Dramabeans the (e)Book: Why Do Dramas Do That?
by javabeans
Why do dramas do that?
If ever there were a question that characterized the seven years we’ve been running this site, that would be the one. What’s with the back hugging? Do Koreans really drink so much soju? Wrist grabs: EXPLAIN!
We attempted to tackle the question with our Pop Culture and Glossary series of posts (examples: What’s an oppa? and an explanation of the folk-tale Gumiho), but quickly realized that there was so much material we wanted to cover that we joked we could easily fill a tome with it. So why don’t we? was the obvious response.
And thus Dramabeans: The Book was born, which we decided to call, aptly, Why Do Dramas Do That?
We’ll be publishing the project as a three-part ebook series, which we’ll make available on Amazon (to be read on a Kindle device or free Kindle apps) and Smashwords (which publishes formats readable on Sony Reader, Kobo, Nook, Kindle, and your iThing of choice).
We’ll be releasing Part 1 soon, so stay tuned for updates. For now, here’s a taste of what’s in store:
Why is everyone in a K-drama obsessed with a first love?
First loves have their own mythic place in K-dramaland (or perhaps because of dramaland), holding power over characters that traverse the unlikeliest of divides: time, memory, generations, even between the living and the dead. Countless dramas base entire romantic plots on the love of a little boy for the first girl who was ever nice to him. Often we can sum up an entire drama this way: boy meets girl in youth, falls in love, gets torn apart by tragedy, spends life fighting all odds to get back to her. The End. Is it realistic? No. Then why do dramas refuse to leave that mythic land, FirstLoveonia?
Why do diametric opposites attract?
He’s deaf but pretends to hear; she pretends to be deaf although she can hear. He can’t feel any pain, while she has acute sensitivity to pain. She’s poor and overflows with warmth; he’s filthy rich and frozen so rock-solid that a lump of ice resides in his chest cavity. How is it that these characters always manage to find the person who represents the exact antithesis of themselves? Is there a special pheromone that only drama stars are keen enough to detect as they hunt for a romantic match? What gets accomplished through this K-drama Law of Diametric Opposites?
The Prince and the Pauper: Wither the Middle Class?
K-dramas might give you the impression that Korea is divided into two economic classes: chaebols (insanely rich, and all handsome, young, and brilliant to boot) and dirt-poor commoners with strong work ethics (all beautiful and sweet, naturally). And while the income gap is a very real thing, these dramas tend to ignore a notable majority of the population, leading us to wonder: What happened to all the normal people? Where’s the middle class?
Why are loan sharks such a threat to the innocent heroes and heroines of dramaland?
Why is dramaland so littered with loan sharks, and why are they always black-suited brutes with fashions from the ’70s and brains from the Cro-Magnon era? And what do they possibly get out of harassing a dirt-poor hero or heroine who clearly can’t pay up anyway?
They’ll harass, stalk, threaten, and then do the same to every relative they can track down. It doesn’t matter if the heroine has not a cent to her name, or if the hero isn’t technically the name on the contract; if the thugs terrorize the debtor’s child, the theory goes that the debtor will be nearby. It’s not fair, but who said fair had any place in a predatory loan in the first place?
RELATED POSTS
Required fields are marked *
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
101 Ladymoonstone143
August 19, 2013 at 9:27 PM
Looking forward to buying and reading this one. Congratulations..:))
Required fields are marked *
102 Gabrielle O
August 19, 2013 at 9:57 PM
Why aren't you going to make it accessible on nook? :/
Required fields are marked *
WickedBiccie
August 20, 2013 at 8:52 AM
Gabrielle, it will be available on Nook through Smashwords.
Happy reading!
Required fields are marked *
103 Classy
August 19, 2013 at 10:28 PM
WOW.. the anything and everything about k dramas... Finally. Maybe now I might understand the certain hipocracy they spout.
Required fields are marked *
104 Julia the Berkshire Beanie
August 19, 2013 at 11:01 PM
javabeans/girlfriday: maybe you could include a sidebar with some of those adorable Korean phrases (idioms?) like blowing the top off your ramen pot and drawing lines on watermelons. Some times the subbers replace these with English equivalents, but I actually adore the flavor of another society's common sayings.
Required fields are marked *
Elina
August 20, 2013 at 10:51 AM
+1
I love this idea.
Common Korean phrases.
Koreans are truly amazed when we (as in "we-foreigners") use them :D
Required fields are marked *
105 John Smith
August 20, 2013 at 12:48 AM
Well good news and bad news.
Good news is that we will be having something interesting in the market. Something that will be fun to read and pass your time.
Bad news is that I can't buy it no cash :( Ofcourse if it was free I would get it but then who isn't like me. :)
Who can avoid free stuff.
In regards if they are qualified to do so or not. I say who cares this is something for fun so if you enjoy stuff like that then do so and if not leave it.
There are many books in the market place that have similar things though they are considered unofficial ie there was one that I saw for Buffy some season, another one that I saw was called all things STAR TREK or something like that. It consisted of info of STAR TREK at that time.
Fans that were into it bought the books. They were well aware that it had nothing to do with the community it nothing offical but they had something to do and enjoy. Yes most probably it was written by fans who put in time and research into the stuff but it was the thought that truly matters and counts.
The writers are going to be spending their precious time and effort for this book so we should be thankful to them for that.
If you don't want to read the book that is entirely upto you. No one is forcing anyone to do so. Plus if you do read it and don't like it then you can always tell them what went wrong so that they can improve the next time. Thus a Win Win situation for all.
Never knew that the writers of this blog were Korean. Never could tell. How does anyone even know that in this day and age. Have you met them or seen pictures of them. I am someone who doesn't believe stuff unless I have proof. (Though Aliens are another matter totally still there is some proof though people don't call it that :) )
I like some of the points that were brought up and would love to see how they turn out in the end.
Though I want to contribute something as well....
Why are loan sharks such a threat to the innocent heroes and heroines of dramaland?
In Romance Town there was a loan shark living next to the Heroines workplace. He was no threat to her infact he was even very helpful towards her. Cashes out her lottery ticket and even lends out an occasional ear etc...
Plus sometimes they seem all though and bad A-- but are there only for comedic relief. ie Smile You, Dating Agency Cryano and one more I can't remember the name. It had the actress who was in the group called VOX or something.
Why is everyone in a K-drama obsessed with a first love?
Another good point though they don't always end up with them.
Smile Again was a perfect example.
The main couple thankfully wasn't like that. Infact the Carl Laker got over his 1st love as soon as she dumped him for his little brother and she tried her best to get rid of him.
Anna Laker was another matter though considering her mental state it could be understood and when she found out that her first love already had a family she tried to even get over him.
James I suspect only liked her later on for the guilt that he felt towards her. though by the end he stuck by his wife. :)
So while these points are common in a lot of dramas they are not true for all of them. Infact I would love to find cases to support where such things don't happen :) .
Sry it must be the case where I took up law at one point and it was our job to bring up such stuff and argue our point.
It is nothing personal towards anyone over here or there.
Still looking forward to this work. Perhaps I will hire out some criminals that I know of to get me a pirated copy of this work so that I can fully enjoy it. LOL :)
Hope read all the other comments sooooooonn !!!!!! :)
Required fields are marked *
106 vlackerine
August 20, 2013 at 12:51 AM
this is going to be awesome! :D
Required fields are marked *
107 caprica
August 20, 2013 at 1:52 AM
THANK YOU..cannot wait for the ebook..
Required fields are marked *
108 k-soup
August 20, 2013 at 3:37 AM
I've been very interested with the structure of Korean Dramas. Despite the repetitive concept of what we call in science "Opposite attracts", I am always magnetize with whatever witchcraft it has.
Maybe because: Male protagonist is hot, Female Protagonist is anime cute and there is this cool third character (guy) in the story. Well, that is also something that is repeated or common in drama..we (the audience, kept on falling for the second guy).
Required fields are marked *
109 KK123
August 20, 2013 at 4:24 AM
yay!!!! Will read definitely, the excerpt made me laugh already.
Required fields are marked *
110 namedx
August 20, 2013 at 4:33 AM
What an exciting project! Looking forward to the finished product. Kudos x
Required fields are marked *
111 malta
August 20, 2013 at 4:35 AM
Wow! I am so excited. Thank you so much. You guys are great!
Required fields are marked *
112 coby
August 20, 2013 at 5:09 AM
I am looking forward for this book. yay!
Its sad to see trolls in our midst. Don't dramas sometimes teach us to be kind?
Now there will be another item on the checklist "You are are a Kdrama addict if you".. have an ebook "Why Do Dramas Do That?" by dramabeans.
Required fields are marked *
113 merry
August 20, 2013 at 5:36 AM
A toast to JB and GF on this wonderful milestone! In my book, you're tops! I can imagine a shelf of books on kpop in English with this occupying seminal place. Being part of this community, i feel the triumph too. squeee time!
Required fields are marked *
114 kiongna
August 20, 2013 at 6:05 AM
Dun forget them turns that pans 360 deg LOL come with hugs/kiss, classic amnesia (was telling my pals, i've not met anyone with amnesia of known anyone that got amnesia in my 4 decades in this world ! How the heck this amnesia come to play so often in Korean Dramas lol, whenever this comes up I want to scream aiyooo dun do that dun do that!), piggy back rides, cancer, tumour in brain, when they wave for a taxi, the taxi is always there on the spot lol, when they drive real fast they can make a U turn anywhere at high speed lol, there's a fried chicken shop everywhere, or they have a fried chicken shop lol (when I was in seoul i hardly could see them fried chicken shops!) ... the list goes on... !
Maybe Javabeans & GF, you should ask us beanies what are the classic K-drama plots/events/scene that we have seen all them years being k-addicts - and we would surely have a good laugh while reading and exclaiming o "OH yessss! hahahah that one"... LOL
Can't wait to ready your books!
Required fields are marked *
Celery
August 20, 2013 at 6:38 AM
God, hate the 360 degrees pan + overuse of lingering shots, arghhhhh
And most of the time, they aren't even making out or kissing properly. Which makes it even more awkward to watch esp when the director insists on lingering on the shot with unnecessary pan-s and closeups.
Required fields are marked *
poulpion
August 21, 2013 at 5:17 AM
And don't forget the wide open eyes!!
so the ultimate combo: 360° pan + stiff closed-lip kiss + eyes wide open + loud ballad with ultra-cheesy lyrics
I think I remember one of these from City Hunter
And yeah, the reaction shots, definitely a Kdrama specialty
Required fields are marked *
WickedBiccie
August 20, 2013 at 8:58 AM
The cancer and high speed U-turns, I'll chalk down to dramatic effect, but the fried chicken shops?
There really ARE everywhere!
I live in a medium sized city outside Seoul and we have one almost on every block!
Required fields are marked *
115 MNS
August 20, 2013 at 7:36 AM
Congratulations! I'll pray for your books success.
Required fields are marked *
116 S2K
August 20, 2013 at 7:58 AM
I can't wait! I think this will be a fun and delightful read. Don't worry about the haters. Its not like anyone is forcing them to buy it. My iPad awaits with baited breath.
Required fields are marked *
117 mlou
August 20, 2013 at 8:03 AM
I like your point about the lack of dramas about the middle class. But what drama recently was such a big hit about the middle class... "Childless Comfort"! It was so well written, something truly missing in almost all dramas. I'm glad that writer is beginning another one.
Required fields are marked *
118 Waca
August 20, 2013 at 8:05 AM
That is going to be awesome! Thanks to the two of you, it's a great idea!
As for me, one of my main questions would be: why do the female protagonists always trip over nothing and fall down, even when they are not supposed to be clumsy? I guess it is kind of the same as the pulling by the wrist thing, that's to say something that looks like a tendancy to infantilize the women. I've seen that a lot in Asian dramas.
Required fields are marked *
windsun33
August 20, 2013 at 12:41 PM
I think one of my big annoyances with many k and Asian dramas in general is all the blatant stereotypes of genders. We have all seen dozens of examples of Candy Girl, but I don't recall ever seeing a similar male trope, and there are many similar examples.
Required fields are marked *
Waca
August 21, 2013 at 8:17 AM
Haha, that's so true! I guess sexism, even if unaware, still impacts the drama writers. Or is it just stereotypes in general? Like JB said, the rich cool guy and the poor hard-working, sweet girl...so many stereotypes!
Required fields are marked *
119 t.j
August 20, 2013 at 8:49 AM
I'm obviously going to buy it!!! release seasame!
Required fields are marked *
120 Quiet Thought
August 20, 2013 at 8:55 AM
Possible cross-cultural hilarity in a movie: American woman visits Korea, gets in trouble, various good-looking, macho Korean men try to help her, but every time they grab her wrist, she tasers them!
I see Sandra Bullock as the female lead.
Required fields are marked *
121 WickedBiccie
August 20, 2013 at 9:03 AM
Asah!!! This is such fantastic news!!
Only an hour ago I was visiting a friend and she wanted to know what was the deal with First Loves in K-Dramas, and then I get home and find this splendiferous announcement!
Let joy be unconfined!
Required fields are marked *
122 cinthy
August 20, 2013 at 10:53 AM
Loved it!!!!!!!! can't wait, and yes what happened to all the normal people?? lol
Required fields are marked *
123 velvet350
August 20, 2013 at 12:25 PM
I hope you explain the bill collectors aka loan sharks busting into peoples homes, tearing the place up, even taking off with their kids etc.. Also what's with all the shoving, pushing, throwing down of people and can happen between complete strangers? I was quite surprised in Good Doctor the other Drs/Interns grabbing, shoving and throwing Park Shi-On down but that's another thread.lol I have more but I'll leave it at that. Just know I'm looking forward to your book and seeing what your thoughts are. I wish you much success. :)
Required fields are marked *
124 dora
August 20, 2013 at 2:43 PM
Yes, yes-well, yes to all of those. Wrist grabs! What the hell is up with that?
Required fields are marked *
125 1worlddreamer
August 20, 2013 at 8:41 PM
Wheeeee! Just got home from a very long day at work and read this! Cannot wait, will definitely buy this. Have been watching for quite a few years and found this site not long after I started watching. Have never laughed so hard...or thought dang I thought the same thing when I was watching
May not always agree with everything written, but have laughed and learned a lot from both of you. As someone said above, no idea where you guys find the time! Writing takes time and sometimes I am so blown away by the volume on this blog!
Way to go...so wonderful...Imagine you have gotten so big you even have anti-fans! How weird is that...but should just be ignored, because it is no reflection on you or who you truly are. Just grateful that both of you share your knowledge and give us such wonderful writing with so much hilarity. Really sometimes it is hard not to get snarky with some of the plots, writing or black holes of logic.
Can't wait...FIGHTING!
Required fields are marked *
126 valleydale
August 21, 2013 at 1:26 AM
I've long been a perplexed observer of the sheer "physicality" seemingly common in Korean culture, in that there appears to be a lot of forehead-flicking, back-of-the-head-slapping, colliding on crowded streets (with nary an apology), and shin-kicking going on in Korea, if K-dramas are any reliable indication. How closely does this reflect reality? Of course here in North America, we often prefer to express our violence by more remote means, and with far more deadly consequences (ie., guns), so it's got me wondering....
I've also been fascinated by the way K-dramas often depict a seeming contradiction between the way women in Korean society commonly occupy high profile/high powered professional roles/occupations, but are just as often constrained by stiflingly narrow roles within the family. Where lies the truth?
Do Koreans really drink as heavily as K-dramas depict, with tent bars on every corner, and people passed out on the backs of their acquaintances?
Why do Female characters fail to notice that the skin below their jaw line is jarringly less white than that of their face?
Oh, so many questions! Thank goodness JB and GF are here to answer them. This is the book I never knew I needed until just now. Count me among the legion of DB denizens who can't wait to read the hopefully side-splittingly fun answers to such questions. I'll even pay money for it. The Kindle app on my IPad is cocked and primed for this download.
Required fields are marked *
127 velvet350
August 21, 2013 at 2:27 AM
Sorry I forgot a major one I think you'll cover it in your book. I sure hope so.
Hospitals ....stub toe, go to hospital...scratch on arm, hospital. Faint, piggyback ride to hospital. Aren't there any clinics or Drs. offices? Curious minds want to know. :)
Required fields are marked *
poulpion
August 21, 2013 at 5:20 AM
stayed in the rain more than 3 minutes -> faint -> hospital ^^
Required fields are marked *
WickedBiccie
August 22, 2013 at 8:35 AM
There are clinics and Doctor's offices here, yes, but the majority of people just head straight to the hospitals.
Partly because the hospitals are everywhere and relatively inexpensive and partly because in Korea, everything needs to be done, "Bali, bali!" (Quickly, quickly)
And that includes healing.
Why go to a Doctor's office or small clinic and get three days worth of medication, when you can go down the street two blocks to a small hospital and get an injection, an IV and be back at work in 4 hours!
Required fields are marked *
128 TS
August 21, 2013 at 5:38 PM
I hope this book answers why characters die by Truck.
Required fields are marked *
129 Estefania Garcia
August 21, 2013 at 10:11 PM
Yay!
Required fields are marked *
130 Noonapau
August 22, 2013 at 7:32 AM
Will eagerly anticipate the ebook. Hope all my questions about K-dramaland will be answered ^^
Required fields are marked *
131 Demi
December 29, 2013 at 10:58 PM
This is why I think this site is such a waste of time. If you don't like kdrama tropes don't watch them. Simple. You're always talking about realism and how some things just look like jokes to you and whatever...well I'm sorry if your life doesn't allow you to see certain things as realistic but in other people's life many things happen the way they do in kdramas (mine included) and that's exactly why some people watch them. Saying something is unrealistic just because it doesn't happen to you doesn't make it unrealistic, so asking for dramas to stop using the common tropes that attracted such a huge audience is just ridiculous and selfish. Many people love dramas the way they are, many people resemble those characters whether you believe or not, so please for god's sake stop "Americanizing" it. It's your own problem if you grow tired of the common tropes used in Asian shows, besides when you do, you still have plenty of "interesting", "refreshing", "modernized" American shows to watch.
Required fields are marked *