296

Dr. Jin: Episode 1

Another time-traveling drama! And wouldn’t you know, Dr. Jin isn’t even the last one, since we’ve still got Faith slated for later this summer. At this point I wonder if I’m just gonna have to watch ’em all, for comparison purposes. They all have certain elements in common, but so far each drama has its own quirks and rules for handling the time-skips, which keep things interesting. At least we hope they will.

(Note: At some point in recent weeks, the drama dropped the “Time Slip” from its title, so now it’s just plain ole Dr. Jin.)

Ratings were fairly equal for the two new weekend shows, with the premiere of A Gentleman’s Dignity edging out Dr. Jin, 14.1% to 12.2%.

SONG OF THE DAY

Dr. Jin OST – “살아도 꿈인 것처럼” (Like a dream) by Jaejoong. [ Download ]

Audio clip: Adobe Flash Player (version 9 or above) is required to play this audio clip. Download the latest version here. You also need to have JavaScript enabled in your browser.

 
EPISODE 1 RECAP

A voice narrates, “From darkness, the light called to me.”

Fade in on a forest at night, moonlight filtering through the trees. A body lies prone on the ground: our hero.

He stirs awake, looking around to get his bearings. This is our titular Dr. Jin—full name JIN HYUK (Song Seung-heon)—and he’s wearing scrubs and a doctor’s coat. He checks his cell phone, its faceplate shattered. Lying next to Hyuk is his bag, and a curious-looking glass jar.

“What’s going on?” he thinks. “Where the hell am I?” Hyuk cautiously makes his way through the forest, thinking this out logically: “I was definitely on the hospital roof…”

He spots torchlight in the distance and is encouraged at the sign of life. But it’s a strange scene he stumbles across, because a bloody swordfight is under way. Hyuk wonders if this is a movie set and walks closer, curious but unafraid. Not until a rider on horseback charges at him, just barely missing him.

The veiled attackers are stopped by the arrival of authorities. The policemen on horseback—led by KIM KYUNG-TAK (Kim Jaejoong)—circle around, trapping the bad guys.

Fighting resumes, and one bandit breaks free and heads straight for Hyuk. Cool-headed officer Kyung-tak just raises a pistol and fires, dropping the assassin just before he reaches Hyuk.

Hyuk shakes the dead guy and sees blood, and it starts to register on him that this is no movie set. Worse yet, he finds himself facing the pointy end of a dozen swords; the officers assume he’s in league with the criminals.

Kyung-tak levels his gun at Hyuk and demands to know who he is. Hyuk is too stunned to answer satisfactorily, so Kyung-tak orders him tied up. Panicking, Hyuk backs away nervously while holding up his flashlight, which scares a horse and throws Kyung-tak to the ground.

Hyuk seizes the moment and runs into the forest. The officers chase. It’s his primitive fight-or-flight response kicking in, because even as he flees, he wonders, “Why am I running away?” He makes his way up a rocky ledge but loses his footing, tumbling over the edge of the cliff.

Thankfully his doctor’s bag saves him, because the strap catches on the rock and Hyuk dangles there on the side of the mountain. He’s quickly losing his hold, though, and things don’t look good. Just as his hand slips, another hand swoops in from above to grab him, pulling him to safety.

His savior (Lee Beom-soo) wears a topknot and a hanbok, and both men collapse in an exhausted heap. As Hyuk fades into unconsciousness, he thinks, “I must go back. Everything started that night, with that voice.”

The scene transitions to modern-day Seoul, as an ambulance carries an injured man to an emergency room. Hyuk is the surgeon who operates on the patient’s brain to remove a tumor; the shocked reactions of all the doctors tells us something is seriously abnormal.

Hyuk goes in to begin the removal, but suddenly a flash of light bursts through his brain, with a disembodied voice saying, “I must go back.” He clutches his head in a hilariously exaggerated gesture like something out of a Frankenstein movie.

Then the headache passes, and he continues working to excise a growth that… looks like a fetus? Creepy. It looks sort of like a gummi bear, sort of like a plastic child’s doll. The fetus is preserved in liquid and put into a glass jar—the same type of jar Hyuk had with him during his time-warp.

After the surgery ends, a call comes in from “Temper Mina”—or YOO MINA (Park Min-young), who must be his girlfriend judging from their photo together. Hyuk has completely forgotten their date, and apologizes for making her wait.

He heads out immediately to meet her, saying he has something important to tell her. He eyes the ring box he has prepared with a smile of anticipation.

He hurries to her place, where she surprises him with a birthday cake. She sings it to “beloved Jin Hyuk oppa,” but he’s slightly exasperated, asking, “It’s been twenty years since you moved in with the family and you still don’t know my birthday?” Wait—is she not your girlfriend then? Is she actually your sister-figure? Please don’t tell me she’s both. You’ve already done that drama!

Mina says it’s because she’s going away next week, so they can celebrate early. Hyuk hides the ring box (let’s just go with girlfriend) on her shelf, just as he catches sight of Mina approaching with the cake and a devilish grin. She charges, and he runs away, not wanting cake-face. Not on the moneymaker!

Instead of the cake, she lands on top of him, and the mood turns romantic. They lean toward each other, and he whispers, “Mina… you’re heavy.” Ha.

She gives him a kiss on his forehead and says, “I don’t love you one bit.” He replies in kind: “I’m sick and tired of you too.” Mina asks outright why he doesn’t propose, and warns that she might run away. He keeps the teasing tone, saying he’d be grateful for that, then kisses her forehead back.

In an odd non sequitur moment, the scene cuts to Hyuk’s empty office, lingering for a long moment on the creepy jar-fetus. It doesn’t move or otherwise indicate evil powers, but clearly some greater force is at work here.

Later that evening, Hyuk starts to mention the strange growth he removed from the patient today, which reminds Mina of her strange dream. She was in an unfamiliar neighborhood when she saw Hyuk there, but he didn’t recognize her and just left, which made her sad and afraid.

The next day, Hyuk calls Mina, who’s also a doctor at the hospital. She’s busy with volunteer work, which he tells her she can quit now since she’s surely logged a lifetime’s worth of helping the needy. Not a big conflict between them, but an example of their clash in values.

While tending to her underprivileged patients, an unconscious man is brought to Mina, and she rushes him to the hospital. She calls Hyuk in because it’s a head trauma injury; the man hit his head, went home, and collapsed later. She urges him to operate immediately, but Hyuk takes one look at the man’s eyes and says, “It’s too late.” I know you’re supposed to be some sort of genius, but really? No MRI, CT scan, bloodwork of any kind?

She pleads anyway, asking him to at least do the operation, even though he says there’s less than 1% chance of survival. She argues that no matter how small the chance, they should take it to save a life: “If I were that patient, would you do the same?”

He sticks to his refusal, saying it’s better for all to just give up. When you know from the outset that it’s impossible, it’s a waste of time and money to operate—use those resources to save someone with a chance.

Mina can’t believe how coldly calculating he is, but Hyuk counters that doctors save lives that can be saved—saving doomed lives is up to God. He argues that it’s worse to give people hope knowing there is none, and while they’re still mid-argument they receive word that the man has died.

Mina is badly shaken and stalks out. She can’t face the man’s now-orphaned boy and shakes off his hand, saying her dream must have been right: “You seem like someone I don’t know.”

She drives off crying, and in her distraction she sees a motorcyclist at the last minute, swerving in time to avoid collision. And then gets slammed by an oncoming truck. Oh, Truck of Doom. What would dramaland be without you?

Hyuk looks at the accident in horror, just as we get an ominous close-up of the tumor-fetus. Okay, we get it. You’re creepy.

Mina’s battered body is rushed inside the hospital, with Hyuk issuing instructions to the staff. Just before she’s wheeled in for surgery, she holds out her hand and tries to whisper something. He assures her everything will be okay, and she says, “We’ll…. be able to meet…. again…”

Then her body goes limp. Hyuk madly scrubs in for surgery, which seems like a terrible idea (aren’t there rules of ethics about operating on people you know?).

Hyuk is mid-surgery when again he’s hit by a burst of light, accompanied by that tumor-fetus image and the same refrain, “I must go back.” This time he can’t hide his reaction and he clutches his head dramatically, blinking and breathing hard.

He says he can continue the surgery, though, which seems like another breach of medical ethics. But when he tries to resume, another flash hits him… and in the moment that he loses focus, something goes wrong and Mina’s brain starts bleeding.

Hyuk scrambles to save her and pleads with her to hang in there, but her blood pressure drops quickly, approaching flatline…

Elsewhere in the hospital, the patient from the first surgery—former host of the fetus-tumor—sneaks into a medical supply room and starts grabbing materials. He appears to know what he’s stealing, and stuffs a bag full before then wandering into Hyuk’s office, where he takes jar-fetus, which I may just have to call Cabbage Patch Kid.

Mina is wheeled out of surgery and Hyuk watches her with devastation; she’s stabilized, but it’s not clear whether she’ll wake up. Another doctor assures Hyuk that it wasn’t his fault.

Hyuk broods on the hospital roof, where he’s joined by a patient—the bandaged baby-stealer. Hyuk sees what he’s carrying and grows suspicious, while the man inches closer to the ledge and says, “I must go back.”

Familiar words. Hyuk gapes: “It was you? What have you done to me?” The man tries to jump off the roof, but Hyuk pulls him back and wrests the bag from his hand. The jar goes flying off the ledge, and Hyuk actually jumps off the roof after it. I don’t know why, but let’s just go with mysterious evil baby. Makes more sense than a genius neurosurgeon jumping off a rooftop to save a thing he doesn’t care about.

Some terrible CGI depicts his long descent from the roof, as he thinks, “This is a dream.” And then, instead of hitting the ground, a portal opens up and Cabbage Patch Baby falls into it, with Hyuk following.

Joseon-era scenes flash onscreen, landing us back with Dr. Jin on the rocky mountainside. It’s the morning after his almost-fall, and snoring next to him is his rescuer, who awakens with a snort. His words likely echo Hyuk’s thoughts: “So it wasn’t a dream after all.”

His savior is LEE HA-EUNG, an odd and disheveled man who wears a flask around his neck. Ha-eung demands payment for saving Hyuk’s life, wanting to spend it on more liquor. But Hyuk is flat broke, sending Ha-eung into a litany of swears.

Hyuk follows Ha-eung down the road, asking for today’s date. Ha-eung’s all, Well, that’s a crazy question. Naturally it’s 1860!

Hyuk can’t believe he’s landed in the Joseon era, in King Chuljong’s reign. Ha-eung takes offense at his use of the king’s name, which Hyuk points out the other man just used. Ha-eung: “That’s because I’m part of the royal family! Royal!

Hyuk looks around in confusion at the evidence of this Joseon world, and if there’s one thing that can get the message across, it’s the view of Seoul, then Hanyang, void of all its modern developments.

Police chief Kyung-tak may have lost track of that strange villain in the woods, but he remembers his face clearly and orders his officers to post “Wanted” drawings of him. And it’s not difficult for Hyuk to attract stares, given his strange dress and lack of a topknot.

Ha-eung sees the posted sign and recognizes the man he saved, then hurries back to take Hyuk aside. But rather than warn him of the wanted sign, he suggests they head to the police station—er, a tavern by the police station, for a bite to eat.

Disguising him is paramount, so Ha-eung swipes peasant’s clothing from a nearby clothesline to dress him in. Hyuk is fixated on somehow returning home, but Ha-eung overrides his protests, saying that he’ll solve that problem for him.

Before they get very far, their paths are blocked by a group of thug types, who tell Ha-eung that he’s wanted by their hyungnim. He owes money, and must repay. The leader warns Ha-eung with bodily harm, but Ha-eung leans in and tells him that the guy standing behind them is his meal ticket. He’s worth a big reward from the police, so Ha-eung will be able to repay his debt soon enough.

Loan Shark Boss decides to cut out the middleman and forgives the debt on the spot, since he can just claim the reward himself. Well, it was Ha-eung’s own fault for telling him of the 100 nyang reward when he only owed 30.

Boss orders his men to call an officer here, while Ha-eung protests this unfair debt repayment plan. By now, Hyuk has figured out his role in this exchange and tries to escape, but the gangsters grab him before he can flee.

While they wait for the police, Hyuk glares at Ha-eung reproachfully, accusing him of selling out an innocent person. Ha-eung retorts that if he was innocent, what was he doing in the forest in the middle of the night? Since he has no explanation, clearly he must be in league with those villains.

Hyuk explains his profession, and coincidentally Ha-eung asks “You’re a doctor?” just as Loan Shark starts choking on his food. Oh, you’ve got to be kidding me. The editing on this show is like something out of SNL—it’s timed like slapstick comedy, only it’s not supposed to be.

While the hooligans are distracted by their choking boss, Ha-eung signals that they should take this opportunity to slip away. But no! Hyuk is A Doctor! With doctorly principles!

The men yell, “Call for a doctor!” and Hyuk steps in, declaring, “I’m a doctor!” He performs the Heimlich maneuver first, but when it fails, he gives us a flashback-narration-tutorial of Plan B, a tracheotomoy. Anybody got a pen?

They’ve got about three minutes to save his life, so Hyuk calls for hot water and opens up his bag. How convenient that he still has his bag with him, which was packed full of random medical supplies by Cabbage Patch Thief. Oh, HA, he pulls out a ballpoint pen and drops it into the bowl of hot water along with a scalpel. And here I was, just makin’ a joke.

The minions naturally balk when he wields scalpel to throat, but Hyuk turns the blade on them and growls intensely, “If you want him to live, stand back.” Stand back, I say!

Hyuk makes the incision in his throat, then inserts the plastic pen shaft into the man’s throat, breathing into the tube. Everyone watches with bated breath, and once respiration resumes, Hyuk raises the boss upright and starts the Heimlich again, which is successful this time.

Everyone claps and marvels. As the tense atmosphere dissipates into relief, Ha-eung spots the arrival of police officers, ready to apprehend their wanted criminal. Thinking fast, he yells, “FIRE!” and grabs Hyuk, buying them a head start.

They do the cartoon chase thing where they run down one side street, come back up another, and manage to escape the police at every turn. It’s a pretty lame chase—again, played like a comedy, only it’s not meant to be comedic.

Hyuk wonders why the backstabber helped him, and Ha-eung points out that if the police catch him now, he doesn’t get his reward. Ha. True enough. He does chuckle, “Just kidding,” saying that he realizes now that Hyuk isn’t a murderous villain.

And then, a shocking sight. A young lady walks through the town with her maid, bearing a face identical to Mina’s. Hyuk starts to follow her, not even noticing that he loses Ha-eung, and then also loses the woman in the crowd.

She’s HONG YOUNG-RAE, daughter to a distinguished family that has fallen on hard times, and has now taken up a job selling her needlework. Lady Young-rae is quick on the uptake and assertive, not letting the shopkeep swindle her out of pay despite attempts to shortchange her work.

Even with her own financial difficulties, Young-rae is still generous enough to buy food for the less fortunate, much as Mina spent much of her time doing community service. Gah, are they reincarnated souls, or just coincidentally identical? I’m not even sure which would be more annoying.

The women come across Kyung-tak berating his officers for letting the criminal slip away. Kyung-tak is hotheaded and has little patience for excuses, sending them on along to continue the search.

But he has a soft spot for Young-rae, smiling when he spots her standing nearby. They’re on familiar terms, though Young-rae keeps him at arm’s length, not particularly thrilled to see him. He chides her for her regular outreach activities, having frequently nagged her about those neighborhoods being unfit for a lady of her standing. She replies that the inhabitants there are still people, displaying an egalitarianism that he surely doesn’t understand.

Ah, he calls himself her fiancé, and the word puts a look of chagrin on her face.

Kyung-tak is visited by his father, Minister Kim, a politician who enjoys quite a lot of power serving (and manipulating) the puppet-like king. Dad warns Kyung-tak about the bandits they encountered the night before, who call themselves Anonymous. (Cue hacking jokes!) They’ve been responsible for a number of crimes, and are more dangerous than your common thief because they appear to be targeting certain noblemen. Ah, likely they’re politically motivated, then. There’s also the growing dissatisfaction of the public to contend with, who are impatient for the criminals to be brought to justice.

Kyung-tak can only apologize for his inability to catch them, but promises his father that he’s on the task.

Minister Kim reminds Kyung-tak of the importance of prevailing over Anonymous, particularly in maintaining his family’s honor. The longer they’re at large, the more insult they fling at their respected Kim clan.

Minister Kim picks up Kyung-tak’s gun and says that the populace is like that horse in the yard, which struggles with its handler after being spooked by Hyuk last night: Give it an inch of freedom, and it’ll run wild. You have to get a firm hold on its neck to show him who’s boss. This, he declares, is the long-held secret that has served their family for generations.

And he shoots the horse in the head. Damn. Even Kyung-tak is stunned, but he tells his father he understands.

We move on to a new character, CHUN-HONG (Lee So-yeon), a gisaeng who tosses a set of dice and reads a fortune in the roll: “An important person has arrived.”

That night, Hyuk finds shelter in a stable. Now he has time to reflect on things, and he takes out his proposal ring thinking painful thoughts of Mina. Sounds from outside draw his attention—more veiled Anonymous bandits have assembled to wreak havoc.

Today, however, they’re stopped even before they begin, and one man is shot. Kyung-tak holds the gun, leading his men in an ambush and subduing the criminals.

Hyuk runs out into the city streets, and collides with a man who falls to the ground (Jin Yi-han! I didn’t know he was in this). He bears a head wound and gasps in pain. Hyuk sees the damage and asks if he’s all right, but the man passes out in his arms.

A man steps out of a nearby house and recognizes the unconscious man as Scholar Hong, so Hyuk asks the man to direct him to the appropriate house.

When they arrive, Mom gasps to see her son Young-hwi bloody and unconscious, and a second figure joins them who makes Hyuk double-take. It’s Young-rae, the scholar’s sister.

 
COMMENTS

Dr. Jin is a mixed bag, and not in a subtle way. It’s ALL over the place, with some very interesting elements and some truly cringe-inducing executions. It generally divides into Joseon timezone okay, modern day bad (execrable, really), but I’ll concede that that may be an oversimplification.

The episode starts out promising. I like the use of voiceover (most of the time), and find it a much more appropriate expository device in a dramatic series; talking to yourself tends to work better in comedies. The narration has a nicely atmospheric vibe when Hyuk (whom I just want to call Jin, damn the drama title!) is working through his thoughts. The slick medical sequences explaining the procedures, all fast cuts and C.S.I editing, on the other hand, are sillier and don’t work as well.

I like that we started in media res, thrown off the deep end along with the hero, left to puzzle out the mystery without advance warning. Then the drama goes forward (back?) to the future, and things just fall apart. It’s definitely a directing flaw, with terrible transitions, strange music cuts, and awkward pacing. This is something that made a lot more sense when I looked up the director and realized this is the Personal Taste PD. Different genre, but yup, the clumsy handling of editing and music is the same. In fact, finding out who the PD is was actually the first big incentive for me to NOT follow this show, because with other dramas I might stick around hoping for improvement, but with this one I already know we’re stuck with this clunky directing the whole way through.

Execution aside, I feel like there’s a nugget of an interesting story here. I see what they’re doing with the Hyuk-Mina clash, where he essentially loses her after coldly cutting her down about her medical philosophy. Now he gets to travel back and do right by her doppelganger, right? Or something.

It’s not just a romantic second chance, either, but a process by which he’ll regain his own sense of humanity and empathy. (I presume.) I do groan at the way Mina and Young-rae are portrayed, as essentially the same person, which bugs me whether or not they’re harboring the same soul. Given that this drama is not (supposed to be) a reincarnation drama, it’s doubly outlandish for him to just run into two girls with the same face and same personality.

But I do like the chemistry between Song Seung-heon and Park Min-young. Neither are actors I am particularly drawn to, but when they find good rapport with their co-stars, they can manage engaging (if somewhat flat) characters. I do wish that Park Min-young (in both forms) weren’t shaping up to be such a Mary Sue, though. That’s just boring.

As for the love triangle: Jaejoong reminds me of Myun in The Princess’s Man, so I can already see where his trajectory will take him. And while he’s not bad in the role, he has a jarring way of speaking that is totally distracting. (He has sageuk intonation, but he rushes all his deliveries and it sounds unnatural and forced.) Lee So-yeon I like, but I’m not sure how prominent her character will be.

But no matter about the romance angle, because I’m pretty sure the Odd Couple pairing between Song Seung-heon and Lee Beom-soo will be the one to beat. They’re already displaying an amusing offbeat dynamic, and while you can probably attribute most of the heavy lifting to Lee Beom-soo (who’s so versatile, so quick and funny), I’ll give Song credit for giving him the straight man to play off of. (Insert wooden man/Hand Towel joke here. Badum-ching!)

As for the time-skip mechanism… I just have one reaction, and you’ll have to imagine the inflection with full-on raised eyebrow: An evil jar baby? Really?

Let’s see… We’ve had magic potions given by Time Conductors, portals opened by Fate, and talismans written by Taoist monks. None is necessarily more believable than the others, and they’re all built upon some element of the supernatural. So yes, who’s to say a creepy fetus can’t be just as able to bend time and space as a mystical incantation?

It’s just… DUDE. You look like a gummi bear. I’m sorry, but no. I just can’t.

That, I think, leads to my biggest issue with the show so far: It doesn’t quite hit the right tone of seriousness, and therefore while it isn’t attempting humor, we get some of the unintended variety. Instead of dramatic, we get melodramatic. Instead of epic, we get cheesy. It’s either taking itself too seriously, or not seriously enough. The director has proven that he doesn’t know how to do delicate, or nuanced, or pull off humor that isn’t over-the-top, or pacing that doesn’t feel frenetic and out of control. The two writers’ credits include Road No. 1, Time of Wolf and Dog, and Myung-wol the Spy. Does one decent show mitigate two terrible ones? I think we all know the answer to that.

I can see this premise being interesting, but ultimately I have the feeling it’ll fail to live up to it. Possibly spectacularly.

So, recaps: We’re going to wait on all the new premieres before deciding what to follow, so final decisions have yet to be made on Dr. Jin. I do think there are a number of dramas in the new crop that look more exciting, however.

RELATED POSTS

Tags: , , , , , , ,

296

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recap. I need it to make up my mind.
An evil jar baby? Really? Muahahaha... I really LOL reading it. Overall, reading your recap I guess I've decided to skip it or at least put it on hold for later.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Funny how many people (not all, mind you) often comment your recaps with "OK, I'll pass it" or "Oh this is genius I'll definitely watch" based solely on just one recap... I always read your articles and you do really good job on them, but to make my own mind I'll always watch the real thing myself. You know, different people means different opinions, right? What if I'll like it to death in the end despite the reviews LOL So, I'll keep in mind that I'll have to wait until subs to understand everything better, because there won't be your recaps beforehand, but that doesn't mean I won't watch at least several episodes before I'll judge it XD

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

That should be the way!

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Plus 1000. That's the only caveat to dramabeans. JB is a trustworthy critic and a great recapper, which is why so many people visit her site. But it kind of worries me how many people seem to jump on the bandwagon. I always wonder how many dramas that could have been enjoyed have been rejected solely based on JB's reviews or flippant comments, or worse yet, because it would somehow be a poor reflection of yourself if you liked it. Also, I guess I have mixed feelings about the romcom bias on this site. I mean, "You're Here, You're Here, You're Really Here" is just as cringe-worthy and laughably bad (imho it's worse) as Dr. Jin. Yet it gets a lenient review and not a hint of sarcasm/facetiousness. But yeah, I have to admit it's pretty much impossible to avoid interjecting one's own feelings in a review~~

All in all, what makes a drama click with us can be arbitrary, inexplicable and sometimes, completely irrational. Logically speaking, if we really wanted to watch something well made, well written, and well acted, we wouldn't be watching 80% of the kdramas we do. Instead, we would be watching the latest films garnering rave reviews at Cannes or even Busan. There's chemistry involved in watching kdramas, so you can only know whether you'll like a drama until you've watched and judged for yourself ^^

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

As much as I dislike it, I can't help but compare this to the Japanese one, which was amazing. Compared to that, this seems kinda lackluster and the only thing that caught my interest at all was LBS...

I'll watch a couple more episodes just to make up my mind, but I'm pretty sure I'll be a passing this:/

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

As much as I dislike to, I can't help but compare this to the Japanese one, which was amazing. Compared to that, this seems kinda lackluster and the only thing that caught my interest at all was LBS...

I'll watch a couple more episodes just to make up my mind, but I'm pretty sure I'll be a passing this:/

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

oops >_< sorry for the double post

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

hi JB, pls recap Gentleman's Dignity...that drama is looking so good and so much more fun!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

What the hell, drama? A time bending jar baby?

... Is it like Mardi Gras, only horrible?

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

First I wanted to watch for JJ but after this lackluster review (which I've seen coming a mile away, frankly, given the rushed production) AND JJ setting up to be the half-bad guy who longs for the main female lead, I'll definitely slip out of this one (pun intended).

Now I can happily wait til Big and Bridal Mask come along, by the looks of it the two seem to be decent. We'll see...

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Fail to understand the negative comments above about the creepy jar baby. It won't be JIN if there isn't any creepy jar baby, or Spiderman without the spider.

0
8
reply

Required fields are marked *

@Jannie....seriously?

I'm asking honestly. knowing nothing about the previous Japanese version..or frankly...ANY version.

The Gummy-Baby in a Jar is actually the time travel ...um....device??? That opens up sooooo many possibilites.

Must say ----► I prefer the port-key in the Harry Potter series.

A muddy boot that transports you to the World Quiddith Match is much more attractive. Especially since you get a tent the size of of an apartment----

---- instead of a sidekick who has a habit of *hocking phlegm* and randomly spitting it onto himself. (those who have watched the 1st episode can ...savvy.)

gelatinous fetus in a jar vs. muddy garden boot

easy choice. ;)

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

*quidditch...gah.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

@sally_b...Yes, seriously, is there any need to call me out? My comment is purely my opinion, and as the creepy jar baby was in Japanese JIN, it was not unusual to me. In fact, the baby in JIN looked like a plastic baby toy, which could open and close its eyes. It was the timing and execution of the scene in the Jdorama that made it creepy. Baby foetus in jars are also quite well-known in the East, they are supposed to contain the spirit of the dead baby, and often used in supernatural/horror stories, movies, dramas etc. My point was why not a baby foetus in a jar?

Whether the jar baby is a time travel device, I have absolutely no idea. If you want to know, you will have to watch the show, just like me.

Unable to comment on Harry Potter's muddy boot as I don't read children stories. But I will check it out with my kid who's read it. Honestly, my personal preference would be to time travel by talisman.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh,my kid says he prefers the tournament cup as the time travel device. Seems like it transported 2 boys to a cemetery where one got killed and the other captured by an evil wizard....

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

@Jannie re: "Yes, seriously, is there any need to call me out?"

um...wasn't calling you out, was just asking an honest question as is revealed by the sentence: "I’m asking honestly. knowing nothing about the previous Japanese version..or frankly…ANY version."

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

It's not necessarily the Brain Fetus that's messing me up. It's the execution here that's laughable. In the right hands the idea could be novel, creeptastic, and interesting. Instead, this Jar Baby seems like something I would give my dog as a chew toy. :/

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

@ravens_nest - re: "...seems like something I would give my dog as a chew toy."

yup. totally agree on that.

Which makes me even more curious...that it REALLY is the *portal device*?....for reals?

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Agreed. Reading through all the comments thus far, this episode is a seminar on how mediocre scripting and direction can cripple what apparently was a decent concept in the Japanese version. Watching a surgeon having an apparent seizure while cutting into a brain and NO ONE CALLING FOR BACK UP doesn't help your credibility. You need a first-rate director to sell a brain fetus as anything but the name of an indie rock band.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I watched it yesterday and sadly if I compare it to the Jap version, Dr.Jin is far behind.

I don't really like the actors except LBS. He's the only one who can act.
PMY is okay. Man, I really can't believe SSH as brain surgeon, he's not convincing at all.
Jaejoong eyes still awkward, as well his saeguk tone. Still long way to go. He still like aware of camera.

and what the hell with fetus bottle? It's super creepy.
I'll drop this one

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

If you watched the j-version there was also a fetus in a jar.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

LOL You say you watched the japanese version of Dr. Jin and bashed the korean version but you just discovered yourself as a HATER because so far as I know the "fetus bottle " appears in the manga and japanese version of Dr. Jin.

I wonder why someone spends her time to spread hate to a drama? O.o

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

LOL

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Yeah, no. I can't take this drama seriously. SSH's dramatic wide-eyed stare = laughter. Even SSH in a totally unnecessary half-naked shower...er...lake-in-the-forest-bathing scene aren't enough to keep me on this boat. I have scruples yah know....sorta. Tally ho to Gentlemen's Dignity!!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

that "hilariously exaggerated move" (from a Frankenstein movie) when Jin had the sudden headache during operation just made him unsterile and shouldn't have been allowed to continue with the procedure. gah! drama with medical-related scenes make me point out the medical absurdities/mistakes in them. i do try to keep myself from doing so and just enjoy the drama. but i can't. it's too...obvious to ignore.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

and yes you can say that "it's too late" for surgery to a patient with severe head trauma without an MRI or CT.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

wow... so many mocking tones of this recaps... is that really bad or it just personal dislike that talking? i mean, the mocking were almost in every scenes.. and just 1 eps and the judgement is out.. that this drama gonna failed? not giving any 2nd chance? wow.. really?

i havent watched the 1st eps tho.. gonna wait till they have 3-4 eps to watched... but abt the fetus thingy.. i don think its lame or the plot is lame since this is adapted from Jin, the Jdrama.. and the evil creepy fetus n the time travelling were from the Jdrama plot..

and SSH n KJJ.. well.. i just hope he could get beeter later on.. and KJJ's saeguk tone? i read from somewhere that didnt he admitted he face difficulty to talked with saeguk tone? well, i hope he could get better.. personal thought, i think the fact that he needs to acted in 2 roles in a drama and movie, one sageuk, one comedy-moderyn style not really helping.. i hope he wont mess his 2 roles..

well, i just gonna wait before agree or disagree. many dramas have lame 1-2 eps, but get better.. eventho many also failed from the 1-2 eps.. but i still wanna know how far the Kdrama followed the Jdrama ver in the term of plot n development, eventho gonna be hard to swallow since the J-ver was so good.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

To Isoluvrain, for me, queen In hyun's Man is one of the best drama I've ever watched *besides Prosecutor Princess*. The plot and the pace is good. I recommend this to a friend, and he likes it. He usually only watches western movies, and the korean series he's ever watched are full house and city hunter.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

To Isoluvrain, for me, queen In hyun's Man is one of the best drama I've ever watched *besides Prosecutor Princess*. The plot and the pace is good. I recommend this to a friend, and he likes it. He usually only watches western movies, and the korean series he's ever watched are full house and city hunter.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Oh man.
*watches episode*
OH MAN.

Lee Beom-soo, how'd you get mixed up in this?
He's the only thing this show has going for it.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

+1

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I been waiting for this drama since forever. Three hot guys in a the same drama, what more can you ask for.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Jb, thank you for the recap. Haven't watched this episode so won't really judge it. But I laughed reading your recap. Just by looking at the screencaps, SSH is not convincing enough to be Dr Jin, but I'll reserve my judgement after I watch the first few episodes.

JIN and JIN 2 are my favorite J-doramas, so my expectations for this k-version is extremely high.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I just have to say if this dramas turns out to be cheesy and melodramatic all throughout the show and til the end well I'm heading right back to the Japanese version and watching it all over again ...

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Fetus baby tumor is creepy but I think in the jdorama version it was a bit better handled.
LBS is freaking hilarious and I think it will be on him and LSY to carry the show.
So far jdorama 1 kdrama 0 if we compare first episodes.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thank you for the recap.

Well at least, we got a lot of screenies of the pretty. Two pretties. And I don't mean PMY. :D

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I avidly watched both seasons of jdorama JIN when they aired. Though I haven't gotten to watching kdrama Dr. Jin, it seems as if they made some interesting plot changes (i.e. in JIN, the sister--played by ayase haruka--was not Jin's contemporary love interest/doppelganger). I know that's gonna change the love conflicts significantly but I guess we should wait for more episodes to see if this kdrama can compensate for this plot change.

... Also, that screencap of Seung-hun's portrayal of the headache looks quite staged and awkward compared to Osawa Takao's. :/

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

wow...jb that fast...

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Wow, so many "I'll pass" just based on one recap. Dear JB, please be kinder when it's Faith's turn. I don't like to gush alone!

0
6
reply

Required fields are marked *

-plot is messy
-pd is known by his ''style''
-the acting isn't good
-the medical stuff that should be cool is funny and makes people laugh

Why we would stick with something like this?

I already am not fan of the main leads, the story isn't nothing wow and new, so yeah, I'll pass, not only because of DB's recap, but because I had my own opnion too, and reading DB's recaps made me sure I was right about this drama......

0
4
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ditto... When I heard of this drama and read its synopsis, I know I would not like it but I do want to give it a try. But after reading JB's recap, I think I'm staying away from it now.

Too bad thou, I was a huge fan of SSH in Autumn in my Heart, which I watched about 10 years ago and hate Won Bin (I know... I hate myself for that).. Heck, he was the first Korean actor I went gaga on but now after watching his dramas (My princess & East of Eden) and movies after that, it makes me wonder what had happened to him. So now, Won Bin is like one of my fav. actor, while SSH is not even in the list.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

oh wow I found someone who didn't like Won Bin!!!

I didn't like Won Bin in Autumn in my tale, everyone talked how hot he was and all, and all I could think is that he was a annoying brat LOL

But in my case, until today, I still don't see what Won Bin has that make fans go crazy. I don't even find him that good looking too *gasp* I know, don't kill me people!

Well, I admit his eyes and lips and body is sexy, but something about his face/heah turns me off.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

i don't get the craze over won bin either.
am surprise to know there's another person who thinks like that too. kekeke.
not too say he's not what people say he is. It's a matter of taste, I suppose.

0

wow, why are we talking about wonbin at Dr. Jin's thread? But, glad to know that at least i'm not the only abnormal person who doesn't go gaga over wonbin. He's good looking, but there are some other actors i know who's more good looking...i think people really overrated him where looks is concern. But, i love the way he carries himself..such a quiet guy.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Episode 1 was messy. I wonder if the rushed filming contributed to the mess. However, one episode does not a drama or plot make, so as usual, I'll reserve judgement for at least 4 episodes.

The acting was good, especially Lee Bum Soo and the evil minister. Park Min Yong was OK, Song Seung Hoon was erratic, Jae Joong was stiff and we didn't get to see much of Lee So Yeon, which was a pity. Anyway, I've noticed that in most dramas, the actors usually need a couple of episodes to settle into their characters, so hopefully they'll improve. I remember a certain Moon-Sun lead actress, who seemed to take many episodes before there was some improvement. Yet, people still stuck with it, probably for the yummy king in white pyjamas...hehe.

As for the medical stuff, the drama had better call for an expert consultant immediately. If the story is anything like the Jdorama, there's gonna be a lot more medical stuff to come!

Actually, the story is supposed to be great, but can the Korean production deliver the goods? We'll have to wait and see.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I'll watch this after Queen I Hyun. I'll watch because of JYJ jaejoong, i want to check if he has improves his acting, can it be at par with Micky. As for park Min Young, I think she will be for-ever Kim Yoon Sik in my heart.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks JB for the recap!

*Sigh* After seeing the first episode, I couldn't find it interesting at all. Maybe because I don't really like the casts, I don't know, and I think the Japanese version's actually better, so I'll pass this drama.

Anyway, Big and Bridal Mask are coming. You'll surely recap them, right? Hehe.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for recap, but I'll still watch to form my own opinion.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Just finished watching Episode 1 .... not as bad as what some had commented. I'm curious and excited to watch following episodes to understand how each scene in Episode 1 inter-relates with the rest ... Both SSH and LBS co-operate well together here. SSH looks good.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I will follow this drama and see where it goes... but for now it's more because I'm not interested in AGD. So if I drop this... I will only follow QIM and QI (Queen Insoo) on weekends and Bridal Mask and Big during the week!

Still looking forward to Nice Guy!*___* Not so much waiting for Faith!:-(

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

We watch this because of Song seung Hun! Keep up the good Job Song oppa! Cheers!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

"The editing on this show is like something out of SNL—it’s timed like slapstick comedy, only it’s not supposed to be."

Wait...you mean it's not billed as a campy exaggerated romp meant to make me bust a gut? *gasp* Say it ain't so!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

It seems kind of similar to the tone of Dr. Who - not overly serious, has some good moments, and very entertaining. But, like I said, not to be taken too seriously.

0
2
reply

Required fields are marked *

Naw...Doctor Who is miles above this in storytelling, themes, music, and acting. Especially the newest era. The camp in DW is largely intentional and played for laughs/nostalgia. The episodes (barring some) are also better edited and plotted. This is just bad...

lol Sorry. I'm a serious Whovian. I'll stop here before I go on an essay long rant about the wonders of Doctor Who.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

I agree... Comparing this to Dr. Who is sacrilege.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I recently watched JIN and I'm currently watching JIN2.

This looks like a train wreck. I might be wrong. I'll revisit it after completing the other program.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

SSH is very good. Song Seung Heon is very good actor. I like how playing. I like Jin Hyuk. I look forward to next episodes.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

‘It’s just… DUDE. You look like a gummi bear. I’m sorry, but no. I just can’t.’

HAHAHAAHAHA!!!!! cannot agree with you more... not sure if we're supposed to be creeped out by it, cuz if that's the point, creepy foetus aint doing its job. the music really does the drama no favors. lee beom soo is undoubtedly the episode's (let's hope it doesnt turn out to be the drama's) saving grace.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

OK... Seriously how can a girl reject or don't feel something for JAEjoong's character.. I mean in which year it is how can a girl reject that pretty face. in that century XD.. Unless you have someone else..which she didn't fell in love with our Hero yet.. she must be blind..XD

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

i guess some women just dont like men who are prettier than they are.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Some prefers manly man over pretty boys :).

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

His costume does him no favors. I know he is thin but he just looks so much more thinner in this costume that it distracts me from watching the pretty face. Well that and his acting detracted from show (but I don't only blame him).

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for this recap, now I'm sure I won't be watching this show..i really hate how they butchered the love aspect of the the original...Jin's fiancee should be the courtesan not the student-doctor...

I also hate to think that PMY's brother in this drama will likely to have a less prominent role than in the J-version.

I'm wondering how the drama will be able to handle to showcase Jin and his sensei (the one who died of tuberculosis) in this version, it's one of the most dramatic scenes in the original..

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

thanks JAVABEANS for the recap. For YOUR COMPARISON the time-traveling dramas oddly come in pairs ;) RTP and QIHM are about male time-travelers who have political backgrounds, former is the Prince, later is the right hand man of the Queen. So in Time Slip Dr. Jin and Faith, we have two doctors going backwards time-travelers, who will be aided by warriors, Jejong and Min Ho respectively. I am waiting impatiently for Faith, because the time gap is huuuge, Min Ho is there, and for the first time there will be a female time-traveler! yay!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recap
.. and i kept waiting for a gentleman's dignity recap but i guess that's not gonna happen :D

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

so if the fetus-looking tumor came from that patient's brain, can we call it a "brainchild"? LOL

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

thanks JB !

Special request please ?

anyone in the team recapping gentlemen dignity,

- funny, hilarious and witty !! but I don't understand the

language !!.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Ah gee, I was so hoping this would be good but all that heavy-handed convenient plotting makes me feel I'll be rolling my eyes throughout the run of this show. But at least you've warned me.

The only reasons I might watch this are because I like time-travel shows and I love Lee Beom-soo. I like Kim Jae-Joong but his acting always makes me cringe and something about the odd perfection of his face makes me cringe even more. It's like watching a model attempt to act: tons of teeth-gritting.

Thanks as usual for your great recaps.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Sorry, but Song Seung-heon does NOT fit Joseon era. He seem really awkward... Come to think of it, he is not that versatile for an actor.

Lee Beom-soo on the other hand, he's awesome. Actually, he's the only reason why I was interested in Dr. Jin. Not Song Seung-heon, not Jae-joong and not even Park Min-young!

I think I'll skip this drama for now and see how the story develops. I already skipped King 2 Heart, Love Rain, Fashion King and Equator Man... Nothing seems that good these days! Except for Queen In Hyun's Man and Big (not out yet but 100% excited for this drama!) and also I Do, I Do (same as Big).

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

But SSH is not supposed to fit the Joseon era as he came from the future! Agree with the limited acting part.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for the recap. Same writer as Myung Wol ??? I swore I would not take that writer's road to nowhere, again. I hated the fiasco with Myung Wol.

If you decide not to continue with the recaps, I'll understand.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Another Lee Won Jong sighting! Isn't that him as the Loan SHark Boss?

If it is, then it is official; he does not sleep. He appears in so many dramas that I am surprised that javabeans and girlfriday have not started a drinking game based on his appearances.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

i am not enamored by the lead pair - their acting is so so. Yoo Bang from History of salary man - is the only interesting acting here... i will wait til this drama ends so i can fast forward the parts that are cliche'......i find nothing new - the fetus in the brain is plain gross!

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

I saw the Japanese version of this which was great. This version...not so much. Reading this recap only cemented the fact that I'm not going to continue watching this drama. Oh well. Thanks for the recap JB

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Trying this out only because I liked the japanese version so much :/

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Thanks for recap! Hmm, I'll give a few more episodes before deciding if I want to follow this one or not. :) You never know, show could surprise us. LOL

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

LOL, watched it live, sighed at another oh- no where am I?, disappointed with PMY's character- boring, canned babe is def a no-no, sighed at med procedures and more are surely coming, and the Joseon era didn't surprise/capture me. Overall, felt dry. Verdict, not gonna follow this one. Sorry, it's probably because I've had two time-travel already, RTP and QIHM, the third one seems pretty hard to swallow. Plus, this drama has that of weekend drama's vibe, which is not a good sign.

Thanks JB ^^

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Had a feeling this was a fail.

0
0
reply

Required fields are marked *

For heaven's sake can't we not enjoy the drama first before tearing it to pieces on episode one.

This drama was first a manga ,then japan made it into a drama, now this. As you know the transition from the small frame into the small screen has never been easy. Execution will always be flawed specially if every detail is scrutinized. You might say as a viewer,you deserve to watch something perfect -but then again ,this is drama not real life(even that is flawed you know). So disbelief must be suspended.

Please don't insult the viewers by actually saying you are watching something crappy. We want to just enjoy not intellectualize the drama. Your analysis may have to be better received in lecture halls in academia.Though to your credit , you make me laugh .Sometimes.

0
3
reply

Required fields are marked *

I don't particularly understand why you're becoming defensive on behalf of the drama or nitpicking what Javabeans does. You came here with the understanding that she reviews dramas in a way that is far from superficial, and she has seen enough of them to know when the elements click or when it is a jumbled mess.

Considering the amount of K-dramas that exist and the increasing number of new dramas released each month, I find her insight extremely helpful when choosing what to watch because I certainly don't have time to view everything that is released. Just because she believes a show is poorly executed doesn't mean she is insulting people who watch it or enjoy it.

0
1
reply

Required fields are marked *

Well, I don't particularly understand why you're becoming so defensive on behalf of JB, jk ^^

On a more serious note, JB is definitely a dependable critic. HOWEVER, even JB is subject to bias; we all are~~ I remember checking out some dramas that were highly recommended, like What's Up Fox, Coffee House, Queen of Reversals, and The Woman Who Still Wants to Marry. These dramas were given waaaayyy more praise than they deserved. Their plots were generally weak, cliche, and at some points ridiculous. (Though I can maybe understand how these dramas could be enjoyable based on the strength of and chemistry between the actors: GHJ, PSH, KNJ, etc).

Anywho, yeah, Dr. Jin was poorly executed, but its plot is a lot more interesting than most generic romcoms like Romance Town or something. And Dr. Jin has logic fails, but I feel like face palming due to absurdities/ridiculousness in 90-95% of all kdramas I watch.

While I also felt like poking fun at Dr. Jin, (argghhh...that fake, fakity fake-looking plastic fetus) I remember feeling nettled about JB's flippancy about Brain (even before the first episode aired!!) because I have a special soft spot for Brain. We don't mind criticism. It's the sarcasm that ruffles our feathers. Because yes, if someone makes fun of a drama that you are enjoying, that tends to make them defensive :) I mean, most people KNOW when they're watching something terrible, but they have some reason or another for watching it, and in that case, the drama's flaws tend to frustrate rather than amuse, lol. I guess mocking is alright when it's done good naturedly. But it may feel unfair that some dramas escape unscathed while others bear the brunt of it. Especially if you disagree. But whatever, that's life~~

0
reply

Required fields are marked *

Dramabeans » DECONSTRUCTING korean dramas and kpop culture.

0
reply

Required fields are marked *