City Hall: Episode 4
by samsooki
(written by Samsooki, editing, layout, design and tireless efforts by 0timelost, cleown, and mead33)
City Hall: Episode 4 – Who Will Be Inju City’s Miss Baendaengi 2009?
Episode 4 begins with the Baendaengi contestants working on a Habitat for Humanity type of project for an old woman – another one of Mi Rae’s ideas. Smelling a good photo opportunity, Mayor Go Boo Shil comes to visit. An anxious Mi Rae tries to hide from the Mayor so as not to get into trouble. But of course, she is discovered… hiding behind the floor mat covering wrapped around Jo Gook’s extremely long legs. No harm no foul, however, just confirmation that one of the Baendaengis is not like the others.
That afternoon, Boo Jung Han, the incumbent National Assembly member throws a dinner for all the Baendaengis. After dinner, Mi Rae drops by the project home to bring leftovers to the old lady and to finish up the wallpapering, but finds Jung Do and fellow handyman Yang there instead. Together, the three of them finish the job late into the evening, laughing and chatting away. As Jung Do takes trash outside, he sees Jo Gook’s car stopped outside of the house. Jo Gook is inside the car, watching, with a very pensive and somewhat sullen look on his face.
Jo Gook looks like a hungry child watching other people eat. After being spotted by Jung Do, Jo Gook drives away. What is the story here? What was Jo Gook doing there?
Early the following morning, it is final preparation time for the Miss Baendaengi finals, and Mi Rae is nowhere to be found. Jo Gook is not surprised to find that Mi Rae has violated the contest rules by not returning to the hotel after the dinner. Mi Rae then runs in, explaining that she had to finish all of the work that the other Baendaengis did not finish. It is an adequate explanation…
Not to Jo Gook, however, who coldly disqualifies Mi Rae from the competition. Mi Rae is stunned, hurt and humiliated, with a heart-breaking-ly cute smile frozen on her face. Jung Do is also stunned – he SAW Jo Gook watching them work the night before. Why is Jo Gook acting this way?
Jo Gook then gives Mi Rae some advice on how the game of life is played. Mi Rae broke the rules, and the rules are there to be kept. (This is a lesson on life that I think that Jo Gook is giving sincerely, although from all manner of appearances, this is an extremely harsh outcome.)
In any case, Jung Do has had enough of Jo Gook waltzing in and out of the contest, and promptly announces that he should also be fired since he was there too helping with the wallpapering. Jo Gook is incredulous, but now he has to run the pageant by himself.
As Mi Rae leaves the hotel, Jung Do is waiting for Mi Rae outside the hotel. Jung Do tries to console Mi Rae, and gives her a little insight into Jo Gook’s history. It seems that Jo Gook was the best at everything at the academy – studying, sports, and even in tango dancing. It appears that Jung Do and Jo Gook have had a long past together.
Jung Do even mentions to Mi Rae that if Jo Gook tried hard enough to remember, he would remember a certain special night that he and Jung Do spent together. Special night? Mi Rae perks up at the mention of a special night that Jung Do and Jo Gook had spent together, and her imagination goes wild… cue the Spanish music!
Meanwhile, as Mi Rae is day-dreaming of hugging-crying men in robes, back at the Mayor’s office, a call comes through from the National Ministry of Gender Equality! The Mayor receives another shock when he hears that the Minister’s deepest regret is not being able to participate in a beauty contest. She is proud that Shin Mi Rae is competing in the contest! The Minister’s encouragement of Shin Mi Rae is pointed and the meaning is obvious.
At the hotel, the Baendaengis are preparing for their evening gown walkthroughs, and Mi Rae is of course not there. The Mayor is outraged at Jo Gook’s dismissal of Mi Rae and demands that she is to be brought back at once!
Outside, Jo Gook calls his friend to thank him for getting the Minister of Gender Equality to make the phone call. Hey… what? Jo Gook planned to bring Mi Rae back in after all! Then why did he humiliate her and dismiss her in the first place? Why go through all that effort if he was going to bring her back in anyway? (Note: we had pages and pages of debate over why Jo Gook dismisses Mi Rae, while all along planning to bring her back by getting the National Minister of Gender Equality to call the Mayor. Literally, each of us had different notions as to why Jo Gook did what he did. In the end, none of our interpretations made the episode recap, mostly because I felt that all of our viewpoints were valid and therefore we had no consensus. What do you guys think? Why did Jo Gook dismiss Mi Rae in the first place?)
Now, he just has to get Mi Rae to come back…
Well, that’s one way.
Finally, it is time for a mini-showdown between Shin Mi Rae and Jo Gook. And this scene is brilliant. Jo Gook tells Mi Rae that she can get back into the contest, but doesn’t apologize for his harsh dismissal. This sets Mi Rae off, turning her into Kim Sam Soon, yelling at Jo Gook, whom is taken down a million pegs, and is speechless. Somewhere, Binnie is smiling.
But then Mi Rae abruptly stops yelling as she has said what needed to be said to wipe the smugness from Jo Gook’s face. She’s a kind-hearted person, after all! Classic scene.
Mi Rae runs back to the hotel / convention center. Shin Mi Rae is back in the contest! It is now time for the pageant, and the crowds are out in force.
It is time for the talent competition, and with the other Baendaengis’ mediocre, Mi Rae is in the mood for tango to wow the audience.
(Shin Mi Rae looks soooooo good here… standing in front of a Jo Gook, holding a rose out to him.)
Which leads to this:
Now comes the final decision… and Mi Rae makes it into the final two. And who will take it? Which Baendaengi will reign as the First Miss Baendaengi of Inju City?
Yes, Shin Mi Rae is Inju City’s Miss Baendaengi!!! Being the ungracious loser, the runner-up accuses Mi Rae of spending the night with several pageant officials. Mi Rae is at a loss. She acknowledges that this is true, but it was only to help put together the contest and make it a success. But, if her actions were to give the contest a bad name, she willingly gives up the title. But as she sticks out her hand to give up the trophy, Mi Rae collapses from exhaustion!
And Jo Gook comes to the rescue! Hilarious and triumphant! And for once, I am happy to the see the “carry the sick girl on back” routine, even though medically speaking, it probably is a terrible idea to carry a sick person like that. Jo Gook’s weak back seems to be holding up well – the potential severity of the collapse has turned Jo Gook into a superhero! (But did Mi Rae really faint or did she feign her fainting spell to get out of a difficult situation? Clever girl if she did!)
Meanwhile, Jung Do’s working late into the night, trying to wrap up the contest, and he knows that he is going to have to tell Mi Rae that the contest was rigged, and that she will get no prize money at all.
Blissfully unaware of the problems to come, Mi Rae parties with her friends with cake, beer and the absolutely delicious looking Korean-style fried chicken. Her friends start asking her about the rumors of her and Deputy Mayor Jo Gook. Boo Mi joins the fun, noting that Mi Rae was drunk that night, and guess whose back was hurting in the morning? Boo Mi guesses that Mi Rae got Jo Gook drunk, then jumped his bones.
Mi Rae: Who was the one who jumped whom? I kept telling him that I didn’t want to, but he kept telling me to come to his room. Telling me to come after I had washed up. And as for how he hurt his back, I was taking a short nap and he lifted me up…
Mi Rae’s friends (Pandemonium as they all scream and talk all at once): Then what happened?
Not content to just tell the boring truth, Mi Rae begins weaving a tale to satisfy her audience.
Mi Rae: Then I said, “Omo, what art thou doing, sir? Oh, please don’t be like this…” His breathing started to get heavy, but then I said to him in a tragically heroic fashion, “This is as far as I can go with you, I have to go.”
Mi Rae looks around, and realizes she cannot stop there. She continues her harlequin recitation.
Mi Rae: When I said that, he grabbed me by my shoulders and spun me around, and said to me, “Do you really have that little clue, as to why I asked that you come to my room? …don’t say a word… if your words end up causing pain to my soul and to your soul, I’d rather not listen… There is only one thing I want to hear from your pretty lips…”
Boo Mi (interrupting): What was it?
Mi Rae (annoyed): Let me tell the story!!
Mi Rae: We stared into each other’s eyes for a long, long time. Thereafter, he said in a soft voice to me…
Jo Gook (in real life): You are drinking again?
Mi Rae could not be less excited to see Jo Gook, suggesting that he sits at another table, or a different bar, but Jo Gook plops right down and is ready to eat, drink, and talk. Mi Rae’s friends launch right into the questions. Any second now, and the romance story will be shown to be a mere imagination. Mi Rae has no choice left.
She must commit assault & battery against a respected Deputy Mayor by slapping him in the back of the head. Hard. Look at that hair flying and the head swinging back and forth; this is even more brutal in slow motion! For those who wished for Mi Rae to get back at Jo Gook for the King Kong comment, well, this is your revenge. *chortle*
But that’s not all. Mi Rae leaps to her feet and shouts, “WHERE DO YOU THINK YOU’RE TOUCHING?” grabbing Jo Gook’s hands and motions that he was stroking her thighs.
Jo Gook is understandably, shocked.
With that Mi Rae storms out. And as she hoped, Jo Gook chases after her for explanation. Mi Rae’s attempt to hide behind a sign fails.
Mi Rae: You know… (about the hitting on the head), well, you see, there were rumors about us, dating and all. (Jo Gook looks shocked) Well, of course, I was the one who started those rumors.
Jo Gook: What?!!
Mi Rae: Well, anyway, things got all twisted and then you showed up, and the only method I had to stop you from talking was that. It was either that or (starts making kissy faces) you know… in dramas, in order to stop people from talking. But what I did was better, right?
Mi Rae notices her friends peeking, and so she starts being rough again, grabbing Jo Gook by the lapels and threatening him.
But Jo Gook is not to be outfoxed by Mi Rae again. He grabs her before she gets away, and now Shin Mi Rae is pleading with her eyes not to make her look like a fool in front of her friends. And Jo Gook, with all the power, laughs and notes that Mi Rae said there was one method that dramas use to stop people from talking, right? And then…
COMMENTS
*CHEER* Finally! This is more like it. The Kim Sun Ah that we all know and love, back to her old bag of tricks, being so cute and beautiful in one moment, a tragic heroine with unbelievable heart and integrity in the next moment, and finally a comic genius in the final moment, making me smile so much that my cheeks hurt. What a fun episode. Fun, cheery, delightful to watch.
And what’s more, the tenor of series has definitely changed. City Hall started to turn substantial as characters are beginning to be fleshed out. We are still missing an over-arching story line, but at least now we have our main characters and the chemistry between the two is just wonderful to watch. It was like the City Hall writers decided to get serious. A light bulb went off, and they figured out how to go from the chaotic introductory episodes to an episode befitting a romantic comedy drama with Kim Sun Ah and Cha Seung Won.
On the other hand, where do we go from here? The lack of a concrete over-arching story line is glaring now that the Miss Baendaengi Contest is over. The one negative for the drama series so far is that the chaotic whirlwind of the first four episodes has run its course and in its wake, it is difficult to find something to hold onto, amid the fun-filled debris strewn about. I feel like the main story for City Hall has YET to show itself, which means that Episodes 1-4 are not the sum total of the Introduction. And in a 20 episode series, a good 20-25% of the show has passed and we still don’t really know what the series is about yet. If there is criticism to be given, it is that.
THE ONE TO WATCH FOR IN THIS EPISODE: Isn’t it obvious? Kim Sun Ah!
I was beginning to wonder when we would see the real Kim Sun Ah with her brilliant comic timing, her soul-rending stares, and her perky, never-say-die attitude. Well, it took a few episodes, but Shin Mi Rae officially rocks. Just love her to pieces.
On To Episode 5!
RELATED POSTS
Tags: Cha Seung-won, City Hall, Kim Sun-ah
Interview with Kim Yoo-jung
Hello Dramabeans series
![[2022 Year in Review] The Bean Count](https://www.dramabeans.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/11/beancount_2022.png)
Required fields are marked *
Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *
51 Malomars
July 15, 2009 at 3:38 AM
Your recaps are so funny! Just as good as the real thing!
:D
Anyway, been thinking about your musings on Jo Guk,
and it feels to me that it's the whole character that's conflicted.
Looking the part of the tall, dark, suave player with everything he wants in the world, money, power, status, great girlfriend.
BUT.
Under the surface, he's this abandoned illegitimate kid who'll never be certain of his place in society. And power can smile on him (though his father won't) but it can look away on a whim.
The only person he thinks is stable, (haha way to misplace trust,but it's a father-complex, so hey) is his natural father. And everyone else, he switches back and forth on. Give-take away, so they can't ever rely on him. Just like his father behaved to him, he's internalized.
Anyway, it'll be fun to see him NOT get to play that "fooled you, fool!" switcheroo, if he wants to build up trust on his own.
Required fields are marked *
52 MinT
July 15, 2009 at 8:37 AM
Thank You for the recaps.
I love reading about the drama recaps after I watched it cuz it point out all the missing puzzle that I miss.
Thank you @9 love that scene too lol
This was a fun and turning point episode for me.
Can't wait for the other recaps.
Fighting Samsooki recaps team!
Required fields are marked *
53 ockoala
July 15, 2009 at 9:26 AM
@49 birdscout
I'll be more than happy to connect the 2 "hand scenes" at the appropriate time, but I think Samsookie may reference it. Either way, don't worry, you'll be informed and can enjoy the cuteness of it.
Speaking of spoilers, I personally love reading them as I find myself still able to fully enjoy a moment regardless of being spoiled. However, I totally respect the need to keep others from being inadvertently spoiled by comments from someone who has seen it, so I am glad Samsookie has reminded us all of this courtesy.
At the end of eps. 4, Jo Gook and Mirae's scenes have gone from a small spark to a light sizzle, and the smells coming from that pot are mouthwatering, Chemistry, my god, how do 2 people have so much chemistry. Everytime JG looks at MR, I want to scream, just kiss her already, dude, you know you want to.
Required fields are marked *
54 Samsooki
July 15, 2009 at 10:17 AM
@53 ockoala -
"I’ll be more than happy to connect the 2 “hand scenes” at the appropriate time, but I think Samsookie may reference it."
This will be among the last comments I make about the mechanics of how we recap. When we recap, we try to stay true to the feelings that we feel when we are watching the episode. Since our recaps are done as if we are watching this for the first time, when I am writing, I really try to just focus on what I see and how I feel when I am watching.
At the time of our (and my) watching to recap, the nehgayo-yehgayo part was amusing, but it was duplicative of the overall scene to put it in there.
As for future recaps, I guess we'll just have to see. :)
Required fields are marked *
55 ockoala
July 15, 2009 at 11:06 AM
Samsooki
"As for future recaps, I guess we’ll just have to see"
Image of little puppy panting, front paws in the air, head cocked to the side quizzically - waiting, waiting.....oh mighty lord and master of City Hall recaps. I await with baited breath each new recap, reading it is like watching it with a best buddy and getting their take of the show and having an added layer of fun. Thanks!
Required fields are marked *
56 alodia
July 16, 2009 at 8:10 AM
I've read this when it was up but i only managed to write comments today. Though late, I won't let this episode pass since it's the episode when I fall in love with City Hall.
Yes, it may not still be great, but this is the episode when there's no turning back for me. My seatbelt was fastened. No matter what will happen I am ready for the ride.
-----
I was privileged to take a peek at one of their drafts for ep4. I never thought I would still enjoy it this much. Again (and again and again) thank you to the entire recap team! City hall team, as always, is the best!
@47langdon813
Same here... from this point on, they're all my favorite episodes as well... though there may be 2 or 3 episodes that would stand out, from this point forward, there will always be something great, new and worth pondering on on every episode.
@49 birdscout
"You have outdone yourselves with this recap of episode 4! Each recap gets better and better!"
- Well, each episode gets better and better. It's great that the recap team is complementing the feeling you got when you watch the series!
@Samsooki
"Since our recaps are done as if we are watching this for the first time, when I am writing, I really try to just focus on what I see and how I feel when I am watching."
- That's why I'm loving the recaps more and more... but you have to admit you were able to highlight a lot of good points that the casual viewer might have missed out because you know the future episodes. :P But really, how were you able to mute the future episodes? You never slipped any spoilers nor cues. You guys are just awesome!
@cleown
The gif was really a very smart idea! I don't know whose idea it was but I see it's you who created the gif. That is very cool!!!
Required fields are marked *
57 alodia
July 16, 2009 at 8:16 AM
My two cents (i forgot since i've read this days ago, i though the questions raised were for ep5.. kekeke)
"But did Mi Rae really faint or did she feign her fainting spell to get out of a difficult situation? Clever girl if she did!"
- Mi Rae feigned her fainting. Else, how can she smile that way while on Jo Guk's back. smart girl indeed!
"What do you guys think? Why did Jo Gook dismiss Mi Rae in the first place?"
- I think he dismissed her to make her look more pitiful. At the same time so that it will appear that he doesn't have anything to do with her winning the contest. No one will suspect him 'rigging' the contest himself since it was clear to everyone that he's the one who dismissed Mi Rae (plus he's the one reprimanded by the Mayor for dismissing Mi Rae). Genius guy! Not even the very observant Jung Do would suspect that it was his doings that made Mi Rae win.
Required fields are marked *
58 samsooki
July 16, 2009 at 8:39 AM
Hmmmmmm...
I am definitely in the minority here, but I believe she actually fainted.
Three nights before, she was up all night creating the program and coordination. Two days before, she spent the day on the boat actually working hard while everybody else was just sitting on the boat. One day before the contest, she was working hard all day on the house. Then, the night before, she went to the house again to finish it. Then the morning of the contest, she got kicked out of the contest, and she was extremely sad. Then she got brought back in at the last moment. She has been pulling double, triple duty:
1. helping create the entire program with JG
2. learning the dance routines in half the time that the other contestants got, because she had other things to do.
3. still participating in all of the Baendaengi activities
That, plus the emotions of having to give up the crown because of unjust accusations, overcoming the unjust accusations, the poor sportsmanship of the other contestants, being kicked out and brought back in, the rush of being the winner, all of her hard work and determination, everything was just overwhelming.
I think she actually collapsed from all the emotions and stress.
I think that when she awoke, and realized she had held onto the crown, she was happy, and smiled. I think it looked like she was smirking, but I think she was just happy. She was being carried by Jo Gook, and she held onto her crown.
:)
Required fields are marked *
59 LadyIgraine
July 16, 2009 at 10:34 AM
I about just died when Mirae had her wild imagination of the two in bed together...
Required fields are marked *
60 dare
July 16, 2009 at 9:24 PM
"THE ONE TO WATCH FOR IN THIS EPISODE: Isn’t it obvious? Kim Sun Ah!"
Welll said!! It was definitely in this ep that I remember why I love Kim sun ah so much
Required fields are marked *
61 cheonsa
July 17, 2009 at 4:32 PM
Great recapping, gang! Your very visual style of writing made me laugh at the scenes you've described all over again!
My take on Mi Rae's fainting is that she faked it. She collapsed at the precise moment that the runner up went for the tiara and it was hilarious watching her try to wrench it from Mi Rae's grip!
And as she was being carried on Gook's back, she did open her eyes and smile, like she knew she managed to pull it off and hold on to her tiara because she didn't really want to give up the title. Then she blissfully settled her head on his back.
On a side note, I've loved Cha Seung-Won since his "Bodyguard" days. He looks so different in CH ... but still sooooo hot!
Required fields are marked *
62 mtoenlob
July 21, 2009 at 2:57 AM
Your recap, as usual, is so engaging. Thank you. And the comments, boy, it sure pays to read all of them. Very enlightening. The different opinions shared were very informative. That's what attracted me to this drama, it makes the viewers THINK. You just don't sit back and watch the story unfolds in front of you. You participate with what's going on. City Hall takes you in and lets you experience the various emotions as the story develops - you become one with the characters - you feel with them, you think with them, you are one of them.
I particularly love this episode. This is where the real Kim Sun Ah stood out; the Kim Sun Ah whom everyone loves. This episode is a showcase of her many talents. Her artistic abilities come to the fore here - her brilliant comic timing as shown in the restaurant scene, her musicality with her tango scene and acting skills in that return-to-the-pageant scene. I love that particular scene when she let go a mouthful of tirade to Jo Gook who was caught in surprise and left dumbfounded. She was firing out at Jo Gook in quick successions non-stop and in a matter of second made a complete turn around. Love it! The look on Jo Gook's bewildered face was priceless. And that cucumber scene which I find so hilarious. What makes this episode more impressive is Jo Gook's remarkable performance. These two matches up - talent for talent. Another factor why I was enthralled by this drama. The cast is awesome.
And the chemistry between the main leads - electrifying. Sparks flew in that tango scene. Those exchange of glances, the mesmerizing gaze sent quivers of excitement. Never have I seen such attraction between leads. Another reason for this drama's appeal is its ability to captivate the viewers.
Required fields are marked *
birdscout
March 3, 2014 at 6:47 AM
Five years later, I've started another rewatch of City Hall, and a proper rewatch is incomplete without samsooki's recaps, for me.
So many lol scenes in ep.4, including the cucumber scene. What I noticed this time:JG takes two bites of the cucumber plain. But, before his third bite, MR motions for him to dip it in the gochujang sauce. On the third bite with the gochujang, he stops chewing for a split second as he thinks back that the first two "plain" bites had a hint of gochujang taste. This scene is so quick I've missed it before, but it had me laughing this time. Makes me wonder if CSW was actually eating the same cucumber that KSA licked, or if they switched it out for a new piece.
City Hall has so much to offer the repeat viewer!
Required fields are marked *
63 Jane
July 26, 2009 at 4:15 PM
Even though I watched the show anyway, I still enjoy reading your recaps-- probably because I love the show in general, haha.
But please update!? You were doing so well with Episodes 1~4 and then you stopped..
Required fields are marked *
64 ockoala
July 27, 2009 at 9:12 AM
@63 Jane
Recaps as of Monday July 27, 2009, are up to Episode 8 for City Hall. Javabeans has not linked them to her recaps page, but if you go to the main page and start scrolling backwards to older posts, you'll find the recap for Episode 8, snd if you scroll down, at the end of the main recap, you'll find links to all earlier 7 episode recaps.
Please don't miss it, Samsooki's recaps are increasing in depth and complexity just like each City Hall episode being recapped, as the action gets more intense and heartrending, sooooo good, a treat in and of itself.
Required fields are marked *
65 Fafa
December 24, 2010 at 10:03 AM
I love Kim Sun Ah. she is the master of comedy.
Required fields are marked *
66 Lovers
February 3, 2011 at 1:44 AM
I like Tango dance scene in eps. 4.
so sweet....
Required fields are marked *
67 iamdeb
November 13, 2012 at 10:51 AM
thanks so much for recapping this drama. I'd heard recommendations here and there for awhile and finally checked it out...I'm in LOVE like I haven't been with k-dramas in awhile. I've watched and dropped so many after the first few k-dramas because I was bored with the cliches but this is just a fun, wonderful journey so far. I'm so happy to hear it gets even better!
Required fields are marked *