ Why.

I haven't even watched a minute of this drama but I read all the recaps, desperately hoping that any of it would be as good as Uhm Tae Woong's expressions but. Wow. :|

Thanks for the recaps, this was painfully glorious.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Okay, well Heads did a masterful job at the recapping and I am not going to touch the finale because well, Tyra says it all.

I will say this,, I had not seen Uhm Force previously and I think he does an amazing job along with some of the other actors. So, that, the music and the cinematography (except for that bizarrely edited between Mo-Seol and Nam-Saeng) are the positives that I will remember. The rest calls for a mind eraser.

Heads...my endless thanks for the recapping and perseverance!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you Heads for sticking with this show till the bitter end. /salute

I haven't even watch the last episode and I don't need to.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for staying with this, Heads.

Eps 17-18 got my hopes up - I thought the writer had finally, after 10 eps, recovered from what must have been brain damage / insanity / a coma, and that we could be having a good (even if tragic) ending after all. But noooo...

Seriously, Mu Young, so many chances to run off with Choong and each and every time, you almost do but decide to go with something dumber instead. You fought for 14 episodes to kill yourself in front of Yeon? Seriously? If you weren't gonna kill the guy, then I don't even know what killing yourself would accomplish. Yeon already gave you a Get Out of Jail Free card to run away with his son, and nope, you refused it out of god knows what.

I would have been somewhat placated with a happy ending, maybe if Choong DIDN'T LEAVE HER in the morning after she was broken out of jail. (What was that about anyway?) Yunno, if he'd stayed, and she decided to take up Choong's offer, they could run away, and just let Yeon/Jang deal with the Psycho. Cute and fat babies (or sons, if Fortuneteller-ssi was right) thereafter. If Geumhwadan hadn't managed to get themselves killed yet, I suppose they could play godparents/nanny.

Btw, I nearly died when I saw the shot for shot replica of the Yeon coup, only headed by Worst Villain Ever Yeon Nam Saeng. Seriously, in some shows or films I would give the writer/director credit for how smart/symbolic this was, but given how the show's been doing, not a chance.

Nam Saeng - over-the-top acting and psychotic behaviour aside, he does seem rather unlucky. Nothing ever works out according to his plan, and it's pretty funny, to be honest:

(1) Tried to arrest the traitorous Geumhwadan members: Fell epicly for Geumhwadan's trap, got tons of his men killed, and lost his Chief position to his lowly brother.

(2) Tried to angle for the Prime Minister position, but Yang Moon was chosen instead.

(3) Failed to get Mu Young to spy on Choong for him.

(4) Tried to frame Choong for Mu Young's escape, but Bear Teacher, with Yeon's support, took the rap.

(5) Tried to get Mu Young to kill his father for him, failed.

(6) Got backstabbed by Jang, who put Yeon's name in the appointment scroll (dude needs to remember to check, check and check again all documents meant to be read aloud in public.

Ah well. If anything, I love the theme (?) song by Wax, it's been playing on repeat mode. I am glad to have also discovered Kim Ok Bin, went back and watched some of her other work like Thirst, Over My Dead Body, and Front Line).

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well said, JT, well said. And thank you so much Heads for your endurance in recapping this drama. I admire you so much. If it were me, I'd given up. But thank you for putting in your own thoughts towards this disaster of a drama (the latter half anyway). Your comments were hilarious. Loved it!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recaps, Heads!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I was waiting for this recap because I want to know your thoughts about the finale and the show but that gif says it all, thanks heads, awesome recap. Good job!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Dear Heads. Thank you for being a recapping trooper. This show. Ugh I wouldn't have blamed you if you'd given up halfway through. This was my first live watch and your recaps added lots to the experience. For the last seven episodes or so I looked forward to reading your recaps more than watching the episodes. Hopefully you get a better show next time. Thanks heaps!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I love your final comments.

I am glad I decided not to watch this through, and at the same time I'm very grateful for your patience to filter the experience for us!

Next drama please!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

But what happend with the umbrella maker daughter ? And also tae do the man who killed her brother

and i hate that fortune teller misleading us like that.

Does anyone know the ost with that rock sound i love it but cant find it a ywhere

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeah the rock sound ost that always plays in action scenes?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recaps...
I still can't watch full episode ,that's way i check your blog every day..
I saw 1N2D when UTW rant to our good doctor who have to hurry for work..LoL
I think the writer have aim that ending must like Romeo and Juliet story.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

And why didnt anyone from geuhwadan mourned the death of boo chi

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ha...Seriously?? After wasting my time watching Shark, I am soooo glad dropping this now after ep 6@7 maybe..

Well, that gif! Enough saying huh!
But as for me I just can't stand how slow is this drama to watch..makes me yawnnnn like garfield~~~

So which one has worst ending? Shark or this?

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Fashion King :-)

If I have to choose between Shark and Sword&Flower, then Sword&Flower has a lousier ending because it was just plain lazy writing by the scriptwriter. Or the whole cast and crew just gave up and found it easier to just kill them off...might as well just fade to black.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Wiping tears of laughter from my eyes.

Thanks, Heads! Muahz!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Hey everyone, does anyone know the ost that is used for the action scenes, been trying to find it and still no luck.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Uhm Force...ask for the finale information in the future

I just...I worry for the other shows I'm watching and starting

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

"Uhm Force…ask for the finale information in the future"

Worth repeating...

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you for recapping it so that we, the readers, did not have to watch the drama.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

That was my feeling.

Endings make dramas hot or not.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

One of the worst dramas of my entire life. This writer was crazy if he really thought he could write a drama :(
I have no problems with sad ending but this ending was like wtf, seriously her death was so pathetic. I didn't like the editing in the end either. I literally wasted one hour of my life, I should have just waited for the recaps hahahah

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

That's the best reaction gif if I ever saw one. Let's hope you get a better show with a better finale! I really felt for you when "Shark" ended and now I'm REALLY feeling for you with this one.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

OMG heads that gif of Tyra banks is the reason I love you so much hahhahhaha

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ugh! So much wrong with this ending I don't even know where to start. Heads pretty much covered it all so I'm not going to repeat it except for a couple of things.

The Geumhwadan. I mean, why were they even at the military parade? Just to show off their amazing incompetence? I ended up getting kinda angry every time we'd cut to a scene of them "planning". Ugh, enough already.

Also, I just could not understand Mu-young's motivations at the end. I get that she had given up her revenge and didn't want any more bloodshed. That's believable. What I don't get is why she needed to kill herself to accomplish this. Running away would have served the same purpose. She didn't even have to run away with Choong and it still would have made more sense than the actual ending.

My heart was breaking for Choong as he begged her to run away with him and asked her why she never thought of him, and at the same time I was totally agreeing with him. I just could not understand her character at the end. If anyone can give any insight into her motivations I would love to hear what you think. Unless it's just the sad fact that the writer just forgot everything that Mu-young was and just destroyed a good character. Sigh.

But on to the good stuff. Choi Min-soo! Uhmforce! I am grateful to this drama for allowing me to discover them. Yeon was a great character and apart from his slight characterisation glitch at the end I loved every second of his screen time. I especially enjoyed how he came to love and accept Choong despite his better judgement and was willing to let Mu-young go to make his son happy.

Choong was also a great character, I thought. He experienced realistic character development and even though he may have made mistakes he was still a consistent character who really deserved to be happy. Sigh. How could she say no to him!

All in all, this drama had such potential and great cast members. The first half was great, and then it just became stupid. I could have accepted the stupid if we'd gotten a happy ending out of it. I really wanted a happy ending for Choong and Mu-young. I would also have loved the tragic ending if it had just made sense. But no. It makes me sad. What a waste.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

You just cant go wrong with Choi Min Soo. Love the guy in anything , good or bad.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *