HOW CAN YOU POSSIBLY BASH ALL THREE OF THEM (HB, HJW AND SHK) all at once??

Do you have evidence HJW had ANYTHING to do with this?

Why do you have to drag her into this?
This is between HB and SHK...
we'll cross bridges when they come

GOSH!

The signs have been there that it's not a bed of roses on the HB-SHG camp. In fact, many have been expecting the break up to be officially announced.

I am for a HB-HJW relationship.

I thought they already broke up long before.

I don't read the rumors beside here at Dramabeans :). Too little interest in their private life. Have one at my own.

I love the shorn photos of actors about to serve. Tells how deep the x factor really is! Binnie is still really HOT.

can't say i'm surprised by the split, though i have to say the timing of this benefits him but not her, which is not particularly nice (and i say this even though i'm not a fan of shk).

I slightly happy at this news.....gosh does that make me a bad bad person.....

I cried when I watch the clip of him leaving. I can't believe that he have to leave. Awwwwww 2 years is such a long time I hope it go by fast

I am saddened by the news for I thought that they could make it work.

Still hoping that they reconcile after having some down time from work. Being busy can eclipse people's real feelings until they find a quiet time to reflect.

Just my wishful heart talking ....

All celebrities relationships should be kept secret and private, then there will nothing to comment on, no bashing ,no speculation,no antis, not even rumours. Some celebrities manage to do that,and we never hear a peep about their lovelife/relationship. Our need to find out everything about our stars are quite intrusive, to the extend that the relationship is very difficult to nurture ,when time is scarce and public scrutiny is so intense. I guess this is the price of stardom.

Just to add with all the other comments -

YES!
YES!
YES!
YAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!

i'm soooo biased...

He's so tall compared to the rest. Such a stand out

haha I'm happy.. I hope he gets with his Secret Garder co star.. XD .. They are both cute and hope she is nice in real life..

See ya in 2 years looking forward for you projects then.. TT

No surprise here. This break-up has been pretty much hinted for a long time.

I truly feel for Hye Kyo. Hope that she'll get over it soon. How hard it must be for her to overcome two high-profile but unsuccessful relationships.

The positive thing is, my fantasy for Bi-Kyo couple is revived again in its full glory. True love will find its way back in the end.//end dreaming

dont noe which im more sad about him leaving or them breaking up

damn, there are some seriously short guys!

I think I'm one of the few people who is happy that he's single! Yay!!!
And I'm sad that he's in the military T.T
Well, see you in two years...
I'm a chant "Kim Soo-han mu..." for now :D

ITS FATE. HYUN BIN NEEDS TO BE WITH HA JI WON

I can`t deny that I like HB very much and this news makes me feel sad. But that`s life, you can`t have it all...success VS love, hard to e both. Good luck HB, I will miss you!

I could safely say that their actual relationship lasted less than a year then. Wow binnie just towers over the rest! haha

finally, actually i'm not suprise. even they not say it officially, we can see it
well, a lot of man and woman must be happy out there....
byebye binnie n SHK, find a new boyfiend, handsome, rich one :)

hear hear!

...I wish HB and SHG all the best.

It may just be me, but I find its disturbing how fans (even the awesome ones commenting here) confuse the actors with the characters they play.

I hope SHG, HB and HJW each are able to have wonderful, lasting relationships with whomever it is they love, period. Its kinda selfish as fans to want HB and HJW to get together in real life, as if they are really Joo-Won and Ra-Im, who often forget are fictional characters.

Or for us to think its any of our business who any of these actors are dating, 'cause its not.

theres a glimpse of tears in his eyes in the 1st. Oh!! Im going to miss u so very much Binnie!

on comment about him and HJW. i think they dont match at all . dont get me wrong im a SG lover.soo yeah..

Thanks GF for this news.

Sorry to hear about HB and SHG split.

If it is for real, I think it might be actually good for both of them to split at this time considering HB will be in the military, the marines to be exact. Not always easy to keep a relationship when you are physically apart. But I guess they've been physically apart even before the MS came up hence the need to split up officially.

Well, only time will tell. I wish the best for both of them. And if they end up together even after 2 years then it must be true love! We will all celebrate with both of them.

With the schedules they take on it is really hard to maintain a sane relationship. Maybe this time in the marines he will take stock of what are the things in his life that really matter.

As drama-watchers, we are most grateful for the actors' passion and dedication in their craft because we benefit from their hard work when they give of themselves to the roles but this very demanding career also cost them their personal lives if the sacrifices for their time goes unchecked. We hope they will prioritize their own relationships rather than doing a project for the heck of it.

Ultimately, we want a fulfilled and happy HB and SHG (and even HJW) as a person/individuals...to pay them back for all the happy moments they gave us through their work.

yipeee!
oh, uhm sorry. *collects self*

btw, he already looks more fit and healthy, and he's not even serving yet.

Just as I guess ha...ha....ha

Binnie will be missed terribly.

i’m sure they will stay amicable

i was kinda expecting this but i just dont want to think about it. i hope they could try again after his military service? hehe. im still hoping. they are awesome together!

Some stupid ppl r bloody fools going around spreading rumours abt hb lie, Ah well don’t get me started ppl are nitpicking it more than others just to go against the grain. you get retribution, your kids born with a split lips
Bloody shk fans same old crying is so not getting me any sympathy shut your bloody fuckup.

LoL. Only good looking one in the bunch. Haha

Agreed, excellent PR handling.

I wish both of them the best.

Misfortunate news of a celeb breakup, however if I had a beautiful gf like SHG making her rounds while I'm on active duty then I might go crazy [or dead] from all possible frustrations. It's way better and for the best, out of sight out of mind, I suppose, and if destiny really is meant to be then 2 yrs seems a short test of sincere affection.

I'm eager to see if SHG will greet him after HB's 2 yrs service terminates than seeing her send him in-service like this.

Stay in good spirits Hyun Bin, and come back safe.

Take care, be healthy and be safe the whole of your service from the military.

We all be waiting for your safe return!

I was your fan in this relationship HB and SHK.
But what can I say about your breaking up... Hope and pray it's the best decision that you both agreed.
If you both are happy with it then I'll understand.

Goodluck to you both!

"Amicable split with girlfriend announced the day after so that every woman turns into a puddle of goo imagining how lonely and heartbroken he is, entering the army? Check."
LOL. That is SO me right now. Poor Hyun Bin!

Seeing him actually shed tears, IN PUBLIC, of gratitude etc makes me really respect him as a person and not just sex-on-a-stick eye candy who also happens to be a good actor.

See ya soon Binnie! ♥

well I miss him already! He is such a great actor, I'll waiting for u HB :)

I'm not a fans a SHK (doesn't mean I hate her), n I'm not a fans of HB too before (I like him after watch SG), so the break up news is not make me sad or happy, when I read the news I just say "oh, they're break up".. That's it. As same as when they announced that they're dating, I'm saying "oh, they're dating".. :D.
I won't comment about who's better with HB , either SHK or HJW (although I'm a HB-HJW shipper :D), because the article is about HB and SHK, so I won't talk about HJW.

I'm just gonna say,, TRUE LOVE WILL FIND THE WAY.... WHATEVER WILL BE, WILL BE... Always support and hopes for the best for them

Wishing him all the best! (Still hoping for a Kim Sun Ah collabo. I just like seeing these two very talented beings together)

Good grief ! Song Hye-gyo would not send Hyun Bin to the marine base! How can yo NOT????

Hyun Bin, yo better off without her..
Kim Sun Ah YES..Ha Ji Won..YES.. Lee Yeon Hee..YES.. they would..

We’ll miss yo Hyun Bin. See you in 2012

What's with the comment about HB being too good for HJW? So shallow!!! No one is too good for someone. Plus, I personally think HJW is very beautiful..inside and out!!!

Anyways, back to HB and SHK. We don't know the inside story...so stop blaming on anyone!! Its not our business! Fans should just support their idols during this hard time..breaking up is never easy!! I may not be a fan of SHK but I sure hope she will get through this....as for Binnie...fighting!! Stay safe!!

if they stil love each other...someday wil know the result. but those said HB and HJW match just your hopeless....wake up...MOST of the Man in the world never dreaming to mary an older Women in real life. if they are useless man sure will do mary older women. .man dreaming to mary or date youg ang beatiful women in real life.

hmmmmm.... I'm so happy....... SHK ONLY MATCH FOR BI RAIN, NOT FOR HYUN BIN .......
BIKYO fighting!!!!!

ha ji won and hyun bin forever!!!!!!! i really love them both!!

he was referring to SHK, i think that episode was filmed jan2011, but they officially announced they called it quits after mar7, right after the military thingy..

but i kinda expected they'll split before the military, that's what men in relationship does when they go military. hope they'll get back together... if not, well, HB and HJW pairing is not that bad though. i seriously think they look so much alike in SG.

if im not mistaken han ji won is 3 or 4 years ahead to hyun bin ,hahaha! well im just saying ! and i hear they just good friends no special feelings for each other its just work so please stop saying nonsense that they are DATING or something ,, hahaha! *MY GAHDDD* acting is acting , work is work ,,of course they have a very good chemistry in secret garden IM SOO addict in kim joo won and gil ra im love's story I ADMIT IT, but reality is reality.. and about the break-up of HYUN BIN and SONG HYE KYO i feel bad for both of them i think they still love each other ,, its just that hyun bin had to leave because of his marine service so he needs to split-up to song hye kyo to give her freedom * yah * 2 years is not A JOKE , well song hye kyo is every man's dream, i hope hyun bin will not regret this later :D

happy to know about well thats part of life for hyun bin just take will miss you saranghe

Oh whatever , Im just glad to see him gain some weight already and he look much healthier now . Sure a 6 fter will stand out.

And about his relationship with SHK , i dont know much about asian couple , but i have never heard of a couple celebrity like that , I mean both of them try to keep it so private that we keep thinking that they never dated actually.

Maybed they dont have persistent Paparazzi as in USA , i mean they are A-Star in korea their personal life should interest viewers but they never been a picture of both of them in the public , NOT one that make me a bit suspect about the nature of their relationship i m sure they are friend but if they dated or not i m not sure since the broke up just confirm it , it's just too obviously calculated a few hours before he enlisted they broke up.

I don't know much about their personality but it's may be like that , they dated a few months since 2009 , they stayed amical after they got apart for their project oversea , and since it's not convenient anymore and troubelsome for both of them their management announced that they broke up

Anyway , I love them both , i love ha ji won too but since we dont know any of them you can't say what's really going on .

Be healthy !