Gumiho vs. Kiss: Vote!
by javabeans
As you know, an epic showdown is approaching, with My Girlfriend Is a Gumiho and Playful Kiss both airing on Wednesday-Thursday nights.
Girlfriday and I have literally spent hours (HOURS!) trying to figure out how to handle recaps of both dramas (if Playful Kiss ends up being recap-worthy, that is), and both dramas have the potential to be madly addictive and highly popular with fans.
One problem: We have yet to discover how to make time stand still.
Basically, the pattern is AABB or ABAB. We’re ignoring ABBA.
Vote for your preference below, and we’ll let the numbers do the talkin’.
BIG FAT CAVEAT: Barring extenuating circumstances, we will abide by the winning pattern. However, we reserve the right to change our minds if, for instance, one drama starts sucking the mighty big one halfway through, in which case we want to feel free to bump up the better performer. And we are not making promises as to WHEN these recaps get put up. We are mindful of fan fervor and would love to be as fast as possible, but we also want to leave room for, you know, life and stuff. We will promise to try.
Required fields are marked *
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
251 wanderingme
August 30, 2010 at 6:51 AM
i'm with GF on this one... ABBA all the way!
Required fields are marked *
252 Kobe
August 30, 2010 at 6:57 AM
Wow! Almost 7 thousand unique votes. Seriously, if JB ran for president she'll win in a landslide.
Required fields are marked *
253 Rosy
August 30, 2010 at 7:34 AM
7000 votes! That's impressive!
Required fields are marked *
254 LILOminusSTITCH
August 30, 2010 at 7:42 AM
Have not watched a single episode of MGIG coz its not showing here in SG yet but just from reading your recaps makes me feel like i'm watching it live!! Great work peeps! Love your writings and animated intelligent and oh so funny posts. Glad to know that AABB is still in the lead. Yay!!
Required fields are marked *
255 suyan
August 30, 2010 at 7:43 AM
i vote for gumiho of course.. that's still original!!
i already watched playful kiss in taiwanese n japan version, even t'indonesian version also.. so i guess everyone already know how t' drama will goes. except it's getting better like kkotboda namja did. but still it must not be far away from t' original manga stories right?!
Required fields are marked *
256 IrishCreme
August 30, 2010 at 8:02 AM
how about JB take the Fox & GF take the Kiss??
Required fields are marked *
257 Mel
August 30, 2010 at 8:56 AM
Gumiho, Kiss, Gumiho, Kiss! <3<3 Thanks!
Required fields are marked *
258 Gina
August 30, 2010 at 9:24 AM
If you have a certain negative vibe for the actor or actress of Mischievous Kiss, then I recommemd not to recap or do anything on that drama, unless you enjoy all the bashing from both antis, and fans.
It's just going to degrade the quality of the blog, unless you do it with a clear, unbiased point of view, which is nooot so easy.
Required fields are marked *
259 pumpkinattack
August 30, 2010 at 10:27 AM
I love you guys. Too funny!
Required fields are marked *
260 MEL
August 30, 2010 at 11:51 AM
JB AND GF THANKS ALWAYS FOR ALL THE HARD WORK YOU DO....IT'S AMAZING HOW SOME OF THE RECAPS ARE SO QUICK THAT I'LL WATCH THE DRAMAS RAW WITH YOUR RECAPS SINCE I DON'T UNDERSTAND HANGUL... THANKS, LOOKS LIKE MGIG IS DOING WELL... AND KISS WILL BE ABLE TO STAND ON ITS OWN... THANKS ONCE AGAIN
Required fields are marked *
261 Hwaiting
August 30, 2010 at 12:09 PM
I actually adore ISWAK and the actors, and I also love Kim Hyun Joong. I can't wait to see what Playful Kiss is gonna be like, but I'm also pretty sure that people love Guhimo a lot, and they'll be going to that drama instead of this one.
Required fields are marked *
Ellie
August 31, 2010 at 8:58 AM
They are recapping both, just one is being done first, I don't see why there is this PK or Gumiho only.
Required fields are marked *
262 ven
August 30, 2010 at 6:26 PM
Hyun Joong is love!
Required fields are marked *
zoe
August 30, 2010 at 10:03 PM
@ 261 and 262:
I kno...just forget it! It is not gonna turn out fair for PK fans like us anyway...i was very excited initially but i guess nw i ll ve to go somewhere else.
Required fields are marked *
Poppy
September 1, 2010 at 12:39 PM
ew
Required fields are marked *
263 lolly
August 30, 2010 at 6:51 PM
gumiho...gumiho...gumiho...gumiho....PLEASE...
since vikii is extreemely slow in my area, i only count on your MGIG recaps girls....
playfull kiss is a drama from old school manga, so if we want to know the story just read the manga...it even have indonesian version about 6-7 years ago.
so gumiho...gumiho...forever....!!!!
Required fields are marked *
264 kathy
August 30, 2010 at 7:30 PM
I want to watch drama G-G-G-G haha!!!
Required fields are marked *
265 Raving Fan
August 30, 2010 at 8:23 PM
I just love Gumiho.
The characters are so unique...
The acting is positively wonderful too!
Required fields are marked *
Annie
September 1, 2010 at 12:38 PM
word.
Required fields are marked *
266 mary
August 31, 2010 at 12:44 AM
I have watched 6 ep of Gumiho already, and I am anticipating to watch Playful Kiss. will decided which drama I like best after watching Playful kiss...
Required fields are marked *
267 vicky
August 31, 2010 at 1:37 AM
me and my friends wants kiss kiss kiss kiss recap because gumiho is too corny at all! all the cast are old to watch!!!
Required fields are marked *
Hannah
September 1, 2010 at 12:37 PM
VOMIT.
Required fields are marked *
268 laila
August 31, 2010 at 1:56 AM
DEFINITELY GUMIHO, GUMIHO, then playful kiss XD i'm looking forward to playful kiss but i've seen other versions of it before and i really want to know what happens next in gumiho and you guys give very detailed recaps, so i only read the summary cos i cant always watch it especially with sites that's only available in US and Canada and i dont have time to, do gumiho first please~
Required fields are marked *
269 alma
August 31, 2010 at 2:45 AM
honestly, most of the PK's fans don't know this kind of poll..i hope the people behind for this will smart enough to know who's drama would be recap first..obviously, this poll is for bashing the lead actor of PK only..sorry but that's what i felt on this poll
Required fields are marked *
Ellie
August 31, 2010 at 8:56 AM
I honestly don't think people are bashing Playful Kiss (although the lead does not get too much love, that's due to his prior acting). The poll is asking how the recaps should be done, and obviously Gumiho might have a better lead because it's already 6 eps in, thus people have already had a chance to really like it. I understand that some of these commenters are not nice about the PK lead but don't call this poll to be unfair.
Required fields are marked *
alma
September 1, 2010 at 2:19 AM
try to read all the comments here, they are all bashing our leader. if they want to vote for their lee seung gi's drama, be it but why does many haters????
it's okay if they don't want to recap PK..don't bother, we're just fine..we will go somewhere for the happiness of gumiho...honestly, i'm watching right now of MGIG but the same as others opinion here. i'm not interested to continue to watch since the leading actor and actress are not my favorite..it doesn't matter to me if the story is fresh and amazing as long as i don't like it
Required fields are marked *
Ellie
September 1, 2010 at 9:03 AM
Like I said, some people are not being nice about saying that the lead of PK cannot act, and perhaps that they don't want PK to be recapped, but that's not bashing.
Me saying that I don't want PK to be recapped is just as okay as you saying that you will not continue watching MG because you don't like the leads.
Required fields are marked *
Ellie
September 1, 2010 at 9:05 AM
And I didn't say that I didn't want PK recapped, I just said it that way to make a point.
Required fields are marked *
Naomi
September 1, 2010 at 12:35 PM
But its true, Kim Hyun Joong can't act to save his life..I cringed, and almost gagged while watching him in Boys Over Flowers.
Required fields are marked *
lalala
September 2, 2010 at 4:19 PM
Our leader?
He ain't no leader of mine girl.
Required fields are marked *
270 gita
August 31, 2010 at 5:44 AM
Gumiho gumiho kiss kiss......
Required fields are marked *
271 soju_chic
August 31, 2010 at 7:48 AM
Gumiho for the win! I'd still like to give PK a try though. But first things first. So GGKK.
Required fields are marked *
272 jeezvive
August 31, 2010 at 8:06 AM
My vote : GUMIHO - GUMIHO - KISS - KISS
Required fields are marked *
273 Jobz
August 31, 2010 at 8:33 AM
Reasons why I picked GGKK
1. It's a new drama, not a remake, and I enjoy the speculations/discussions on what's going to happen next.
2. The couples in drama are adorable, and not just the main pair. The aunt-director pairing is quite fun as well.
3. Shin Min-ah. She owns the role, even though some people had their reservations when she was casted, the way she portrays Mi Ho is JUST. THAT. AWESOME.
4. It's the Hong Sisters'.
5. It's already 6-episodes in, and so far all the episodes are a delight to watch.
I think the way this poll was conducted is pretty fair. And it's understandable that majority of the voters would pick Gumiho over PK because of reason #5. I don't hate PK, I just love Gumiho.
Anyway more power to JB and GF. You're recaps ROCK!
Required fields are marked *
Jobz
August 31, 2010 at 8:36 AM
brain-fart moment "your* recaps ROCK" XD
Required fields are marked *
274 jenni
August 31, 2010 at 10:03 AM
I guess i should start watching this drama if it's beating Kiss in the polls
Required fields are marked *
jenni
August 31, 2010 at 11:50 AM
So like i said i was going to watch Gumiho drama and I am so happy i did i just finished the first ep and there really i was mad at myself for not taking interest at first its a really good drama...I am sure Pk is going to be good to but right now Gumiho is my priority DRAMA
Thank you Javabeans & Girlfriday you guys rock
Required fields are marked *
Jobz
August 31, 2010 at 5:20 PM
Glad you liked the show. :) I wish more PK fans would see what the buzz about Gumiho first before judging it.
Required fields are marked *
alma
September 1, 2010 at 2:09 AM
no matter what the outcome of playfull kiss, we stand it for khj, nothing more...i'm pretty sure triple s from korea and around the world really don't know this poll...as i've learned from the past if the name of khj stated, girls rocks!
Required fields are marked *
Elana
September 2, 2010 at 4:17 PM
dayum, you are obsessed with ugly khj...weird.
275 b.m
August 31, 2010 at 12:03 PM
i voted gumiho kiss gumiho kiss
Required fields are marked *
276 sokhasen
August 31, 2010 at 12:27 PM
hoi-hoi and pk-pk for me....
Required fields are marked *
sokhasen
August 31, 2010 at 12:28 PM
i meant
Hoi Hoi-Hoi Hoi and pk-pk
Required fields are marked *
277 Yeng
August 31, 2010 at 9:07 PM
As long as the pattern is aabb i wont mind which one go first because is better for me to know what is next after another than to come back for one after a day. But I am fine with anyway really becuase you guys try so hard to recap them, i am thankful for it ^^
Required fields are marked *
278 Mediet
September 1, 2010 at 12:50 AM
I vote for Gumiho, Kiss, Gumiho, Kiss..
That is if Playful Kiss will be as good as Gumiho..Right now i am totally hooked with Gumiho...
Myself don't know how to watch all of these dramas that are showing...so i don't know how u (JB n GF) will be able to do this...
But u guys do what's best and what works for u..and which drama that most drawn u guys...Even if the recaps come late..it doesn't matter..coz i really love both of ur writing..and all i want is to be able to read ur recaps at ur timeline....love love
Required fields are marked *
279 issabella
September 1, 2010 at 8:01 AM
either way, i'm happy that both are being recapped.. especially if they finish it :)
Required fields are marked *
S
September 3, 2010 at 1:41 AM
:) :) :) :) :)!!!
Required fields are marked *
280 ichigopan
September 1, 2010 at 10:10 AM
This is tough. I guess it doesn't really matter if both start going down hill. Lol.
Pessimism aside, thanks JB and GF for opening this up to a vote and considering recapping both at the same time. Recaps are hard work so thank you for punching them out and making them fun to read. Most importantly, you always demystify nuances and clear up inaccurate translations. :) Thank you!
Required fields are marked *
281 Rose
September 1, 2010 at 12:28 PM
Definitely Gumiho.
Plus I can't stand Kim Hyun Joong's acting!
Required fields are marked *
S
September 3, 2010 at 1:40 AM
dude you should watch Playful Kiss and knows that he has improved a hell lot AND KNOWS HOW TO ACT. not being a crazy fangirl (when i'm not even one of his to begin with) but you should see before you talk.
Required fields are marked *
Dude
September 3, 2010 at 2:22 PM
sry to say this but if that's what you call acting.. wow........ speechless.
Instead of praising about his little improvement on acting, I hope that some of his fans write constructive criticism about his acting so he can read and realize and practice acting or sth. Seriously open your eyes!
Awkward facial expressions, awkward speech and tone and sometimes I couldn't understand what he was saying (and I am korean), his eyes looked dull and not very attractive as well.
If KHJ continues to show that kind of acting throughout entire episodes. He should end his acting career. He doesn't seem to have other images or characters to show other than cool good looking character, what I mean is that he has limits of getting different roles. You think Korean audiences are blind and deaf?! Filming drama is not practicing stage!!
(Glad I got this out of my chest.. I just couldn't stand it anymore. )
Required fields are marked *
dianao9o4
September 4, 2010 at 12:36 AM
i agree with you.. ^^
Required fields are marked *
282 Carmen
September 2, 2010 at 3:35 PM
Gumiho, Gumiho,Gumiho and Gumiho Hoi… Hoi
I’m enjoying Gumiho and will watch it first before Kiss.
Required fields are marked *
283 dianao9o4
September 4, 2010 at 12:34 AM
absolutely i vote for gumiho,gumiho,kiss,kiss...
the truth is i was also fanatic with iswak..
but when i saw the korean version, it's not daebak as the taiwanese version..
i;m so dissapointed.. =(
i hope in the future they can do more better..
so in order to heal my broken heart, i watched gumiho..
omo!!! shin min ah so cute you know..
i wish i can be just like her.. keke.. ^^
Required fields are marked *
284 Heilie
September 5, 2010 at 4:36 AM
Gumiho Gumiho Gumiho Gumiho!
Required fields are marked *
285 Isabella
September 5, 2010 at 10:59 PM
Gumiho all the way! I love reading your recaps!! Its awesome!!! :)))
Required fields are marked *
286 moonlight
September 6, 2010 at 3:32 PM
Is Seung Jo not Arrogant and Cold Enough ?
There are viewers who are urging Hyun Joong to portray Seung Jo with more coldness and arrogance . That is to say , according to their take of his acting in the past shown episodes 1 and 2 of Mischievous Kiss, he is still not displaying the appropriate attributes and attitudes of the character .
How is an actor suppose to assay his character ? Should he just project it through physical means ,his clothes, his facial expressions ,his body language ? Could he also verbalize them ? How is he suppose to show or withhold his emotions ?
But the trouble with these attributes and attitudes is they come in different shades or variations and still be in the same range. They can also be projected in subtle ways . One does not have to be loud and obvious .
Arrogance, for example can be physically manifested by the theatrical stiff upper lip and by a flip of the hand (you can say this is the stereotypical snobbish trait ). Arrogance can also be shown by surrounding oneself with a cordon sanitaire –that impenetrable bastion of loyal subjects (read :gang or close friends) A person can also be arrogant by the way he speak –overbearing , overly authoritative, overconfident. Arrogance also be expressed when a person sees himself as better , smarter and more capable than others . Specially when that person cannot understand why some people are more concerned wasting their time on stupid things .In short being stupid in the days of explosion of knowledge and the internet already being taken for granted is not only unacceptable but unforgivable. Guess where Seung Jo’s arrogance’s is coming from .
Coldness also comes in many forms .Frigid cold ? Thawing cold ? Refrigeration cold ? You get the idea that even coldness varies . Or one can be dead cold as in lacking physical warmth (read : lack of affection) and enthusiasm . Do you remember how distant Seung Jo responds to his Mom ? Or how unenthusiastic he relate to his classmates? Coldness can also be felt when a person does not show emotion , he is unmoved and is passionless . Seung Jo’s eyes are dead –because you don’t see warmth there , no fire nor interest . Did you see his reaction to the love letter that HaNi gave him that he returned ? Does Seung Jo now give you the chill ?
Seung Jo’s character is not given to the audience in a Big Bang . You see his character unfolding . The viewer must be ready to pay attention to details. You see the way Seung Jo sighs to express his exasperation over inane matters . You see his conceit the way he uses his fingers to command attention. His eyes speak a thousand words –“if only my looks can kill you’ll be dead by now” –a dialogue is no longer needed. His smirk says “don’t mess with me ,you are going to be in deep trouble”. Hands eternally kept in his pockets makes his social space restricted, “I’m not within your grasp”. His voice tells you “I’m in control. I am authoritative in whatever I say.” His complacent walk say “I don’t care.” Facial expressions matching the non verbalized character traits are priceless .
And yet the audience is treated to his rare smiles ,smiles that are actually more amused at HaNi’s antics than becoming soft and a changed person in this early point of the drama .Don’t worry , it’s only us audience who are seeing him smile . HaNi does not see him smile , his schoolmates do not see him smile, his own parents do not see him smile, either . You see, we , the audience is so privileged in dramas.
I like that Hyun joong is not forcing his character Seung Jo to us in Mischievous Kiss. He is letting us get to know him and feel him slowly with our hearts. I am savoring the subtle cues , even the sudden outbursts , the momentary and fleeting gentleness and then the return to frigid territory all over again that Hyun Joong has ably mastered .
I look forward to the wonderful pleasure of viewing the coming episodes in this drama . It is a human drama of young love and relationships , of change and prospects for a planned future. Though it came originally from a manga it has been transformed for the third time into a breathing ,living story of our lives .
Required fields are marked *
287 noi
October 17, 2010 at 7:56 AM
it's late, i know, but i lol @ this post. you two are freaking hilarious. and what's that about abba and dancing queen? see that girl~ watch that scene~ diggin' the dancing queen~ omoo, i feel like i'm going to play that song in my playlist. jb and gf hwaiting! xD
Required fields are marked *
288 candy
December 11, 2010 at 8:29 PM
go........gumiho..............i like
Required fields are marked *